Image placeholder

Myanmar Ends Opaque Banking of Proceeds from State Enterprises

An estimated USD 8.6 billion in taxes and other payments collected by state-owned enterprises were placed in an opaque fund known as “Other Accounts” at the Myanmar Economic Bank.

The Myanmar government’s efforts to normalize relations with the international community started in 2012. Reforms of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) were part of this process. But not all reforms were positive—an estimated USD 8.6 billion in taxes and other payments collected by SOEs were placed in an opaque fund known as “Other Accounts” at the Myanmar Economic Bank.
 
In 2016, NRGI published Gilded Gatekeepers, the first-ever report on the “Other Accounts." The report prompted the government to grant permission to NRGI and its local partner, the Renaissance Institute, to research the problem. The resulting analysis led to another NRGI report, State-Owned Economic Enterprise Reform in Myanmar. In January 2018, that report was publicly released. NRGI circulated infographics and speaking points to policymakers and journalists; briefed parliamentarians; testified in parliament; and presented to key civil society groups, international financial institutions and international economic advisors.
 
In June 2019, Myanmar’s cabinet issued a directive to abolish the Other Accounts and required all SOEs to transfer revenues to the treasury or Internal Revenue Department. Billions of dollars in natural resource revenues will now likely be channeled through the normal budget process. NRGI’s report recommendations were wholly incorporated into Myanmar’s sustainable development plan and are guiding the technical assistance plans of donors and international financial institutions.
 
Government economic advisors now have a more accurate understanding of how the system functions, civil society actors are beginning to challenge the government on economic issues and the media have begun reporting more accurately on SOE activities.

Suthep Kritsanavarin for NRGI

Image placeholder

IMF Strengthens Global Resource Governance Norms With Its Fiscal Transparency Code

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has overhauled one of its main tools for promoting voluntary transparency among its members to include a new pillar covering natural resource revenue transparency. NRGI worked with the IMF to make the overall Fiscal Transparency Code and its new pillar more robust. NRGI provided three substantial written submissions, participated in a civil society forum to discuss recommendations, and engaged IMF officials directly. While there remains some room for improvement in the code, its final text, published in 2019, reflects many of NRGI’s recommendations. It:

  • stresses the importance of open contracting procedures for license allocation.
  • calls for the identification of beneficial owners of companies holding licenses.
  • describes reporting on payments to governments at the project level “an established international norm.”
  • recognizes the importance of transparency in commodity trading and recognizes that disclosing payments by traders is well within reach of countries and companies.
  • calls for publication of environmental and social impact assessments (ESIAs) and accompanying management plans and reports.
  • reinforces existing standards and requirements around state-owned natural resource companies from other key actors like EITI and the OECD.

The new code is a win for transparency, and will serve as an important tool for the IMF to help countries spot weaknesses in their resource revenue management.

 

 

 

 

Photo credit: "imf_cso_youth_04" (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0) by International Monetary Fund

Image placeholder

Subnational Oil, Gas and Mineral Revenue Management

This paper discusses challenges and approaches in managing resource revenues at the subnational level. Subnational resource-rich governments face distinct challenges in managing revenues from volatile, exhaustible resources. These include: unpredictable and discretionary resource revenue transfers between national and subnational governments, which can undermine development planning; resource revenue volatility which can lead to wasteful spending, poor quality investments; over the longer term, the finite nature of oil, gas and mineral revenues can lead to a long period of economic growth followed by a depression; and difficulty in scaling up public investment efficiently when experiencing a revenue windfall.

To address revenue volatility, subnational governments can “smooth” expenditures by delinking revenues from expenditures. When revenues are unexpectedly high, governments can run a surplus, to be saved or used to pay down public debt. When revenues are unexpectedly low, they can draw on those savings or borrow. To prevent long-term booms and busts, governments can also save a portion of resource revenues for future generations, as well as invest in the local economy to generate future growth. Fiscal rules can underpin these policies, constraining government spending decisions and compelling government bodies to adopt a long-term perspective on public finances.

Development planning can help prepare resource-rich regions for life after their oil, gas or minerals have been depleted. Planning helps prevent shortsighted reactions to temporary ebbs and flows in oil or mineral revenues, helps define the role of the resource sector in development, and lays the groundwork for a thriving post-extractive economy.

Image placeholder

Natural Resource Charter (2nd ed.)

The Natural Resource Charter is a set of principles to guide governments' and societies' use of natural resources so these economic opportunities result in maximum and sustained returns for a country's citizens. It outlines tools and policy options designed to avoid the mismanagement of diminishing natural riches, and ensure their ongoing benefits.

The charter is organized around 12 core precepts offering guidance on key decisions governments face, beginning with whether to extract resources and ending with how generated revenue can produce maximum good for citizens.

First launched in 2010 at the annual meetings of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, the charter was written by an independent group of practitioners and academics, under the governance of an oversight board composed of distinguished international figures with first-hand experience of the challenges faced by resource-rich countries. It relaunched at the 2014 Natural Resource Charter Conference in Oxford, England.

The charter's framework and body of experts form an integral part of the Natural Resource Governance Institute.

Read more about the framework and its applications around the world.

Image placeholder

Ending Nigeria’s Oil Dependency: Not If, But When…and How

Image placeholder

What Ghana’s 2021 Budget Reveals About Its Oil Fund Management

Image placeholder

Newly Implemented Law Gives Mongolians Visibility Into State Mining Companies

Image placeholder

How Mozambique Could Strengthen its Proposed Sovereign Wealth Fund

Image placeholder

Risk and Reward in Ghana’s Agyapa Gold Royalties Deal: Eight Points for Consideration

Image placeholder

How Have Governments of Resource-Rich Countries Used Their Sovereign Wealth Funds During the Crisis?