Unveiling the invisible: Combating corruption in Togo's extractive sector
Guinea’s Bauxite Corruption Diagnosis, One Year Later: Progress, Challenges and Outlook
Bauxite is a crucial sector in Guinea, yet the industry faces numerous challenges. Guinea holds the world’s largest reserves of this strategic mineral, essential for producing aluminum needed for the energy transition. In 2022, bauxite exports reached historic highs, with nearly 103 million tons produced annually. According to a 2021 Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) report, bauxite accounted for nearly 60 percent of the USD 630 million in revenues generated from the country’s mining sector that year.
But behind these figures, questions persist about governance practices and issues surrounding the extraction of this mineral, regularly raised by the media and Guinean civil society. Despite substantial revenues generated, these have yet to translate into tangible improvements in citizens’ living conditions. Moreover, the sector’s vulnerability to corruption poses heightened risks, particularly given the likely surge in demand in the coming years.
Need for diagnosis and anticorruption efforts
In this context, a group of civil society actors initiated a diagnosis of corruption risks in Guinea’s bauxite sector and an action plan to strengthen transparency and accountability mechanisms. The group finalized the diagnostic report in mid-2023, with support from stakeholders of EITI-Guinea and the Agence Nationale de Lutte contre la Corruption (in English, the National Agency for Combating Corruption (ANLC)).
At NRGI we supported this work using our corruption diagnosis tool. The diagnosis identified critical corruption issues and their underlying causes. These related to mining licensing, tax practices, transparency in mining agreements and the impact of undervaluation of bauxite quality and transfer pricing on revenues. The exercise led to the development of the action plan aimed at preventing these practices. Civil society actors played a pivotal role in mobilizing all stakeholders to secure their commitment and support, convening discussions on identified risks and to collectively define interventions. This inclusive approach was underscored by the publication of the final action plan on the website of EITI-Guinea, which committed to its implementation.
Nearly a year later, participants at the ongoing 21st International Anti-Corruption Conference (IACC) in Vilnius are discussing global efforts to combat corruption. This is an opportune moment to review the implementation of the Guinean action plan: the progress achieved, the challenges faced and the expected further steps.
Civil society actors hoped that this intervention plan, based on extensive consultations, facts and robust documentation, would provide an ideal framework to strengthen efforts to combat corruption in Guinea’s mining sector. However, as with all anticorruption actions, effective implementation of reforms is complex and fraught with challenges, particularly due to resistance to change among political and economic actors.
From diagnosis to action
The publication of the corruption diagnosis reignited the debate on corruption within Guinea’s mining sector, receiving extensive media coverage. Numerous press articles and television programs highlighted the identified corruption risks, rallying various anticorruption actors in the sector. This increased pressure on authorities to pursue comprehensive reforms and review mining policies. The civil society coalition has yet to present a memorandum to the country’s new prime minister for consideration of the diagnosis results.
The dissemination of the diagnosis and intervention plan contributed significantly to the ANLC’s efforts to revive the process of revising the anticorruption law enacted in 2017. Previously, the ANLC had approached the National Transitional Council (CNT) to initiate this revision, a task which had remained pending. A key goal of the effort to amend the current anticorruption law is to address a key issue underscored in the diagnosis: enhancing ANLC’s capacity to function effectively and independently.
In the mining sector specifically, on International Anti-Corruption Day, the ANLC conducted an awarenesscampaign in Boké—center of bauxite mining in the country—on corruption risks identified in the intervention plan.
“The revision of the anticorruption law is crucial to strengthen our legislative framework and continue current authorities’ efforts for more effective and sustainable anti-corruption measures. We are committed to conducting this legislative work closely with all stakeholders.”—Alpha Abdoulaye Diallo (CNT).
Furthermore, some activities outlined in EITI-Guinea’s 2024 workplan and budget clearly align with the action plan’s recommendations. Key priorities include modernizing the mining cadastre, improving transparency in license issuance, evaluating legal obligations, administrative monitoring, training community representatives, analyzing revenue management, strengthening the capacities of mining employees, and efficient use of extractives revenues.
Remaining challenges
Despite promising initial steps toward implementation of the action plan, several challenges persist:
- Limited civil society monitoring capacity. The coalition of civil society organizations lacks the necessary financial and technical resources to effectively support, monitor and evaluate the identified actions.
- Media space restrictions. Recent political and regulatory pressures have curtailed freedom of expression and dissemination of information. This constrains public debate and the spread of critical information, thereby reducing pressure to implement recommended interventions.
- Sensitivities of anticorruption work. In the current political climate, anticorruption actors, particularly those from civil society organizations, face significant risks to their safety, which greatly hinder their engagement. The absence of protective measures for these actors further exacerbates these risks.
“Civil society organizations demonstrate determination in preventing, detecting and combating corruption in all its forms. However, they lack adequate technical and financial support to better explore and navigate the intricacies of corruption that tends to be institutionalized in Guinea.”—Moussa Iboun Conté (coalition of civil society organizations)
Beyond these challenges, political will and institutional actors’ capacity to implement identified reforms remain fundamental. In this regard, the Guinean government should recognize and support notable efforts by the ANLC and EITI-Guinea ahead of the upcoming EITI validation in 2025, and should prioritize the revision of the anticorruption law. To ensure that the promises of bauxite benefit Guinean citizens, in the current context of the “race for transition minerals”, the Ministry of Mines and Geology should issue new licenses according to best practices, mining companies should operate new sites operate responsibly, and that the state financial agencies collect revenue efficiently. On all these three issues, fighting corruption is key.
Safeguarding a Just Energy Transition in the Extractive and Energy Sectors (International Anti-Corruption Conference 2024)
In-person
As the world moves away from fossil fuels, demand for minerals essential for renewable technologies is rising steeply. This session will create awareness of the corruption risks stemming from these changes and their impact on communities. Speakers will focus on innovative approaches to strengthen multistakeholder governance, to ensure transparency and accountability for a just energy transition.
Featuring
- Susannah Fitzgerald, Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI)
- Marie Gay Alessandra Ordenes, Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI)
- Sophie Frossard, Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH
- Brooke Stearns Lawson, United States Agency for International Development (USAID)
- Clancy Moore, Transparency International Australia (TI - Australia)
This in-person session is part of the International Anti-Corruption Conference (IACC) 2024. Visit the IACC website to learn more about the event.
Featuring NRGI's
Susannah Fitzgerald
Critical Minerals Governance Senior Officer
NRGI has developed a tool to help anticorruption actors identify, prioritize and address corruption issues in the extractives sector.
Mining: Stakeholders rally journalists to champion host communities’ rights
Scrutinize all deals in minerals industry – Analyst
Levers for Policy Action: How Can Regulation be an Effective Tool to Ensure Responsible Mineral Supply Chains? (OECD Forum on Responsible Mineral Supply Chains)
Paris, France
If mineral supply chains are to be responsible and secure, we must ensure that intense competition for transition minerals does not further erode compliance with standards. This session considered how policy levers can achieve this, particularly how we can make regulation as effective a tool as possible in raising standards of industry conduct.
Speakers:
- Mauricio Cabrera Leal, Colombian Ministry of Environment and Sustainable Development, Vice Minister of Environmental Policy and Standardization
- Lihui Sun, head of sustainability, CCCMC; founder of RCI, CCCMC/Responsible Critical Mineral Initiative (RCI)
- K.C. Michaels, legal counsel, International Energy Agency (IEA)
- Beverly Besmanos, Mindanao sub-national coordinator, Bantay Kita – Publish What You Pay Philippines
- Susannah Fitzgerald, governance officer, Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI)
- Tobias Kind-Rieper, global lead for mining and metals, WWF (Chair)
This event was part of the 2024 OECD Forum on Responsible Mineral Supply Chains.
French and Chinese interpretation was available.
Featuring NRGI's
Susannah Fitzgerald
Critical Minerals Governance Senior Officer
How to Fight Against Corruption in the Extractives Sector
From research to action using NRGI corruption diagnostic tool
The pervasive nature of extractives sector corruption is widely acknowledged by civil society, governments, international organizations and businesses. While there is agreement on the existence of the problem, the question of how to address corruption is still ever-present. Many civil society actors have engaged in anticorruption efforts, but it can be difficult to know where to start. This is why NRGI developed an extractives corruption diagnostic tool.
First developed in 2021, NRGI’s corruption diagnostic tool is an adaptable, step-by-step process designed to help anticorruption actors identify and understand major corruption issues in the extractives sector of their country or region, prioritize which issues are most important to focus on, and then build and implement action plans for reforms to address these issues. The process emphasizes collaboration across stakeholders, both to strengthen understanding of the most pressing issues and to build buy-in for reform. Newly relaunched, NRGI has incorporated new insights and research to make this tool as effective as possible.
During this webinar, participants will hear about different experiences from civil society actors engaged in anticorruption efforts in extractives. NRGI will present the new version of its diagnostic tool, highlighting examples of diagnostics conducted so far, when and how anticorruption actors–especially civil society organizations–can use it, the opportunities it represents, and the challenges faced. And finally, participants will discuss opportunities and ideas to strengthen anticorruption engagement in their countries.
Speakers
- Beverly F. Besmanos, Bantay Kita - Publish What You Pay Philippines
- Susannah Fitzgerald, NRGI
- Tamika Halwiindi, Transparency International Zambia
- Emil Omarov, Publish What You Pay
NRGI's corruption diagnostic tool helps support effective research and advocacy.
Susannah Fitzgerald
Critical Minerals Governance Senior Officer
Matthieu Salomon
Lead, Anticorruption
How Do You Tackle a Problem Like Corruption? NRGI’s Tool Can Help
Corruption has, as ever, been hitting the headlines. Guatemala’s Ministry of Energy and Mines has announced a full investigation into all recent decisions on mining licenses in response to multiple allegations of bribery and corruption. The Portuguese prime minister will step down over a high-level corruption investigation into lithium projects in the country. Swiss authorities have charged Trafigura with bribing a government official, allegedly a chief executive of a subsidiary of Angola’s state-owned enterprise Sonangol–merely the latest in a series of commodity trading corruption scandals.
Yet these cases are not just fodder for newspapers’ financial or politics pages; they have a real and devastating impact on people and the planet. The UN estimates that Africa loses USD 88.6 billion each year in illicit financial flows, money that cannot be put towards healthcare, education, or essential infrastructure. In the extractives sector, this corruption can also come at a physical cost to communities, such as through pollution or eviction, and harms our global ambitions to fight climate change.
The pervasive nature of extractives sector corruption is widely acknowledged by civil society, governments, international organizations and businesses. While there is agreement on the existence of the problem, the question of how to address corruption is still ever-present. It can be difficult to know where to start, but inaction is not an option if we are to reach a fairer, more sustainable future. This is why at NRGI we developed a corruption diagnostic tool.
What is our corruption diagnostic tool?
First developed in 2021, NRGI’s corruption diagnostic tool is an adaptable, step-by-step process designed to help anticorruption actors identify and understand major corruption issues in the extractives sector of their country or region, prioritize which issues are most important to focus on, and then build and implement action plans for reforms to address these issues. The process emphasizes collaboration across stakeholders, both to strengthen understanding of the most pressing issues and to build buy-in for reform. Newly relaunched, we’ve incorporated new insights and research to make this tool as effective as possible.
A tool is a practical guide, therefore understanding how it is used in practice is essential to making sure that it is as effective as possible in supporting anticorruption actors. We’ve gathered feedback from five different uses of the tool on what has been helpful, what could be improved, and what new information is needed to refine and update the tool.
What’s new?
As part of this update to the tool, future users can now find:
- Updated step-by-step guidance. One of the most significant changes to our guidance is adding a new step on implementation. As any campaigner or policy wonk will tell you, securing buy-in and effective implementation for your reform ideas is the toughest challenge–especially when there may be actors with vested interests working against you. This has proved true for users of the tool as well, so we’ve now dedicated more space to advocacy and what comes after you’ve developed an action plan. But this isn’t the only change to the guidance. We’ve also, for example, sought to clarify topics such as definitions on policy and state capture and provide quick glance summaries of the main types of corruption under different stages of the decision-making chain or thematic topics.
- Three new research modules. One of the key steps of the tool is Step 4, where users carry out more in-depth research into high-priority topics. To support this, we’ve developed three more modules covering corruption and artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM), socioenvironmental harm in the mining sector, and fossil-fuel phase out. These modules are designed to help users better navigate specific challenges, particularly around the energy transition. Users can also still draw on five existing modules on the decision chain (the decision to extract, license, and contract; operations; revenue collection; and revenue management) and state-owned enterprises.
- Summaries of past uses of the tool. Whenever you start a new project, it can be helpful to understand how others have approached the same problem. We’ve therefore developed summaries outlining how the tool was used in Chile, Colombia, Guinea, Mongolia, and the Philippines, placing a particular focus on the action plans they developed. For more about lessons learned and advice, you can also read blog posts about the process from users in Mongolia, Colombia, and Guinea. By examining the experiences of others, users can gain valuable insights to inform their own anticorruption efforts and adapt strategies for maximum impact.
- Two new research briefings. We also wanted to bring in lessons from elsewhere in the anticorruption or resource governance spaces, so we’ve developed two new briefings. The first explains new provisions in the 2023 EITI Standard, offering practical insights for anticorruption actors—whether they are multi-stakeholder groups, CSOs and journalists or anticorruption institutions, how to use this information and examples of how this has been done in the past. The second briefing looks at anticorruption reforms in other sectors, such as forestry and defense, to understand what lessons anticorruption actors in the extractives space can learn from these efforts. We’ve focused on successful reforms, drawing out key principles from these cases to help guide action planning, which have also been incorporated into the updated guidance.
- A digital platform to navigate this information. All this content may seem a bit intimidating to anyone new to the tool or who wants to learn more about a specific topic, such as how corruption could manifest in the licensing process or as fossil-fuels are being phased out. That’s why we developed a one-stop-shop for all this information. Our microsite summarizes the steps in the process, including clear links to all the information shared above. We hope that this will also make the research developed for the tool more accessible for all actors working to tackle corruption in the extractives sector.
We have exciting plans for the tool in NRGI’s focus countries over the next couple of years, so keep an eye out for more updates on this work.
Contact NRGI if you’d like to carry out your own diagnostic process or have any questions.
How Companies at Africa’s Mining Indaba Can Take Meaningful Action for People and Planet
Next week, policymakers, industry executives, civil society actors and development partners will converge on Cape Town, South Africa for the 2024 African Mining Indaba. Now in its 30th year, Indaba is an annual confab, primarily known as a venue for dealmaking and discussions between governments and mining companies.
This year’s theme—“Embracing the power of positive disruption: A bold new future for African mining”—is encouraging. As players like the U.S., EU, China and most recently Gulf oil powers scramble for the continent’s minerals, this time must indeed be different. The history of mining in Africa is riddled with economic, social and environmental injustice, often accompanied by underinvestment and supply disruptions. A triple win—for people in African mining countries, for their environment, and for the energy transition itself—is sorely needed.
Only by reducing investor risks arising from disputes with governments and communities will companies be able to sufficiently increase capital flows into Africa's mining sector to take full advantage of booming demand.
Civil society organizations and activists at the Alternative Mining Indaba, a very un-corporate parallel Indaba universe, have for years made the case for a better deal for Africans. World leaders are belatedly recognizing the importance of transition mineral governance for ensuring the production of green technology needed for climate change mitigation. At the COP28 climate conference, UN Secretary-General António Guterres stated that “the extraction of critical minerals for the clean energy revolution… must be done in a sustainable, fair and just way.”
Companies must also ensure that Africans get a better deal. Only by reducing investor risks arising from disputes with governments and communities will they be able to sufficiently increase capital flows into the sector to take full advantage of booming demand. And it seems companies are beginning to realize this. At last year’s Indaba, industry executives made frequent reference to “ESG” (environmental, social and governance considerations). And at this year’s edition companies are again queuing up to speak on panels about sustainability.
However, in the last year concrete action has been sporadic at best. This year’s Indaba is a good opportunity for companies to clearly define what actions they will take. Below are some of these actions on value addition, social and environmental protection, and corruption.
Value addition
Value addition—usually meaning the refining of raw commodities into something closer to their final consumable form—is increasingly sought after in most mining nations, as it brings additional revenues, jobs and, in some cases, an opportunity to produce inputs for producers’ domestic economies. African leaders reinforced their call for more value addition to take place on the continent at last year’s inaugural Africa Climate Summit.
To realize these ambitions, African governments must develop a clear and credible mineral-specific strategy. International players such as the U.S. and European Union need to convert memoranda of understanding on mineral supply cooperation with the likes of the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Zambia into concrete action to derisk financing and address other bottlenecks.
However, industry also has a critical role. Companies should:
- Support independent, publicly disclosed value addition feasibility studies. Companies should work with governments to better incorporate value addition planning in the licensing process and ensure transparency at key decision points. Companies, such as those soon to start mining Tanzania’s rare earths and Ghana’s lithium, increasingly agree to some form of scoping of value addition feasibility. But these assessments are often ill-defined and lack clear timeframes, and neither the companies nor government tend to publish them. Independent, published feasibility studies as part of license conditions would not only help governments to manage public expectations when value addition is not feasible but also help them to make value addition more feasible in the longer term by identifying bottlenecks.
- Coordinate. Coordination between mining companies operating in the same or neighboring countries could alleviate challenges of costly infrastructure needs and scale. Guinea’s huge Simandou iron ore project is finally proceeding with at least eight companies coordinating to construct two mines, a railway and a port; but companies in Guinea continue to primarily export bauxite ore despite sufficient scale for large alumina refineries that could bring down costs if they coordinated to supply feedstock. Governments should help to bring companies around the table, but companies themselves can be more proactive in this regard.
Social and environmental protection
Limiting the social and environmental harms of mining is just as crucial as maximizing the benefits. Some mining companies have taken positive, preliminary steps in this area—for example, “nature positive” commitments made by International Council of Mining and Metals (ICMM) members last month. But companies can and must do more. They should:
- Observe and expand mining no-go zones. ICMM members have committed to not exploring or mining in UNESCO world heritage sites and complying with the objectives of legally designated protected areas. However, this falls short, for example, of protecting forests of high conservation value inside and outside of protected areas—a key step for protecting communities and the environment. Nearly 27 percent of the Congo Basin’s intact tropical rainforests overlap with mining concessions. Governments should designate no-go zones, but companies shouldn’t wait for that to act themselves.
- Meaningfully consult with communities. In principle, governments and companies have increasingly recognized the need for “free prior and informed consent” from communities before allowing extraction. However, this engagement often has limited meaning. A recent analysis of 26 African countries found that seven do not require public consultation until after companies have completed a draft environmental and social impact assessment, rather than during the drafting process. Given the importance of community relations for companies’ “social license to operate,” and the expertise that communities bring on managing their local environment, companies should undertake meaningful consultation irrespective of any legal requirements.
- Publish project-level information on impacts. More project-level information will enable greater engagement by local actors directly affected by mining’s social and environmental impacts. The new Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) mining standard, set to launch next week at Indaba, supports this move by emphasizing mine-site reporting on a wide range of impacts such as water, waste and emissions.
Corruption
Corruption stands in the way of a better deal for the people and environment in African mining countries, and with it more minerals to address the climate crisis. Without action, the risk that the scramble for Africa’s minerals fuels corruption is high: corruption allegations have already emerged in relation to the race for Africa’s lithium.
To effectively tackle corruption, companies should, among other actions:
- Reduce the use of agents and intermediaries. Corruption commonly comes in the form of company staff paying bribes to public officials via agents and intermediaries. Companies should follow the example of trader Trafigura, which in 2019 committed to no longer hiring third parties to perform “business development” functions (recently announced bribery charges related to activities in 2009-2011 show why action on corruption at the company was essential). Companies should exert extensive control over relationships with any remaining intermediaries.
- Be transparent. Companies should adopt and champion project-level contract, payment, commodity trading and beneficial ownership transparency in line with the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative Standard (EITI) to make it easier for journalists, citizens and other accountability actors to detect corruption. While there are examples of good practice, such as Newmont and Rio Tinto, 73 percent of EITI supporting companies still do not meet the expectations on beneficial ownership transparency and 27 percent fall short on contract transparency.
- Ensure strong due diligence to avoid elite capture. In many countries, powerful officials and their allies receive unfair access to the mining sector and its profits, including through influencing the choice of subcontractors and partners. Petrobras, the Brazilian national oil company, has reduced these risks following the “Car Wash” scandal by requiring suppliers to report beneficial ownership information and verifying this information for higher-risk entities—and refusing to engage with any entity whose key personnel or beneficial owners have unmanageable conflicts of interest. Mining companies should follow suit.
As Indaba kicks off on Monday, we hope to see companies embrace the types of positive disruption outlined above to achieve a “triple win.” It’s in everyone’s interest that they do.
The extraction of critical minerals for the clean energy revolution must be done in a sustainable, fair and just way. The Democratic Republic of the Congo-Zambia battery plant offers an opportunity.
Sustainable and Responsible Critical Mineral Supply Chains
This webinar, featuring reaction from experts including NRGI's Matthieu Salomon, presented the key findings of Sustainable and Responsible Critical Mineral Supply Chains: Guidance for Policy Makers and the Critical Minerals Policy Tracker 2023.
The event began with remarks from the Critical Minerals Working Party’s ESG Task Force, followed by a detailed presentation by the IEA Office of Legal Counsel. The report offers five recommendations for policy makers for creating sustainable and responsible supply chains and delves into key areas such as water management, emissions, biodiversity, human rights, communities, and corruption. It is complemented by the latest update to the Policy Tracker, which includes over 200 new laws, regulations, and policies with a special focus on environmental, social and governance issues.
Salomon emphasized the importance of enforcement of laws targeting corruption in mining; the key role of independent monitoring in the sector; and the importance of acknowledging and mitigating corruption risk and disruption to supply chains.