Image placeholder

Celebrating Inspirational People Advancing Gender Equality in Extractives

Image placeholder

For Every Law, a Plan: Overcoming Implementation Gaps to Realize Gender Equality in the Extractive Sector

Image placeholder

Why Extractive Industry Gender Advocates Should Ask For Contract Transparency

Image placeholder

New Film: Women Ensure Sierra Leone’s Government Progresses on Gender Equity in Mining

Image placeholder

Women in Mining: A History of Legal Invisibility and Exclusion

Image placeholder

Inclusive Extractives Governance Depends on Elusive Gender-Disaggregated Data

This is the second in a series of posts from the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) and World Resources Institute (WRI) research project on gender and extractives, carried out with support from the Open Government Partnership Multi Donor Trust Fund, which is managed by the World Bank. Learn more about the project in this blog post.

As the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) and World Resources Institute (WRI) continue our research on gender, open government and extractives, we often find ourselves frustrated by a lack of relevant data and policies. While many countries are making commitments to gender equity, without this data, countries often develop policies that don’t account for the unique experiences and needs of men, women, boys and girls. Governments are working to address labor biases, create diversification strategies that are gender-inclusive, build inclusive tender practices, create enhanced environmental monitoring and develop gender responsive revenue management. However, without data disaggregation, it’s difficult to know who is participating and to hold governments accountable.

In Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men, a bestselling book that won the 2019 Financial Times and McKinsey Business Book of the Year Award, author Caroline Criado-Perez explains the pervasive absence of gender-segregated data, and its consequences: Criado-Perez writes that this gendered data gap is not necessarily malicious or even deliberate, but instead results from assuming that women and men experience life in similar ways, when they so often don’t.

As has become apparent in natural resource extraction, oil, gas, and mining projects can impact people differently, often due to their gender or other identities. Oxfam Australia recently published a report on the various ways in which natural resource extraction can differently impact women and men’s lives and livelihoods. Their findings reveal that these projects can inadvertently reinforce existing power structures, disrupt the ways that women have traditionally earned their livelihoods or make physical spaces more dangerous for women. Unfortunately, the Oxfam report is rare;

In surveying the laws, policies, regulations and guidelines governing the extractive sectors of 12 countries, our team found that most extractive governance documents are gender-blind. In our sample, only 25 documents that directly govern extractive activity mention “women” or “gender.” These mentions were more likely to appear in guidelines—the least binding form of documentation—than in laws, policies or regulations. In most countries it is faster and easier to pass guidelines than it is to create or amend laws, policies or regulations. Developing guidelines may lead to faster and nominally better consideration of gender. However, government actors and regulators may interpret guidelines as suggestions rather than mandates to which they must adhere, thus negating their potential impact.

While our research uncovered very few documents that referenced gender, we notice some trends from this small sample:

From “women” to “gender”

In analyzing these 25 documents, we found that over time the language that countries use to describe their efforts to address differentiated outcomes is shifting. Although references were scant, documents adopted from before 2011 more often used the term “women.” While “women” continued to be the more commonly-used term, in documents from 2011 to 2020, “gender” is used with increasing frequency (though the term is most often used simply as a substitute for “women”). While it’s not possible to draw definitive conclusions from this small sample, it seems that documents that use “gender” are more likely to also focus on participation and environmental and social impacts.

Mentions of “women” and “gender”

Gender considerations in legal and policy documents are becoming more common

From the countries that we surveyed, the earliest document that governs the extractive sector and mentions women is a 1993 Ghanaian law that implements a quota for women’s participation on the board of the country’s minerals commission. But it would be some time before other countries followed suit. Most only began to adopt extractive documents that make reference to women or gender in the 2000s. In fact, 20 out of the 25 documents that we found were only adopted in the last ten years.

It seems that consideration of women and gender in extractive governance documents is a relatively recent trend, but one that will continue. In 2019, the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) adopted new gender-responsive requirements that mandate certain data disclosures around gender. This may prompt officials in more countries to begin thinking about the varied ways that extractive industries impact diverse groups of citizens and reflect this in policies and guiding documents. However, policymakers and legislators must match an increase in the number of references to gender issues with an increase in the quality of provisions in legal and policy frameworks. We found that references rarely reflect a thorough examination or understanding of gender issues; some were overly simplistic and potentially reinforced stereotypical views of women. We will examine this further in our future research, diving deep into three countries’ experiences.

As countries implement these policies with increasing frequency, it will be important to know which laws, policies, regulations and guidelines achieve their intended effect and which fail or cause further harm. Unfortunately, much of the data that we have about the differentiated impact of extractive projects is anecdotal. As in the industries that Criado-Perez highlights in her book, there is little disaggregated data available about the sector’s gendered affects, and it is difficult to collect enough data to draw conclusions based on the few laws, policies, regulations and guidelines currently in place. As we develop recommendations and work with governments on building Open Government Partnership commitments that lead to gender-transformative extractive governance, we will emphasize the need for data collection and disaggregation, working with changemakers to build understanding of how they can collect and use this data to benefit their countries’ development.

Aubrey Menard is a consultant gender advisor with the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI).

Photo by Suthep Kritsanavarin for NRGI.

Image placeholder

How Can Extractive Sector Laws and Policies Contribute to Gender Equality?

Image placeholder

Learning from and Using Country Practice to Inform Open Government Partnership Gender Initiatives

There’s ample evidence that natural resource extraction has gendered impacts.

From gender balance of people employed in extraction companies to environmental impacts, women tend to absorb more of the costs of extraction. They have less access to the benefits. At the Natural Resource Governance Institute and World Resources Institute, we suspect that even our organizations' resource governance responses, from fiscal rules to transparency standards, might have gendered impacts because of who has been able to participate, how information has been shared and what types of economic factors are prioritized.

That is why it is so surprising there are no gendered natural resource commitments in any Open Government Partnership National Action Plan.

We are excited to be in Ottawa this week at the Open Government Partnership Global Summit to work toward addressing the lack of commitments. There will be a number of discussions about what a feminist open government can look like and how countries might be able to craft commitments that respond to specific natural resource challenges in a gender informed way. It is an important moment for change—there is high-level support from national governments, leading civil society organizations and industry trend-setters.

The OGP community might be able to learn a lot from what is already happening at the national level. Innovators and gender champions in many resource-rich countries have already started creating policies to respond to some of the gendered challenges of managing natural resources. These can range from broad policy commitments in the Africa Mining Vision to detailed regulations in the Mexican rules for creating social and environmental impact assessments. Country level innovation has not yet been connected to global initiatives, making it difficult for interested change-makers to learn from what different countries have tried, as well as the impact of those policies.

NRGI, in partnership with the World Resources Institute, is excited to launch a research project generously funded by the OGP Multi-Donor Trust Fund. The project aims to gather and learn from these national practices to inform and support national OGP working groups. The research will include three phases:

  • Collect, analyze and share practice. Analyzing current gender and extractive policy practice will create a starting point of discussion on how countries are actually approaching gendered natural resource governance and provide practical options going forward.
  • Understand gaps between policy and implementation. We will focus on three to four countries to more deeply understand which actors must be involved and what types of policies drive implementation.
  • Leverage multiple networks for broader, more transformative change. We will gather key government, industry and civil society players to share experiences, and discuss how to leverage the OGP to better amplify national commitments and strengthen peer learning through webinars and knowledge tools.
Join us

This project provides a bridge between natural resource governance and gender communities inside and outside the OGP. We think this project is going to be most successful if we can be joined by civil society, institutions and government officials as we collect examples, discuss priorities and foster opportunities to influence and create exciting new reforms that meet the needs of everyone.

Rebecca Iwerks is the capacity development director at the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI). Elizabeth Moses is an associate with the Environmental Democracy Practice at the World Resources Institute (WRI).

For more information or to share your country experience, please contact Rebecca Iwerks at riwerks@resourcegovernance.org or Elizabeth Moses at emoses@wri.org.
 
Image placeholder

Contract, Environment, Gender, Project and Commodity Sales Data Among New Disclosure Requirements of Strengthened EITI

Major enhancements of the global norms governing transparency in natural resources are afoot. As the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) international board meeting in Kyiv concludes today, board members representing governments, companies and civil society actors have just broadly agreed upon historic revisions to the EITI Standard, which sets out norms for the disclosure of oil, gas and mining data and is implemented by over 50 countries. The revised EITI Standard now being finalized will be ratified at the EITI Global Conference in June.

In the run-up to Kyiv, we at NRGI have been doing analytical work, advocating and negotiating for improvements on several important issues, each detailed below. Our efforts on many of these topics have been underway for several years, working alongside partner organizations like Publish What You Pay, the EITI International Secretariat, Oxfam, Global Witness, and numerous civil society organizations and government reformers in the resource-rich countries where we work.   

Progress on these issues helps ensure that EITI remains relevant as a global standard for extractives transparency and reflects emerging best practices in implementing countries. More importantly, these improvements move EITI several steps closer to helping countries improve natural resource governance, improving company practices, and enabling citizens to demand accountability for the management of public resources.

The true impact of these revisions will depend on the strength of their implementation among the governments, companies, and civil society actors that lead EITI processes, and on whether the new information unlocked by these improvements is actually used to inform stronger policy-making on natural resources.

Contract transparency

The EITI Standard will now require the publication of contracts and licenses that are granted, entered into or amended from 1 January 2021. The initiative continues to encourage disclosure of all contracts and licenses, regardless of when signed. Contracts and licenses are vitally important documents that lie at the heart of the legal framework governing extractive processes, and are therefore at the core of EITI reporting. Thirty-one of 51 EITI implementing countries have already disclosed at least some contracts and 24 already have laws requiring disclosure. The practice is also required by the IFC, MIGA and EBRD; and has been endorsed by the IMF, UN, International Bar Association, the B-Team, the OECD the ICMM and IPIECA. By joining ranks with these leading institutions, EITI has taken a major step forward and comes into alignment with global norms.

Project-level payment transparency

After several years of stagnation, the EITI’s project-level reporting requirement will now be proactively implemented by companies and governments. The EITI Standard will now provide clarity around the precise definition of “project” that all EITI countries will use for reporting on fiscal years ending on or after 31 December 2018. This form of reporting provides critical and relevant information to local communities, governments and investors, and enables companies to demonstrate their economic contributions in relation to specific projects and affected communities. EITI’s new definition of “project” will be based on the contract or other legal agreement between a government and company, as recently endorsed by the IMF as a global norm. Helpfully, the definition will also be in line with the European Union’s extractives transparency law (Chapter 10 of the EU Accounting Directive), which will facilitate harmonization across payment disclosures. Through such mandatory disclosure laws in the European Union, Canada and Norway extractive companies have already reported on over USD 500 billion at the project level around the world. Today’s board decision will lead to a huge increase in project-level data and ensure that companies will report such data across the 51 EITI countries. It is now essential that key countries such as Australia and the United States (neither of which implements the EITI Standard or mandatory disclosure laws) get on board with this form of reporting.

Environmental reporting

The EITI Standard will now require companies to disclose material payments to governments that are related to the environment and are mandated by law, regulation or contract. The standard will also encourage implementing countries to disclose information on the management and monitoring of environmental impacts of extraction.

Environmental issues are central to meaningful public debates on natural resource governance. Given that the purpose of EITI is to help facilitate and inform such debates in implementing countries, these new disclosures represent critical improvements to the EITI Standard. Prior to this week’s agreement, the EITI Standard did not include any reference to the environment. However, over half of EITI countries have already included environmental issues as part of their EITI reporting. These new revisions will help increase levels of environmental information available to accountability actors in resource-rich countries.

Gender

The EITI Standard will now require employment data disclosures to be disaggregated by gender and, when available, by company and occupational level. For extractives to benefit everyone, it is essential that everyone involved more proactively consider how extraction and good resource governance can result in gender equity. In that vein, the EITI Standard now also requires constituencies to consider gender when selecting participants to their national multi-stakeholder group and when planning how to disseminate their data. With these groundbreaking measures, the EITI standard has set a minimum expectation of gender integration while also leaving room for countries to continue to innovate on ways to incorporate gender into their national EITI implementation to ensure that everyone can benefit from extraction.

Commodity trading transparency

The sale of oil, gas and minerals by governments and state-owned enterprises (SOEs) to commodity traders is a critical source of income—in Nigeria and Iraq, for example, these sales constitute the governments’ largest revenue source. At the same time, these commodity sales are often opaque and prone to corruption and mismanagement. Revisions to the EITI Standard agreed today will shed important new light on these high-value transactions. Crucially, today’s breakthrough on project-level reporting will also be applied to the sale of commodities, meaning that disclosure must take place at the level of the sales contract entered into between a trading company and the government (or the SOE) selling the commodity. The EITI board also decided that final language tackling the important issue of sale-by-sale disclosure still needs to be agreed.

The new revisions on trading also include important new encouragements in the EITI standard related to the role of state-appointed marketing companies, resource-backed loans, product swap arrangements, the process for selecting buyers and disclosure of the sales agreements themselves. While the revisions agreed fall short of requiring trading companies themselves to disclose (the board agreed only to encourage traders to disclose, while it is a requirement for governments and SOEs to do so), a number of companies including Trafigura and Glencore have begun to unilaterally disclose their payments to purchase commodities, and the governments of major trading hubs including the U.K. and Switzerland have resolved to improve company transparency in this area through work at the OECD. Given their size, it is also clear that these transactions should be included in existing mandatory payment disclosure laws, an approach which has also been endorsed by the IMF.   

Other improvements

The revisions to the EITI Standard will also include improvements on a number of other critical issues. The standard will require disclosing entities to disaggregate production and export data at the company and project level. The revisions also include major improvements regarding state-owned enterprises (SOEs). The current requirement that EITI reports include an explanation of the role of and rules governing SOEs in the sector will now need to include disclosures of transfers, retained earnings, reinvestment and third-party financing related to SOE joint ventures and subsidiaries. SOEs will now be expected to publicly disclose their audited financial statements. And EITI countries will be encouraged to describe the rules and practices related to SOEs’ operating and capital expenditures, procurement, subcontracting and corporate governance. On open data, the standard will now require implementing countries to complete summary data files for each fiscal year, and essential step towards facilitating accurate use of EITI data.

Looking forward

The EITI itself still has room to grow. In Kyiv, we signaled that broader transparency regarding climate risks and energy transition issues, as well as increased focus on anticorruption and state capture in EITI’s principles and norms would be central to the initiative’s strategic direction and future policy relevance. The new EITI Standard will be ratified in June along with the installation of a new EITI board. These issues will represent important topics for future consideration by that newly constituted body, as the EITI charts its next steps.

Image placeholder

An Opportunity to Walk the Talk: Making Gender Disclosure Part of the EITI Standard

This blog post was also released on the Environmental Governance Programme (EGP) for Sustainable Natural Resource Management blog.

There are many questions and good intentions floating around to address gender and extractives. We know that women are more likely to be negatively impacted by extraction than men. What can be done as a policy response is often less evident.

IISD Economic and Law Policy Program International Law Advisor Suzy Nikièma (center) and environment and social governance expert Sohinee Mazumdar lead a working group of delegates at the IGF Global Forum. Photo by IISD Reporting Services Digital Manager Diego Noguera.

Last fall, UNDP and the Intergovernmental Forum on Mining, Minerals, Metals, and Sustainable Development hosted a discussion exploring which gender impacts of mining are most significant and most difficult to tackle. After a panel in which I and other experts dissected recent literature and good practice, the participants – 90 government officials from 40 countries – were asked to order 10 gendered impacts of mining from greatest to least important.

The results were clear. The vast majority of groups identify “lack of voice and participation in decision-making” as the top concern, followed by “access to employment and education” and “increased risk of gender-based violence.” After the survey, delegates highlighted the challenges of confronting cultural norms while attempting to craft inclusive policies. This wasn’t a room full of gender experts—this was a group of officials who mostly focus on mining but have grown to understand the importance of addressing gendered impacts of the industry.

The good news? There is an opportunity to make progress in providing countries a policy tool to respond to the gender gap in participation. In just under a month, the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative board will meet to discuss revisions to their governing standard, including gender provisions.

EITI has long been a tool to level the playing field and create room for participation in decision-making for unlikely actors. EITI, a multi-stakeholder body, collects and shares information about extractive industries in 51 countries with the hope of informing better policy-making. It was originally created as a gender-neutral platform, like many international mechanisms. Before it started to explicitly address issues of gender, EITI developed an unintended bias toward having more men participate and be able to access its information. Over the past several years, the EITI board and its supporters have said that they want to make sure the initiative can be more gender-responsive.

There are important proposals before the EITI board to make strides toward addressing these challenges. The changes recommended by civil society address each aspect of EITI, from who participates, to what data is disclosed, to how the data is shared. This comprehensive approach is necessary to give advocates in EITI implementing countries the leverage to transform policy discussions. The proposal championed by civil society members of the board will enhance the EITI Standard and require:

  • Multi-stakeholder groups to consider gender when creating their membership
  • Disclosure of employment statistics disaggregated by gender
  • Commentary of whether a country conducts gender-responsive budgeting
  • Consideration of how different genders access information when creating a data dissemination strategy

These changes are not only necessary. They are relatively easy to implement. Participation in EITI stakeholder groups have often been extremely gender-skewed, with more than half of the groups having fewer than 25 percent female participation. Many countries and companies already disaggregate labor information by gender. For the last two years, Tullow Oil, BP, Shell and many private sector entities based in the U.K. published a report analyzing the pay gap between men and women working for their company. Having the information about gender breakdown in the work force is the first step for countries and companies to address the gender gap. UNWomen and others have produced recommendations on gender-responsive budgeting for over 30 years. A World Bank report six years ago drew attention to the gender gap in understanding EITI data within countries, and gave recommendations for how transparency mechanisms can share data in more gender-responsive ways.

Gender in development is an area that can often get trapped in good intentions and tokenistic responses. Making these changes a requirement for all EITI implementing countries is an opportunity for the EITI to grow from talking about gender to creating policy change that meets minimum gender norms. Some members of the EITI board have suggested that “encouraging” countries would be sufficient. For EITI to fulfill its desire to be gender relevant and to meet the needs of those in resource-rich countries, the board must respond to this important moment in making gender requirements part of the EITI Standard.

Rebecca Iwerks is the capacity development director at the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI).