Image placeholder

Life After Oil in Campeche: Youth Must Lead Alternative Paths

Image placeholder

NRGI at LCOY Mexico: Elevating Youth Voices From Oil-Dependent Regions for a Just Transition

Image placeholder

Mining Revenues Flow to Provinces and Communities in the DRC

NRGI experts provided support to Congolese civil society groups to revise the country’s mining code which has resulted in a fresh flow of revenues to provinces and local communities. 

In 2002, the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) adopted a mining code offering generous terms to investors to attract them to the country’s post-conflict environment. Investment indeed soared, but government revenues and local benefits did not—there was an urgent need to reform the code to decrease this disparity. 

In 2011, NRGI provided a grant to the civil society organization POM to reform the code. POM then led advocacy to add a mechanism mandating that a fixed percentage of mining companies’ revenues go directly to subnational governments and local communities. POM also successfully pushed for a community development fund. 

Parliament passed revisions in March 2018. The regulation was published in June 2019, and companies have begun payments to communities. The provincial governments of Haut-Katanga and Lualaba are projected to receive between USD 75 million and 225 million in annual revenue, while local communities will receive between 45 million and 157 million. Every province has received some money already. The sector head in Luilu said “With the first collections of our part of the mining royalty, we have already built some community facilities: a pediatric and a maternity ward at the Luilu Health Center, but also a well-equipped mortuary.”

Many communities still lack capacity to receive transfers, while others don’t have the infrastructure to ensure the money benefits citizens. NRGI is measuring the impact of transfers on communities and facilitating a manual to help communities budget, develop capacity and develop revenue management standards. 

Image placeholder

Fiscal Sustainability in Mongolia in 2018

Монгол »

The authors of this report analyze Mongolia’s public finance outlook and risks to the country’s economic sustainability using an advanced macro-fiscal model.

Though Mongolia’s fiscal solvency challenges seem resolved for now, the underlying problem of fiscal sustainability remains. The government continues to carry a high level of debt and is very dependent on commodity revenues. Until debt stabilizes, the authors suggest that the Mongolian government should prioritize debt reduction rather than focus on increasing the balances of the Fiscal Stability Fund and Future Heritage Fund.


They also recommend that the government continue with reforms directed at improving fiscal discipline; make budget revenue projections with more caution in order to stabilize expenditure; and continue with the current fiscal consolidation model and comply with fiscal rules in order to prepare for negative mining shocks.

Image placeholder

Reaching Wider Populations with Global Online Courses

Both the MOOC and Petronia have become key tools for building a broader and more foundational understanding of issues that are critical to good natural resource governance. 

The Challenge
 
Despite the critical relevance of natural resources to millions of peoples’ lives, most citizens of resource-rich countries have limited knowledge about how resources are governed. To address this knowledge gap, the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) developed two online training tools aimed at generating critical awareness and building technical knowledge about core resource governance issues. The first tool is a massive open online course (MOOC), “Natural Resources for Sustainable Development: The Fundamentals of Oil, Gas and Mining Governance.” The second is an online simulation called “Petronia,” named for an imaginary oil-rich country.
 
NRGI’s role
 
NRGI’s MOOC is a 12-week online course (produced in partnership with the Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment, the Sustainable Development Goals Academy and the World Bank) that provides a structured curriculum for those interested in learning about natural resource governance. Modules cover a wide range of topics, including legal and regulatory frameworks as well as environmental and social impacts. Participants audit university-quality lectures; engage in comparative analyses of their country contexts on a discussion board; pose questions then answered by faculty; and receive accreditation upon satisfactory course completion.

 

Aimed at a broader audience, Petronia is a simulated learning experience that allows online learners to explore the policy challenges of a fictional developing country that has just begun oil production. The learner joins a team of experts deployed to Petronia to advise policy-makers on a series of complex resource governance scenarios (based on models and case studies developed by NRGI experts). Learners explore various topics, including contract transparency and risk tolerance. Petronia’s animated graphics, presentation of technical content via brief conversational formats and interactive challenges are all designed to appeal to younger audiences who possess limited background knowledge of resource governance.
 
Impact
 
Within just four months of Petronia’s launch in June 2018, more than 5,000 learners have logged on, of whom nearly 400 have moved beyond the first mission. By mid-2018, more than 16,000 learners had enrolled in the MOOC.
 
These tools are reaching a wide range of learners. By providing them online at no cost, NRGI is increasing educational opportunities for learners who would be unable to attend formal in-person training. Women constitute approximately 40 percent of MOOC participants. Around 30 percent of MOOC participants originate from private sector entities (including extractive sector corporations). Online learning has been particularly successful in introducing younger people to natural resource governance issues—a majority of Petronia survey respondents fall within the 25-34 age range.
 
NRGI’s online offerings have allowed NRGI to reach individuals in over 140 countries/territories, including many places where NRGI doesn’t otherwise operate. A geoscientist from Somalia’s Ministry of Petroleum and Mineral Resources who completed the Petronia simulation remarked that “the discussed issues and options on natural resource governance has been very crucial and gave me a solid understanding of this sector.”
 
The principles of good governance that underpin the content of both the MOOC and Petronia are informing the work of other development organizations. For example, an independent expert assisting the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) used course materials to inform the development of a UNDP capacity building program on sustainable development in Central Asia.
 
The courses have also helped to raise awareness of diagnostic and analytical tools and catalyze action. After completing the MOOC, a member from Union Minière du Gabon, a private sector alliance of around 20 companies in Gabon, learned about the Resource Governance Index (RGI), an NRGI tool that measures the quality of resource governance in 81 countries. He reached out to NRGI to discuss the role of the private sector in fostering transparency and accountability in Gabon.
 
Both the MOOC and Petronia have become key tools for building a broader and more foundational understanding of issues that are critical to good natural resource governance. Diverse participants are gaining knowledge that can help them make a difference in their professional roles, or simply as informed citizens. NRGI will continue to explore how to maximize these tools’ impact as it refines both the MOOC and Petronia.

 

Image placeholder

Ghana’s Gold Mining Revenues: An Analysis of Company Disclosures

In Ghana the majority of international mining companies, including Asanko Gold, Golden Star Resources, Endeavour Mining, Kinross Gold, Perseus Mining and Xtra-Gold Resources, have disclosed payments-to-governments reports under the Extractive Sector Transparency Measures Act (ESTMA) in Canada. In addition Gold Fields, AngloGold Ashanti and Newmont Mining have made voluntary disclosures regarding the payments they make to the Ghanaian government.

With the introduction of the Extractive Sector Transparency Measures Act (ESTMA), extractive companies incorporated or listed in Canada are now required to disclose their payments-to-government entities. These newly released payments-to-governments reports provide timely information on the payments mining and oil and gas companies make to government entities. Companies must categorize payments into one of seven payment types, such as taxes and royalties. They must also report which government entity receives the payment, and must break down the payment data by project, where applicable.

Focusing on the gold sector, the aim of this briefing is to explore ways company disclosures can be used by government, civil society, media and other oversight actors to better understand the revenues generated within Ghana’s gold sector and use this new data source as an accountability tool within the country.

Click to enlarge

This briefing outlines how payments-to-governments data can be used to: monitor whether company payments match what would be expected under the fiscal regime; to monitor the allocation and disbursement of mining royalties to subnational entities; and to monitor payments for infrastructure improvements in mining-affected areas.

The dataset used for the analysis in this briefing has been made available on Resourcedata.org and the payments-to-governments data covered in this briefing are available on ResourceProjects.org.
Image placeholder

Local Level Agreements in Mongolia’s Resource Sector: Lessons Learned and the Way Forward

Монгол »

Formal agreements between resource companies and subnational or local level stakeholders affected by company projects, or local level agreements (LLAs), are becoming an important mechanism for increasing benefits for local communities and minimizing or avoiding conflicts in many countries. The main objectives of this policy paper are to assess Mongolia’s experience with LLAs to date, identify gaps and opportunities, and recommend policy responses to improve existing regulation and agreement-making in practice.

Key policy recommendations

  • Prioritize mining projects and reduce the number of resource projects required to establish LLAs
    Implementation of the LLA requirement can be optimized by defining thresholds for resource development projects to establish LLAs.
  • Incentivize the establishment of LLAs
    Linkages back to the project approval process can be created to motivate mining companies to engage and establish agreements with “host” local governments and communities.
  • Clarify enforcement of the model agreement
    The model agreement needs to be revised and defined as a hybrid document consisting of a mandatory framework that defines the core elements of an LLA and a non-binding guidance document on potential agreement processes and content that local governments and mining companies can adjust to their needs and contexts.
  • Develop and implement capacity-building programs
    Comprehensive capacity-building programs on local level agreement-making need to be developed and implemented countrywide.
  • Support local civil society organizations to monitor implementation of LLAs
    The monitoring projects prove that independent third parties can play an important role in identifying gaps in implementation and opportunities for improvement of both individual LLAs and the overarching legal and policy frameworks for LLAs.
Image placeholder

Subnational Revenue Sharing in the DRC after Découpage: Four Recommendations for Better Governance

Français »

In 2015, the parliament of the Democratic Republic of Congo split the country’s 11 provinces into 26 by passing an administrative law. The provincial split, known as découpage, significantly altered the distribution of benefits from mining revenues. This briefing maps changes to revenue flows and shows that with the new borders, mining revenues are concentrated in three new, smaller provinces. It outlines existing challenges related to lack of clarity and transparency in the DRC’s mineral revenue sharing system and how they may be exacerbated post-découpage. Finally, it applies NRGI’s institutional knowledge of good subnational revenue sharing practice to the découpage context and outlines four recommendations that can help these new subnational governments to optimize their use of subnational revenues.
Image placeholder

Developing a Strong Mining Divestment Rule in Indonesia

As in many countries, the Indonesian government wishes to establish greater sovereignty over the country’s mineral resources. However, the government has so far struggled to realize a policy that works for both the country and investors. The key part of government efforts to exert greater sovereignty over the mining sector is the “divestment rule,” which mandates that foreign mining companies divest increasing portions of equity to Indonesian government authorities, state-owned enterprises and companies.

This policy paper evaluates costs and benefits of the divestment rule for Indonesia and provides eight recommendations to the government:

Recommendation 1: Consider eliminating the divestment rule and explore other approaches to a state-led mining sector.

Recommendation 2: Limit government purchases of mining equity and limit how public funds are used to finance state-owned enterprise investments.

Recommendation 3: Reduce the 51 percent requirement.

Recommendation 4: Establish clearer rules for negotiation and auction processes, and designate a third party to administer the processes.

Recommendation 5: Require companies that buy mining equity to publicly disclose their beneficial owners.

Recommendation 6: Allow companies the option to sell via an initial public offering.

Recommendation 7: Reconsider and further define the approach to valuing equity.

Recommendation 8: Develop a policy to manage mining state-owned enterprises.