State Oil Companies Betting Billions Against the UAE Consensus
After the COP28 UN climate conference in Dubai unprecedented attention has finally landed on the hidden half of the world’s oil and gas industry: national oil companies (NOCs). These state companies produce half the world’s oil and gas, yet their finances and operations are often hidden from the view of their countries’ own citizens.
Bringing to light and engaging with the operations of NOCs is now crucial and urgent. The landmark agreement by 195 countries in Dubai—the “UAE Consensus”— calls for a “transition away from fossil fuels.” Having slow-walked climate action for decades, the richest and most polluting countries have left the global carbon budget so tight that even NOCs in the poorest countries have little time to transition.
(Meanwhile NOCs’ efforts to reduce carbon and methane pollution from the production of oil and gas are insufficient. The Oil and Gas Decarbonization Charter announced in the early days of COP28 falls well short of what is needed to reach the Paris Agreement goals.)
The COP decision sends a clear message to national oil companies and their governments: look to a greener future. Instead NOCs are on course to spend $1.8 trillion in the coming decade to produce fossil fuels. This is mostly public money funding oil and gas in amounts far beyond levels consistent with a 1.5C upper temperature increase limit.
In essence, this money is a big bet that energy transition fails. More than two-thirds—$1.2 trillion—of this spending will only break even if the world consumes oil and gas at a rate that will cause catastrophic climate change. Not only does the UAE Consensus make this bet look riskier but governments with shrinking pockets will be less able to bail out NOCs whose bets turn bad. Across countries with NOCs, the average government debt as a proportion of gross domestic product doubled between 2011 and 2021.
How might NOCs and their governments respond? They must first recognize that there can be no more business as usual. Either the global transition fails to meet the UAE Consensus and the resulting climate crisis hits hard, or the transition erodes fossil fuel demand on which these countries depend.
From there, they should assess how their strategies will fare in a range of energy transition scenarios. How would revenue shortfalls affect the economic health of their countries? Saudi Aramco and ADNOC enjoy plentiful, low-cost oil that positions them to be among the “last producers standing.” But most NOCs don’t.
Where profit hinges on global climate inaction, NOCs must pursue new pathways or right-size their spending plans; and if they don’t or can’t, their governments should tighten the reins.
Before COP28, we examined the public statements of 21 leading NOCs and found that more than half hadn’t even acknowledged the threat of the global energy transition to their business models and the fiscal well-being of their countries. And fewer than a quarter had articulated plans to mitigate this risk. The global call to transition away from fossil fuels may now change these attitudes.
Amid a largely discouraging picture, some positive examples stand out. Colombia’s Ecopetrol has disclosed a detailed analysis of transition risk and the use of risk assessment tools. This is bold—the company’s portfolio relies heavily on high-cost oil that won’t make economic sense in a greener future—but acknowledging risk and identifying options are the first steps to progress.
Yet with few obvious options for replacing the revenues and energy that oil and gas bring, political leaders and NOC executives in such countries will likely remain hooked on hydrocarbons. They need support to take these steps.
NOCs and their governments—especially the lowest-income producers with the least ability to transition their economies on their own—shouldn’t bear the whole burden of transition. Wealthy, heavily polluting countries should be the first and fastest to phase out their production—and to finance transition in lower-income countries where citizens disproportionately suffer climate impacts and have contributed far less to warming. Without concrete commitments by wealthy countries on this front, the call for a “just and equitable” transition in the UAE Consensus risks falling flat.
The UAE Consensus requires both NOCs and the international community to respond, and to do so in this crucial decade.
National oil companies are making risky bets amid the energy transition
Africa After COP28: Imperatives for Sustainable Development
Despite resistance and challenging negotiations, the final text of the COP28 climate conference includes an historic compromise, calling for “transitioning away from fossil fuels”. This marks the beginning of the end of the fossil fuel era.
The global transition to alternative energy sources presents specific challenges and opportunities for Africa, considering its greater vulnerability to the impacts of climate change (as highlighted by African head of states in the Nairobi Declaration), its low per capita fossil fuel emissions, and pervavise energy and cooking deficits.
Leaders, decision-makers, multilateral financial institutions, and African civil society actors should now unite in prioritizing Africa’s development within the climate agenda. Strategic planning and international support can mitigate potential risks and maximize the economic, social, and environmental benefits of the energy transition in Africa. Here, we explore key African climate priorities for the immediate attention of decision-makers.
1. Prioritize adaptation over mitigation
Contributing less than 4 percent of global emissions, Africa faces primarily an adaptation challenge rather than a mitigation one. The impacts of climate change are more pronounced on the African continent. While we applaud the establishment of the Loss and Damage Fund, current financial commitments total only $792 million for all developing countries, covering less than 0.2 percent of what’s needed. Before advancing in mitigation financing, African parties and developed countries must address this crucial issue, particularly at the next COP in Azerbaijan, which will have a greater focus on transition financing.
African leaders must advocate for adequate representation in the governance of the Loss and Damage Fund, ensuring the consideration of their concerns and leaving no one behind. Streamlining procedures by UNFCCC and the World Bank (the initial host of the fund) are essential for the swift provision of necessary resources.
2. Emphasize more economic, social and energy diversity
Equity in the energy transition requires differentiated treatment for low-income fossil fuel producers, offering them more time and international support to gradually reduce their production. At COP28, African delegation united to advocate for a just and equitable energy transition, highlighting challenges related to energy poverty with over 600 million Africans without access to electricity.
Rather than debating the justice of leaving fossil resources underground, developed and African countries must collaborate to define faster, ambitious, and country-specific energy transition trajectories. The transition away from fossil fuels will impact African countries differently, and just energy transition partnerships (JETPs) can be useful instruments for African countries producing fossil fuels, tailored to local needs with technical and financial support from developed countries.
Additionally, gas raises controversies, and officials in several new African producers (including Ghana, Nigeria and Senegal) consider it a “transition fuel.” Excessive investment in gas could hinder the transition of these countries to renewable energies. To reach a quick consensus, developed and African countries must actively, transparently and respectfully collaborate to assess the compatibility of high-impact gas projects on energy poverty with the Paris Agreement, and also through rigorous and transparent modeling avoid a scenario in which African producing countries are exposed to a lock-in risk.
Officials from new African producers should model emissions for all proposed gas projects and supply chains, indicating planned volumes, the need for gas imports, operating duration, and capacity levels of gas infrastructure, and considering methane-minimization technology.
3. Fully harness the potential of renewable energies
COP28’s commitment to tripling renewable energy supply and doubling efficiency aligns with Africa’s determination to eliminate fossil fuels. Nations such as Ghana, Nigeria and Uganda are accelerating the transition to electric vehicles; and Senegal is reforming its mass transport systems toward electrification and is planning to increase the share of renewables in its mix to 40 percent. These commitments clearly illustrate Africa’s willingness to play a significant role in the global transition to a more climate-respectful economy.
Africa has every reason to continue in this direction given the continent’s enormous potential in renewable energy which is cheaper, safer and cleaner. However, an equity problem arises as most funds for clean energy still go to rich countries. Sub-Saharan Africa received less than 1 percent of the global total in the last two years.
African nations must collaborate with the international community to reduce risks associated with investments in large-scale production capacity. Innovative instruments addressing private investor concerns such as high local interest rates or the lack of local currency financing for solar and wind projects can play a role.
4. Profit from significant transition mineral reserves
Given global ambitions around expansion of renewable energy capacity, the demand for transition minerals associated green technology will likely explode. Africa will play a crucial role in the massive deployment of renewable energy technologies, considering its endowment of transition minerals. Africa holds 19 percent of the world’s reserves of metals needed for manufacturing a standard battery-powered electric vehicle and at least one-fifth of the world's reserves of a dozen minerals essential to energy transition. A “triple win,” benefiting African citizens, their environment and the energy transition, is possible and necessary.
Africa’s leaders must work toward establishing domestic value chains for electric batteries and renewable technologies, and control corruption associated with the boom in these minerals, especially since 70 percent of African countries with transitional mineral reserves rank in the lower half of corruption indices.
In conclusion, Africa's post-COP28 trajectory is defined by a commitment to a sustainable, climate-respectful economy and justice. The outlined priorities are essential for shaping Africa's resilient and environmentally conscious future. The continent’s dedication to these priorities not only secures its sustainable development but also contributes significantly to global environmental goals.
Local Voices, Global Impact: Effective Communication Strategies for Climate Change and Energy Transitions (COP28 Blue Zone Event)
This event will focus on questions including:
- What are key strategies for effective communication to local communities in promoting a just transition?
- How are communities navigating the path to sustainable energy, and what is their contribution to global solutions for sustainable energy transition?
- How can faith-based organizations in Africa actively engage with and empower local communities to be key stakeholders in energy transition and climate change initiatives?
Featured NRGI team member:
Gabriela Flores Zavala
Communications Strategy Consultant
Community of Practice: Legal and Regulatory Measures for Fossil Fuel Phaseout (COP28 Blue Zone Event)
The pathway to oil and gas phase out will require guiding legislation, regulation, and policy. As well as legislation affecting new licensing and the timeframe for production, including setting production end-dates, wider reforms to the regulatory frameworks guiding the sector may be required. Governments that pre-emptively identify legal and regulatory barriers to phase out and address potential risks should be in stronger position to manage a just transition, compared to those that implement reforms quickly in response to a declining market for oil and gas.
The BOGA Community of Practice is designed as a platform for peer learning and knowledge sharing amongst BOGA governments, other interested governments, legal and technical experts, and the broader community working in the space. This panel brings together discussants from first mover governments who have already enacted legislation toward the phase out of oil and gas, and technical partners, to discuss developments in the design and implementation of regulation for phase out.
Speakers will include:
- Tomas Anker Christensen, Climate Ambassador, Denmark
- Felicia Cruz, Director of Blue Economy, Belize
- Suneeta Kaimal, president and CEO, NRGI
- Jean Lemire, Envoy for Climate Change, Northern and Arctic Affairs, Quebec
With NRGI's
Suneeta Kaimal
President and Chief Executive Officer, NRGI Governing Board ex officio
The Three C's of Just Energy Transition (COP28 Blue Zone Event)
This event will explore the importance of citizenship, collaboration and communication for a just energy transition. The event will be in Spanish and feature simultaneous translation into English.
Speakers:
- Jorge Villareeal, Iniciativa Climática
- Gabriela Flores, NRGI
- Daniela Castilla, Movilizatorio
- Javier Campillo, Vice-Minister of Energy, Colombia
Moderator:
- Juliana Uribe, Movilizatorio
Dispatches from COP28
Keep an eye on this page for video updates from NRGI colleagues in Dubai at COP28.
Engage with NRGI at COP28
Portafolio 2023 de proyectos estratégicos para la transición energética justa de Colombia (COP28 Blue Zone Event)
En este evento participarán Omar Andrés Camacho Morales, ministro de Minas y Energía de Colombia; Antonio Hill, asesor de Transición Energética de NRGI; y representantes de Bloomberg Philanthropies y ODI. Se debatirá sobre los compromisos de Colombia en materia de NDC en proyectos estratégicos para acelerar la transición energética.
Con
Antonio Hill
Advisor
Addressing Governance and Corruption Challenges in the Response to Climate Change (COP28 Blue Zone Event)
Investing in climate change resilience requires large scale financing. The potential for corruption to exacerbate the challenge, undermine the effectiveness of the response and increase costs means that better governance must be at the heart of the climate response. Acting fast will mean leveraging the existing anticorruption architecture and catalyzing coalitions in a highly coordinated way. In this joint event with the World Bank, panelists discussed corruption vulnerabilities that are specific to the green transition and how to address them.
Panelists
- Shuang Liu, World Resources Institute, China Finance Director
- Tsakani Maluleke, South Africa, Auditor-General
- Mark Robinson, Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, Executive Director
Moderator
- Laury Haytayan, Natural Resource Governance Institute, MENA Director
Laury Haytayan
Middle East and North Africa Director
Just Transitions in the Oil & Gas Sector (COP28 Parallel Event)
Delta by Marriott Hotel, Dubai Investment Park
Managing the shift away from fossil fuels proactively, with the right policies and plans for a just and inclusive transition, is essential to addressing potential social friction and obstacles to moving as swiftly as possible onto a clean energy and net-zero emissions trajectory. While considerable attention has been placed on just transitions in the coal sector, including in developing countries recently, comparatively little attention has been placed on just transition issues in oil-and-gas-producing developing countries.
Despite commitments to achieve net zero and against continuous warnings from climate science, major producers’ plans may overshoot the 1.5C target by 110 percent by 2030 (2023 Production Gap Report). Oil and gas continue to be considered by many traditionally producing nations, as well as new countries in the developed and developing world, as a viable source of economic and social development, propelled by energy security concerns, geopolitical volatility and arguments of historical responsibility for the climate crisis.
How can we change this outlook and build consensus on the oil and gas transition after COP28? There is a need for meaningful discussions with stakeholders from developed and developing countries on several issues that will be crucial to just transitions from oil and gas. These include the development of inclusive policies to address impacts on affected communities and workers directly and indirectly employed in the industry; the effects of declining government revenue from oil and gas on public services; impacts on local governments and public sector employment; and how to diversify economies and build alternative development pathways.
This workshop aims to:
- Bring together global partners and stakeholders under the banner of COP28;
- Take a stock of the status of COP28 negotiations;
- Enable sharing of knowledge on just transitions from oil and gas in both developing and developed countries;
- Build strategies and plans for further collaboration on the just transition from oil and gas across participants.
The Energy Transition: Supply, Demand and the Investor Perspective (COP28 Blue Zone Event)
Against the backdrop of an escalating climate crisis and the need to fund an accelerated energy transition, this session will showcase supply-side and demand-side themes, as well as consider them through an investor/stakeholder lens.
Speakers will include:
- Mike Coffin, Head of Oil, Gas & Mining, Carbon Tracker
- Richard Folland, Head of Policy and Engagement, Carbon Tracker
- Denis Gyeyir, Senior Africa Analyst, NRGI
- Ben Scott, Senior Automotive Analyst, Carbon Tracker
- Representatives of Powershift Africa, EITI and UNEP-FI