War in Ukraine: Strategic Challenges for Extractive Governance in Latin America
Key messages
- In the context of the war in Ukraine, the overall economic outlook for Latin America is poor. However, countries rich in natural resources will receive extraordinary income due to increased commodity prices.
- High prices have led to decisions that could increase dependence on fossil fuels in the long term, including announcements of increases in production, new investments, and domestic fuel subsidies.
- This situation could slow down domestic energy transition agendas, but the problems created by fossil fuel dependence could also be an opportunity to encourage investment in renewable energy.
- Governments should use extraordinary profits made during this period to finance the energy transition and productive diversification.
- Neither this nor any other situation justifies lowering governance standards in the extractive sector.
Introduction
This briefing analyzes the impact of the war in Ukraine on strategic prospects and governance challenges in the extractive sector in Latin America, focusing on the situation in Colombia, Mexico and Peru. The analysis leads us to question the enthusiasm that some actors in the region have shown regarding the potential profits from natural resource exports. These profits will be realized in a scenario characterized by lower growth prospects, more expensive credit, lower rates of foreign direct investment and higher inflation and fiscal pressure to subsidize fuel and food.
In this context, we discuss three strategic challenges for natural resource governance: the increased commitment to fossil fuels and the slowing prospects for the energy transition; the need to strategically plan for the use of the extraordinary income that natural resource exporters receive due to high price cycles; and the importance of strengthening governance systems to prevent weakening standards for regulating resource extraction.
In addition to the humanitarian, economic and geopolitical impacts of the war, there are also potential environmental impacts, mainly related to climate change, as the war is changing the prospects for fossil fuel consumption.
Even before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the global economy was already facing the consequences of the health crisis caused by the coronavirus pandemic and bottlenecks in global supply chains. The war has further complicated international trade, exacerbating inflationary trends and the rise in commodity prices, particularly energy and food prices. Russia and Ukraine are major exporters of natural resources, including oil, gas, iron ore, nickel, aluminium, coal, grains, and fertilizers. According to the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Antonio Guterres, the war in Ukraine could trigger a “hurricane of hunger” and bring the global food system to collapse. The disruption of the supply chain will bring higher inflation and affect the recovery of the global economy. In addition to the humanitarian, economic and geopolitical impacts of the war, there are also potential environmental impacts, mainly related to climate change, as the war is changing the prospects for fossil fuel consumption and could further complicate the global energy transition.
Institutions such as Goldman Sachs and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have indicated that the war in Ukraine will impact Latin America's economic performance: growth rates will be lower and interest and inflation rates will be increasingly higher across the region. The next few years will most likely bring financial instability and a decline in private investment. Despite potentially high revenues from higher commodity prices, higher energy and food costs could significantly weaken the prospects for these countries. Furthermore, the impact within countries will not be uniform. While some sectors, such as resource exporters, will benefit, others will be harmed, including possibly producers of food intended for local markets.
Extraordinary profits in an adverse economic context
The credit rating agency Fitch Ratings has revised forecasts for mineral and fossil fuel prices due to the situation in Ukraine. These generally show a short-term increase in prices, but a recovery of the original trends in the medium to long term. In the case of mining, prices of major metals and minerals will generally be higher than expected in 2022 and 2023. However, the projections remain unchanged for 2024 and the long term. In the case of copper, however, the long-term price forecast has been revised upward, as this metal plays an important role in global decarbonization strategies. The price forecast for thermal coal has increased through to 2025, but maintains its long-term downward trend, specifically because of the prospect of declining coal consumption due to associated high greenhouse gas emissions. For oil and gas, the same rating agency projects high prices between 2022 and 2024; thereafter the downward trend will be maintained.
In Latin America, the incomes of countries rich in natural resources will be boosted by the increased prices of the commodities they export. The dynamics vary depending on the type of resource. Thus, for example, copper producers like Chile and Peru will benefit from the long-term prospects for this mineral, even though production costs are also higher against a backdrop of inflation and high energy prices. In the case of Colombia, the main mining export is coal, the price of which is forecast to rise in the short term but fall in the medium to long term. This country will also benefit from high nickel prices. As for mining in Brazil, it is important to note that the country is a major exporter of iron ore, which is also experiencing an upward cycle.
Oil exporters are also expected to see an increase in revenues due to higher prices. These include countries like Brazil, Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador and Venezuela, in addition to Guyana’s significant export prospects. Despite the structural difficulties they face, state-owned oil enterprises in the region have got a new boost to their operations in the context of high prices.
In Mexico, according to the Brattle Group, additional income from crude oil exports at $100 per barrel amount to about $284 million per week. Most of this revenue is going to Pemex, which, as the most indebted oil company in the world, is forced to use this extraordinary income to improve its financial situation and reduce its debt.
In Peru, the state-owned company Petroperú is in the midst of an internal crisis that has led risk rating agencies such as Fitch and S&P Global Ratings to reduce its credit rating and elsewhere to talk of a potential bankruptcy of the company. Recently, however, there has been a change of leadership in the company and the Talara oil refinery has come into operation, which could give Petroperú new momentum. In the case of Colombia, Ecopetrol earned record profits in 2021. Projections for 2022 suggest that public and private investment in hydrocarbons will increase as production declines due to the lack of new discoveries of significant reserves, which in turn will lead to increased offshore exploration.
High fossil fuel prices also pose a challenge to domestic demand for fuels. The price increase mainly affects countries that are net importers of oil and fuels, like Peru, but also producer countries that tend to subsidize domestic consumption or grant tax exemptions, such as Mexico and Colombia.
In the case of Mexico, the government has granted tax incentives to petrol refiners and importers, which they can credit against other taxes for each liter sold. According to several Mexican analysts, tax exemptions and subsidies have historically exceeded estimated additional oil revenues when prices have been high. As Mexico is a net importer of fuel, one of the largest investments by the government of president Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO) is the Dos Bocas refinery. The purpose of this refinery is to strengthen Mexico's energy security by allowing the country to refine oil domestically and avoid dependence on fuel imports.
As has become clear worldwide, domestic fuel prices are a very sensitive political issue. In Mexico, measures seek to protect the purchasing power of Mexican households in the political context of a presidential impeachment and elections in six states. In Colombia, a liberalization of petrol prices could have unforeseen social consequences given the recent social unrest and electoral situation in the country. In Peru, a truckers’ strike related to high fuel prices put the government of Pedro Castillo in a particularly precarious situation in early April this year. As a result, the Peruvian government decided to include several fuels, such as 90-octane petrol, diesel and bulk liquefied petroleum gas— in the Petroleum Derived Fuel Price Stabilisation Fund, in addition to exempting several basic foodstuffs from general sales tax.
New enthusiasm for increasing extraction
Against the backdrop of a bleak economic outlook, extracting natural resources once again seems to be the best option for countries that have historically been committed to this activity. This is a global phenomenon. In Africa, the war in Ukraine and the blockade of Russian gas have generated expectations that the continent could supply Europe with gas, although it is unrealistic to think that this will be feasible in the short term. Similar enthusiasm has built up in Latin America, either because of opportunities to profit from high prices or because of the resurgence of the energy security agenda, with announcements of new oil investments in countries such as Argentina and Ecuador.
In Colombia, the prospects for oil and coal, the country's two main exports, have been greeted with enthusiasm. As a result of the oil price increase caused by the war in Ukraine, the oil producers’ association is expecting the industry to be more dynamic, with greater investments in exploration and in the development of unconventional sources, such as fracking, and offshore investments, both of which have sparked resistance from various actors in Colombia. Furthermore, according to statements by President Iván Duque after a visit to the United States, Colombia intends to increase its production from approximately 800,000 to 1 million barrels of oil per day. Oil is Colombia's largest export and its contribution to the royalty system accounts for about one third of the total, therefore any increase in the international price has a profound impact on the country's political economy.
The sharp increase in the price of coal has also revived enthusiasm for the industry in Colombia and complicated discussions about the transition to coal in producing regions, which intensified when Prodeco announced the closure of its operations in Cesar. The change in the prospects for coal is directly related to the war in Ukraine, as some analysts say the blockade on Russian coal has reopened the doors for Colombian coal in the European Union. Coal could also replace part of Europe's gas consumption from Russia. This is a relatively quick and straightforward alternative, as countries like Germany have not completely cut back on their coal consumption and have even reopened coal plants as a result of the war. The new situation reverses the downward trend in coal, at least in the short term, giving a renewed impetus for Colombia’s coal industry.
In Mexico, the war has favored the mining companies already in operation, due to the strong performance of silver, copper and goal, among others. In the case of oil, the price increase is helping Pemex manage its debt, which does not necessarily mean an increase in production, but possibly a review of the decision to reduce exports. In December 2021, Pemex’s director stated that the company would reduce its exports in 2022 and stop exporting crude oil by 2023, given that the administration's objective is to achieve energy sovereignty. However, this promise is now being reconsidered due to the rise in oil prices and the additional income that will allow it to subsidize domestic fuel consumption. The energy and finance ministries are currently conducting a detailed analysis to determine if this will change.
In Peru, public debate in recent months has focused on inflation worries, particularly regarding energy and food prices. Peru exports various mining products, some of which are rising in price, including copper, silver, zinc, tin and iron. However, rising oil prices will hit the sector’s cost structure. In addition, there are the recurring social conflicts in various mines around the country, as for example in the southern mining corridor. The high level of conflict, combined with low business confidence in the Pedro Castillo government and institutional deterioration in the energy and mining sectors, have led to a slowdown in mining investment in the country. In view of this, according to Fitch Ratings, in a note picked up by Diario Gestión, the boards of foreign mining companies have not approved any new projects in Peru.
On the other hand, testing of the new Talara refinery began on 12 April this year and officials expect it to be fully operational by the end of 2022. As a precaution, the Peruvian government has not promised any price cuts as a result of the new refinery, although it is offering more competitive prices to the wholesale market and cleaner fuels to the local market.
In the context of the war in Ukraine and related energy security challenges, the Peruvian government has stated its intention to increase oil production through state-owned Petroperú, mainly in the country’s Amazon region. Petroperú plans to participate in oil extraction at Lot 192, the largest in the country, but also the one that has suffered the greatest number of spills. This situation has led to a long history of conflicts with indigenous peoples in the Amazon department of Loreto and along the northern Peruvian pipeline that transports extracted oil to the Talara refinery on the country's northern coast. Furthermore, the state oil company plans to become a partner in a series of lots which, in principle, would be returned to Petroperú in the coming years when their contracts expire. However, this is generating resistance and conflicts with the private sector, which are also being voiced in the country’s parliament. Added to this new push for oil is the government’s political decision to spread the use of Camisea gas across the country, which would also involve increasing natural gas reserves, in this case from the Amazon region of Cusco.
Strategic challenges for the governance of natural resources
The disruption caused by the war is influencing pre-existing political dynamics and governance challenges in each country. At the regional level, the problems that Latin America already faces in terms of natural resource governance, such as the reprimarization of exports, problems with corporate management in state-owned oil companies, little progress in domestic energy transition and high levels of conflict related to extractive activities, are exacerbated by high prices and the resulting pressure to deepen the extractive agenda.
There is evidence that high prices encourage national oil companies to make risky bets in terms of new investments that may not be viable in the future of the global energy transition.
Although the scenarios of the countries analyzed vary, they all have in common an increased commitment to fossil fuels. This is true for Colombia, Mexico, Peru and many other countries in the region and the world. It is important to note, however, that these short-term price prospects do not determine the companies' long-term strategies. There is evidence that high prices encourage national oil companies to make risky bets in terms of new investments that may not be viable in the future of the global energy transition. The enthusiasm for fossil fuels comes at a time when scientists and activists are calling more strongly for the need to drastically reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
The message is clear: unless immediate and radical action is taken, we will not hit the target of reducing global warming to 1.5°C. And while fossil fuel consumption will not stop overnight, global criteria to allow developing countries to have priority in extraction must be discussed, but without encouraging new exploration projects. The Secretary-General of the United Nations, Antonio Guterres has pointed out that the obsession with obtaining oil in the short term may increase dependence in the long term and could also lead to failure to meet climate goals. Regarding the support given to coal consumption by G20 countries in the context of the war, Guterres has said that “Their support for coal not only could cost the world its climate goals. It’s a stupid investment”.
In the long term, we can expect a decrease in fossil fuel consumption and an increase in the renewable energy market.
The renewed push for fossil fuels is linked to price increases, which, as we have seen, are a short-term factor, and to concerns about energy security. Governments need to consider the medium- and long-term prospects when making decisions. In the long term, we can expect a decrease in fossil fuel consumption and an increase in the renewable energy market. This is due to climate considerations, but also issues of oil price volatility, bottlenecks in the fossil fuel supply chain and the association of oil with authoritarian and kleptocratic regimes.
Energy prices have also risen. Again, this is a short-term dynamic, as renewable energy are already a cheaper economic option than fossil fuels, and the long-term trend is that the transition to renewables will result in government savings. In the case of Latin America, progress on renewables varies between countries, but it is clear that active policies and the development of clear regulatory frameworks are required to promote these energy sources. The transition to renewables also presents opportunities for investment in new technologies. The deepening of the fossil fuel consumption agenda is slowing down the progress of renewable energy in the region.
In this context, how to take advantage of the extraordinary resources that high prices for non-renewable resources bring is an important topic for public discussion. As we have seen, economic prospects are generally poor and many of these resources go towards stabilizing fuel prices domestically. Insisting on investments that increase dependence on fossil fuels, as is the case in Mexico, Colombia and Peru, under different formulas and conditions, is not a sustainable strategy in the medium and long term. Instead, windfall profits should be used to finance energy transition strategies and productive diversification.
Finally, given the high prices, pressures are increasing to expand the extractive frontier. Examples include pressure to develop mining projects in indigenous territories in Brazil, offshore oil projects and fracking in Colombia and the agenda to increase gas reserves in the Peruvian Amazon. From the perspective of extractive promoters, it is always a good time to make things easier for the functioning of the sector: when prices are low there is a need to avoid losses; when prices are high, there is a need to ensure profits. No situation justifies lowering environmental, social and governance standards for the extractive sector.
The authors are grateful for comments from Antonio Hill and Andrea Furnaro (NRGI) on an earlier version of this document. Likewise, the members of the Platform for a Sustainable Reactivation in Peru and Colombia and Sergio Guzmán from Colombia Risk Analysis, who took part in the discussion following a presentation on this topic in Bogotá in March 2022.
One Year of War in Ukraine: The View from Resource-Rich Developing Countries
Listen to this post · One Year of War in Ukraine The View from Resource-Rich Developing Countries
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has uniquely affected developing countries rich in oil, gas and minerals. Translating resource wealth into economic and energy pathways that benefit all citizens has been a longstanding challenge in such countries. A year of mixed messages, market turbulence and persistent vested interests have added further complexity. Policymakers in resource-rich countries—and their international partners—have three opportunities to advance economic and environmental sustainability.
Invest in renewables and equitable energy access
Coming on the heels of the pandemic recovery, the war in Ukraine threw the global energy transition into doubt. Prioritization of energy security pointed to a resurgence of demand for fossil fuels. Oil, gas, and coal prices rose as Europe scrambled to secure alternatives to Russian supply. Expectations across African gas-producing countries soared, and Colombian coal exporters were likewise buoyant as coal’s share of EU power generation reached its highest point since 2018.
Yet, a year later, policy responses to the war have actually turbocharged the global energy transition. Global capital expenditure on wind and solar assets surpassed investment in new and existing oil and gas wells for the first time. In 2021, wind and solar already made up 75 percent of all global power production capacity added, as fossil fuels additions hit a record low (14 percent). In pursuit of greater energy security, countries that have historically imported large amounts of oil, gas and coal have doubled down on domestic deployment of renewables. Europe launched its REPowerEU package less than three months after the invasion, promising an aggressive expansion of wind and solar power and new energy efficiency measures. Even if delivering on that ambition by 2030 remains a challenge, Europe made steady progress in 2022: wind and solar power generation reached record levels and exceeded gas generation for the first time. The U.S. Inflation Reduction Act represented the most significant expansion of public spending on the clean energy economy ever and has pressured the EU to keep up the pace of its own financial outlays.
As a result, policymakers need to plan for economic and energy pathways beyond fossil fuels. For the first time, the IEA’s World Energy Outlook (WEO) 2022 contains a prevailing policy scenario (called STEPS) that projects a global peak or plateau for all fossil fuels, with total fossil fuel demand falling steadily from “the mid-2020s.” Policymakers in low- and middle-income exporting countries need to factor the resilience of the global energy transition—and its implications for their countries’ revenues—into economic and energy transition planning. These countries should redouble efforts—and international partners should support them—to boost their own energy security through faster deployment of renewables.
Low- and middle-income fossil fuel-producing countries are particularly vulnerable to energy shocks. They were fully exposed to the turmoil, unlike wealthy countries that spent upwards of $500 billion to shield consumers from price shocks. Paradoxically even Africa’s largest oil producer, Nigeria, saw businesses struggle as diesel prices increased by more than 200 percent shortly after the invasion. And rising gas prices made utility-scale power generation much more expensive in markets like Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana and Nigeria. The IEA reported that the number of people without access to modern energy services rose for the first time in a decade. Around 75 million people (more than four times the population of Senegal) who recently gained access to electricity now risk losing the ability to pay for it, and 100 million people may be forced to revert to traditional biomass for cooking.
Investment in renewables, advocacy for international financial and technical support and equitable energy access are priorities. Annual clean energy investment in emerging and developing economies (excluding China) has remained flat since the 2015 Paris Agreement. And yet the IEA STEPS scenario makes clear that these countries require the greatest growth in renewables investment in the 2020s. To meet necessary energy demand growth, governments in developing oil- and gas-producing countries need to develop their pipeline of “shovel-ready” wind and solar projects. They can also work with international partners to prioritize public investment around hard-to-finance areas that will unlock large-scale private investment in renewables. Policymakers also need to develop governance frameworks that equitably share renewable energy’s developmental benefits, expand energy access and economic opportunities for the most vulnerable populations, and prevent harmful community impacts and corruption.
Improve minerals governance to seize energy transition opportunities
The conflict has heightened global concern about a stable supply of transition minerals. The accelerating energy transition and the impact of the conflict on the gas supply chain has spooked officials in major consumer countries, who see control of transition minerals as a matter of energy security. The world’s top three producing nations for each of lithium, cobalt and rare earths control more than three-quarters of the global output of each mineral. Processing of transition minerals is even more concentrated. This significantly increases the risk of supply chain disruptions due to trade restrictions, conflict, climate impacts or other shocks affecting major producing countries.
Officials in G7 countries are particularly concerned by China’s important role in the transition minerals supply chain, due to its significant domestic resources (e.g., 60 percent of global rare earths production in 2019), overseas investments, and key processing role in many commodities. Fears that Beijing could restrict access to minerals in case of a severe geopolitical crisis (around Taiwan, for example) have motivated initiatives such as the U.S.-led Mineral Security Partnership.
Competition for transition minerals opens economic opportunities for producing countries. The imperative of securing supply was on full display at this year’s African Mining Indaba, where Mineral Security Partnership envoys met with African officials to discuss financing and other support to transition mineral mining, processing and recycling. African countries such as the Democratic Republic of the Congo are already essential suppliers of metals for electric vehicles and of other transition minerals. And Africa’s geology is also relatively underexplored; many African countries have the potential and ambition to play a more important role in mineral supply. At the 2022 Summit of the Americas, Argentina and Chile launched a bilateral lithium working group, and Bolivia and Mexico have worked to foster regional cooperation around value generation, royalties and industry standards.
Good governance—increased transparency, open public dialogue and policy reforms that advance the public interest—is essential to seize opportunities. By prioritizing good governance, transition mineral-producing countries in Africa and Latin America can leverage the opportunities presented by competition for minerals in an accelerated energy transition. To deliver a “triple win” for their citizens, the environment, and the energy transition, many of these countries need to undertake urgent policy reforms, putting mining governance (including anticorruption measures) at the center of their policy plans.
Support the increasing range of anticorruption efforts
Kleptocrats have been put on notice. The 2022 energy crisis initially prompted an “anywhere but Russia" approach. However, there is a growing call for action against kleptocrats like Vladimir Putin who use fossil fuel wealth to perpetrate instability and aggression. A year on, in Europe and North America, policymakers have ramped up measures to crack down on dirty money flowing into their jurisdictions. From Nigeria to Angola, Azerbaijan to Belarus, those who steal wealth generated from their countries’ resources to invest in property and other luxuries are already being exposed, at home and abroad.
Leadership on anticorruption will help to secure economic opportunities. Growing demand for transition minerals brings its own corruption risks. Producing countries should ensure transparency over contracts, payments, commodity trading, and beneficial ownership; implement robust measures to prevent elites from capturing opportunities; and enforce accountability mechanisms to hold wrongdoers to account. And initiatives like the Mineral Security Partnership and EU Critical Raw Materials Act must be equally tough on corruption. By focusing on this good governance, policymakers can prevent public funds leaking out into private hands, and better respect local communities, protect the environment, and prevent disruptions and delays to supply. NRGI colleagues found that of three factors identified as shortening mineral production lead times, better governance is the only one within policymakers’ control.
Prioritizing the development of new economic and energy pathways, seizing opportunities presented by transition minerals and promoting good governance will help ensure policymakers in Africa and Latin America navigate the geopolitical and market forces unleashed by the war in Ukraine for the benefit of their citizens.
The Resource Remix: Europe's Gas Crunch, African Supply, and the Energy Transition
The Resource Remix is a podcast from the Natural Resource Governance Institute exploring new futures for commodity-exporting countries in the energy transition.
In this third episode of NRGI's podcast, available on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts and Spotify, NRGI’s Silas Olan’g converses with Crystol Energy CEO Carole Nakhle and Theophilus Acheampong, economist and political risk analyst, and senior lecturer at the University of Dundee.
NRGI · The Resource Remix - Episode 3 - Europe's Gas Crunch, African Supply, and The Energy Transition
During their conversation, Nakhle, Acheampong and Olan’g explore the implications of Russia’s war in Ukraine on global energy markets, how it has prompted many countries to reevaluate their dependency on Russian oil and gas, and what Europe’s subsequent demand for gas means for African countries. They discuss whether the current geopolitical climate and market dynamic presents African oil- and gas-producing states with opportunities or risks.
With COP27 on the horizon, the three experts deliberate on whether recent developments will influence African producer countries’ energy transition plans, and to what extent. Acheampong points out how the crisis has exposed how energy security seems to come above all else, including achieving climate goals. With prevailing energy poverty across the African continent, Acheampong argues that African countries shouldn’t have to choose. Concurring, Nakhle affirms that, while domestic energy supply should be the priority for African countries, ensuring the energy transition and safeguarding energy security are not mutually exclusive. But, she adds, this hasn’t happened in practice so far, noting that governance should underpin any efforts to achieve both.
On to the topic of financing the energy transition, Olan’g highlights that the European Union, and other wealthy importers, haven’t yet met their existing climate finance commitments. Acheampong but adds that investment opportunities also exist elsewhere and must be considered.
***
Transcript:
Silsa Olan’g, NRGI: The 27th Conference of the Parties will take place in Egypt this November. The so-called African COP will be the first major climate conference in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The war has had implications on global energy markets. Much attention has focused on how African countries from the Cape up to the Mediterranean have reacted to the shockwave. For many years now we have heard that fossil fuels must go. But suddenly European countries are hunting high and low for natural gas, including in Africa. This dash for gas has exposed double standards in energy access and achieving climate goals. What opportunities might resource-rich African states have in these tumultuous times? And how will this affect African governments and citizens’ agenda at COP27?
Welcome to The Resource Remix, a podcast from the Natural Resource Governance Institute. We bring listeners dynamic perspectives on the cutting-edge issues affecting countries rich in commodities in the context of the energy transition. I am Silas Olan’g. I have been with NRGI for more than a decade. And now serve as the organization's Africa energy transition advisor based in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Two guests join me today to dive into the prospects for African countries in this new energy market landscape. Our first guest speaking to us from London is Carole Nakhle. Carole is an energy economist, founder and chief executive officer of Crystol Energy, an advisory and research firm, and a member of NRGI’s Governing Board. Carole, welcome to NRGI’s podcast.
Carole Nakhle, Crystol Energy: Hello Silas. I am very happy to join you today.
SO: Thank you. We also welcome Theo Acheampong. Theo is an economist and political risk analyst and a lecturer at the University of Dundee in Scotland where he is speaking to us from today. Theo, you are most welcome to the podcast.
Theo Acheampong, University of Dundee: Thank you very much, a pleasure to be here.
SO: Thank you both so much for joining me in this episode.
Russian invasion has prompted moves by many countries to reassess their reliance on Russian oil and gas and reduce their dependence on its imports. Many articles have sprung up with commentators, discussing how world leaders desperate for energy are turning to Africa for its reserves of oil and gas, considering them as potential beneficiaries of Europe’s supply gap. In May, the EU published its energy strategy, but the strategy leaves many unanswered questions. Carole, now that it has been some months since the initial market shock, what is the clear-eyed view of the coming two to three years? Are some of the countries likely to profit from the current context of increased European demand? If so, which countries and in which way?
CN: Thank you, Silas. Well, first of all, before I answer the question, it is very important to clarify to the listeners and viewers that the crisis we are seeing today in Europe and elsewhere – because the record high gas prices that we are seeing currently are not only in Europe but also in Asia, even North America – it is not caused by Russia's invasion of Ukraine. It is, of course, that factor that the geopolitical development plays a very important role, but it would be naive to blame it all on the war, because some dynamics have been happening in gas markets over decades, including the development of LNG trade, which I think, last year or 2020, but probably last year, if I am not mistaken, for the first time overtakes pipeline trade. So, there is this globalization of gas markets. Of course, we are very far from what we have in oil markets, but the fact that you have more LNG trade happening than originally, markets that were independent of each other – so European would not really care about what was happening to the Asians, the Asians would not care what was happening in North America – this is not the case anymore today. Today if Asia catches a cold, Europe sneezes because of LNG trade, that's very important. I am saying that right up front, because it has implications for existing and potential producers, especially exporters of LNG, whether by pipeline, for example, from North Africa to Europe, or LNG exporters, including in West Africa, but even more so in East Africa, with the likes of Mozambique. They will be facing a completely different market than, for example, what they faced a few years ago.
Now to go back to your question about the outlook for the gas situation in Europe — what that means for African producers, current and future. And I insist on “the future” because we shouldn't underestimate the role that East Africa will play in the next few years. But, first, in the short term, if I focus on this winter, because gas demand increases in winter in Europe, I am more pessimistic because you've got to see usually gas demand increase around this time. If winter is going to be as cold as it was a year ago, then we should expect the most important consequence, which is higher prices. And we're already seeing record prices across Europe, and then in the longer term, after that, things should start to ease up. But I am an economist, so I have to say that high prices may be the solution to high prices, and I say it may be, because it depends also on what governments are doing, and see, as you highlighted, that in your opening remarks about the kind of contradictions and new terms that we are seeing. Because for years, if not decades, the rich countries, the OECD countries, blamed or recommended the developing countries for giving subsidies to their people, energy subsidies for self-use subsidies. Guess what? They are doing exactly the same today and giving subsidies to the rich and poor alike. So that is one aspect. I had to get it off my chest because it really bothers me as an economist.
But if we think about the high price signal, that is pushing consumers to adjust their demand. They are looking for an alternative, they are even thinking about which room to congregate into the winter and avoid using other rooms in the house if they have more than one room, let's say, in a house. We are seeing on the biggest scale the switching from gas to a targeted source of energy. Nuclear is one option, and renewables is another option. But ironically, we are seeing a shift to coal. We are seeing a shift to oil products, such as diesel. So that is another reversal and climate change and energy policies we are seeing in Europe. And they are scrambling to find alternatives for supplies coming from Russia because Russia for decades has been the largest, or was maybe, today's not anymore, the largest supplier of gas to the continent. But that means, maybe on the face of it, you would say, Okay, that's great. That will be an opportunity for African gas producers. But there are two things I want to highlight here.
First, they are not the only ones eyeing the European markets. You have American LNG increased by more than 70 percent compared to last year for the first quarter of this year. They love to send their gas to Europe, and don't forget the American-sanctioned Nord Stream 2, the pipeline coming from Russia to Europe from last year. So, it is not after the war. It was long before the war started. So, for the Americans, the European market is very attractive. So African producers will have to face the reality that there will be greater competition from the Middle East, Qatar, for example, from elsewhere. Everybody wants to send their gas to Europe. But the second thing, and that's a big question. Does Africa have the capacity to increase its exports beyond what they have today?
Let me focus on North Africa, and I leave it there, and then I let Theo elaborate more on sub-Saharan Africa. But look at Algeria, look at Egypt, especially Algeria, its export potential has been declining because its production has not been rising as fast as its consumption. So local consumption has been growing very fast because of different unattractive, irrational policies, economically speaking, and as a result, if they don't keep up with investment, if they don't keep up with increasing production, and they don't slow down the growth in demand, I think we should be realistic about how much more Africa can send to Europe. I'll leave it there, and we can elaborate on the rest later on.
SO: Thank you very much, Carol. From what you're saying, several established producers, Algeria, Angola and Nigeria seem already well positioned to benefit from this demand. As they are already reaping higher revenues from the spike in oil and gas prices. Countries with projects due to start within the next year or so, such as Mauritius and Senegal, I think they will likely also benefit from the higher prices. Others, on the other hand, where investment decisions on key LNG projects are still pending, could end up suffering larger financial risks than benefits. I am thinking of Mozambique, for example, given security challenges, and, of course, my own country, Tanzania, due to ongoing negotiations and outstanding project design processes. Is there a risk of heightened expectations not being made for certain producer countries, especially in sub-Saharan Africa? And what are the risks associated for some countries in attempting to meet European demand? Theo, I would really like to hear your views on this.
TA: Thank you very much, Silas. And again, it is a pleasure to be here. Let me also start with a much broader-level remark, and then we can look at the specifics.
I think what is interesting is that we live in quite extraordinary times. In my relatively short life, I have seen at least three crises, if not maybe four. From the financial crisis of 2008-2009, and then the commodities price lump of 2014-2017, then we had COVID, and, just as the recovery was gaining momentum, now we're dealing with the aftershocks of the Russia-Ukraine war or conflict, and, of course, that has had some major repercussions in terms of the global energy geopolitics or the dynamics. For me, what is kind of interesting, as you already allude to in your opening remarks, is the fact that there seems to be a change in tone.
Only from a year ago, when a lot of the European and Western nations were saying, we're going on net-zero, and the environment is the key consideration, but rather we've seen energy security and issues of access and affordability becoming the dominant theme in the global energy debate going forward. And of course, some have even said that it is quite hypocritical in a sense that some of the developing countries, including those in Africa, haven't been given as much of an opportunity to also develop their own domestic energy resources, which are mostly fossil fuels, by the way. But I think the tone has changed and because Europe especially is looking to fill its energy supplies with alternative sources, Africa, then, of course, comes strongly into the question. As you rightly pointed out, in terms of the gap, or the size that needs to be filled, a couple of numbers may be able to help you put things in a better context.
Then we look at specifically which of sub-Saharan African countries are likely to benefit. If so, when and how? So? We know that Russia has about 17 percent of the world’s production of natural gas. I checked some numbers. It is about 25 Tcf and about 40 percent of the European or EU import historically has come from Russia. If we look at the African context, Africa has just about 7 percent of the world’s production of natural gas, and you're expecting to ramp this up to about 350 billion kilometers or 12.4 Tcf. The earlier production is about 9 Tcf. And if you look at how much the size of the gap is, I don't think that African countries would be able to fill that in the short term.
So there are several issues, but it really comes down, in my view, to about four, some of which Carole talks about. The first one is the availability of spare capacity or how much countries would really be able to ramp up their production even the one year to be able to augment the sort of supply deficit that the Europeans are looking for. And related to that are also issues of logistics and infrastructure. If I take Nigeria, for example, which has the highest gas reserves in Africa at about 207 Tcf. Last year they were only able to produce 2 Tcf. And exported 1 Tcf out of that. Predominantly it comes down to financing issues. It comes down even to issues of theft of petroleum products, including the landscape or the regulatory landscape not being fully harmonized. So, I think it is not really a problem of reserves per se. But how fast African countries can ramp up that production. And this is where given the logistical issues, given that the gas markets are not fully formed, I don't really see any potential beneficiaries in at least the one-year outlook, I think. Of course, we've seen Italy trying to negotiate for more gas from the likes of Algeria and Egypt, and some of the production may go up, but in terms of sub-Saharan Africa, when I look at Nigeria, or Equatorial Guinea, or Mauritania, Senegal, or Mozambique, and Tanzania, or even Republic of Congo, I think, in the one year highly unlikely. Beyond that, in maybe two to three, you can even say four years, there is a possibility of that happening. But again, it takes a lot to develop these gas projects and policy will play a role, regulation will play a role, and ultimately even the direction of the war will play a role in terms of these alternative supplies from the likes of the US and the other Middle Eastern countries who are able to much more quickly ramp up capacity and take market share.
SO: Thank you very much. So yes, capacity is a real issue, and because we’re are looking into one year, two years is okay. But there is a big question as to how long Europe will continue demanding gas, given that they are also developing their own energy transition. So indeed, Europe is looking for gas now and not necessarily in the long term, which may lead to a disconnect somehow, because we're looking at, on the one hand, the capacity gap requires significant investment in Africa, for example, producing countries. On the other hand, Europe is also going for the countries, as you mentioned, the US and others. So I think Europe is looking really for renewables as well, and this is where the disconnect is.
This is a warning to gas-producing countries in Africa when setting their priorities, as you talk about setting up the policies, but if they are setting the policies looking into the European market, while the European market, again, is trying to focus on renewables, what does this mean in terms of a long-term engagement with Europe from African producer countries?
CN: What you're touching on is a very important question that I asked myself recently when I wrote an article on policy confusion that you are seeing across the Western countries, in particular the EU and North America, and the UK as well. In the sense that we see these governments are asking, oil companies are asking oil and gas producers across the world, including Africa, to produce more oil and gas, and send it across to Europe to help them temporarily with the crisis. But, as we all know, oil and gas projects are by their own nature long-term. So by the time you take the investment decision to commit the capital, it will take a couple of years before you start producing, and then you're not going to produce for a year or two. You are hoping to produce for the next 20-30 years, and if the outlook for those 20-30 years is hugely uncertain, then why would you bother and commit today? So this is really the fair position and questioning that existing producers are telling those consumers. Those consumers are telling them we want your gas, but only to help us through the crisis, to help us through this winter, and maybe next, until we beef up our capacity of nuclear and renewable energy.
But let me tell you an example of a country that doesn't often come to my mind. And this is a European country, Norway. So, just to understand the position of African countries. Let's look at a country in Norway, that is the closest to the EU in everything culturally, values, principles, legislations, regulations, you name it.
Norway made it very clear in May. The Minister of Energy said it openly. If Europe commits to buying more gas for the long term, we can help it replace Russian gas. And that's why, a month or two later, if I am not mistaken, there was EU-Norway energy cooperation where the EU openly said that it supports Norway's continuous exploration and production of oil and gas for 2030 and beyond. So that was a clear reassurance that the EU gave to Norway to say, we'll continue buying your oil and gas, continue investing. Why would it be a different position for African countries? So African countries should also get the same commitment from European customers who are desperate for gas that they want to maintain their gas demand for many years to come. if they don't want it., there is China on its own. If you look at the expected increase and the demand for China for the next few years on its own, it can capture all the additional capacity in expansion in liquified natural gas and LNG. So this goes back to the point I said earlier about the globalization of gas markets. It is not any more Europe on its own telling producers, “send me your gas.” If Europe is not going to be more linear and understand the position of oil and gas producers in Africa, Europe will lose it to Asian consumers who are very hungry for natural gas.
SO: Thank you very much. As we approach COP27, it is important to consider the impact of recent developments on the energy transition that we have been speaking about and the implications for African producer countries and their energy transition plans. Theo, you have shared elsewhere how wealthy countries have not delivered on their climate finance promise to sub-Saharan African countries. Some people have suggested that African countries shouldn’t pursue plans to extract gas in a world of crisis and gas supply crisis, balancing the climate crisis and gas supply crisis somewhat competing. And can be tricky. Should issues, such as who gets to extract fossil fuels and which projects are financed, be revisited in the pursuit of a more equitable energy transition? Is Europe’s sudden interest in African gas hypocritical, especially as Europe pressures African country to meet green goals or potential revenues from gas is worth it? Theo, you have spoken a lot about that.
TA: Yeah, very interesting question. And let me piggyback to what Carole said earlier. If Norway can still produce oil and gas in 2030 and beyond, if the UK in their new energy strategy clearly outlined the role of oil and gas, even in the US, again, oil and gas being a mainstay even in 2030 and beyond, then I ask myself, why must it be different for Africa in that sense? Because at the end of the day what this crisis has shown above all else is that energy security comes first. And Africa for that matter must also prioritize meeting its own domestic energy security needs. And then the rest, of course, for export to wherever the market may be. And as Carole actually told us, the market is not necessarily in Europe, and if you do a 30-40-year demand projection, the market is elsewhere outside of Europe, and the technology is also available now to even produce some of these fossil fuel resources and reduce the carbon intensity of that production process.
In my sort of limited world where I sit, I don't really see a disconnect between the climate objectives and energy security in terms of access and affordability, what we typically in literature will call “the energy trilemma,” and more so, for Africa, because, again, what this conflict has shown, and even COVID has also shown is that we have very fragile energy systems, you have deepening or prevailing energy poverty on the continent, and we need all the resources to be able to address those concerns around energy security, and in that regard the fewer choice to plug that gap, I don't think African countries should be forced into the binary whole of having to choose between renewables and/or oil and gas in that matter. When you even talk specifically about the overall emissions, if you take Africa as a whole, it is actually less than 4 percent of the total CO2 emissions cumulatively to date. If you look even specifically within the energy systems of many African countries, I argue, that it is largely already decarbonized except for South Africa, where coal is the most dominant. So I think the issue of the just and equitable transition is very much paramount at the heart of the continent.
But it shouldn't be made to look as though you have to choose one particular technology option and/or the other. When it comes to the financing issues again, this is where you see quite a bit of geopolitics also at play. So we know from some estimates, including a very recent study done by the climate policy initiative that Africa as a whole, needs about 250 billion every year between 2020 and 2030. We are already two years into that. If you look at last year's numbers and the flux, the continent got just a little around 30 billion coming in terms of these financing flows. And, interestingly, most of them actually went into mitigation, less into adaptation, where the research also shows African countries are heavily exposed, and even on the financing flows, many of these are coming in as loans interest-bearing commercial laws, and less as grants. So, in a sense, you see a lot of African countries caught in this quagmire. But I don't think that the solution should be one to force a technology choice on African countries, one even in Europe, the main producers as to exploring their oil and gas deposits and number two, the issue of the financing, I think, is going to be absolutely critical, especially at COP where many of the financing flows would need to be increased, and when it comes to things of the mitigation financing, and of course, the other one, which I forgot to mention, is the issue of loss and damage for historical emissions.
SO: I cannot agree with you more. Indeed, in a recent media appearance, my colleague, Thomas Scurfield also noted that European Union and wealthy countries, in general, must meet their existing climate and finance commitment before new European Union investment commitment and funding pledges can be taken seriously, particularly in Africa, where they have not made those bridges.
Building on sustainable and reliable domestic energy systems is another crucial aspect that's just mentioned. I think in the end, in the EU energy strategy this has not been clearly addressed, and many of the commentators in the Western media also noted that. But today, 600 million people in Africa still lack access to electricity and Europe wants to find as much gas as possible in Africa and other regions. It doesn’t sufficiently support energy access for market references on the need to diversify its own energy sources. I think, Carole, you mentioned this before. What are and should be the priorities for export business domestic consumption in Africa? I would like to hear from both of you.
CN: For long we all believed that in the case of gas, and in particular in the case of Africa especially, I think, the priority should be given to the local market, to the domestic market. Because if you want to really have economic development, you need to give access to energy.
You need to allow that access by developing the local market, by putting the regulations in place, the right pricing systems in place, to build the infrastructure. So if you have gas, and that's why gas by large remains a regional business, and a big chunk of the gas produced is consumed locally, why would it be any different in Africa? I think the main problem in Africa is domestically because of the institutional side, because of the investment climate, and these are things that African countries need to really work on improving the governance of the sector. If they are to seize your portion of the golden opportunity that no other country maybe has in this way, or onahe same scale, not only in terms of oil and gas resources and reserves.
We forget that Africa is very rich in the critical minerals needed for the energy transition. And that's why I will go back to the point that you made. We don't need to choose between oil and gas and green energy, because Africa is blessed with resources that allow the production of both to meet the energy transition while safeguarding energy security. But the experiences show that it is not if you have the resources in the ground you're going to benefit. Look at Venezuela — they have the largest proven reserves in the world, and yet they are not among the largest oil producers in the world because of what was well-known as the resource curse. So let me keep my answer brief to your question, and say, the domestic market should take precedence, but that will not be developed automatically, you need to put in place the right institutional framework to allow that to happen so that everybody benefits from the resources that you have, and the export market can be developed in parallel but should not be given priority over the domestic market.
TA: Just to add a bit to Carole's point, an interesting point, we've been doing some bit of exercise just to see if you doubled Africa's current electricity output to bridge the access deficit, how much more emissions would that contribute if you even had a major chunk of that coming by way of natural gas. And what is quite remarkable is that even if we double the output of power on the continent using the same energy mix as currently pertains, it Is still going to contribute less than 5 percent of the total cumulative greenhouse emissions in that regard. The point here is that seeking to export gas from Africa for me is not necessarily a bad idea, but as Carole said, the important thing is also to develop the regional gas markets.
I have been involved in a few studies, and you can find that there are significant constraints in terms of developing these markets. However, we have an opportunity now with the Africa Continental free trade area to work on some of these issues, such as having harmonized gas pricing, regime, the issues about the investment requirements, and I think some of the sovereign wealth funds on the continent need to think about pulling some of their resources together, because, after all, if the money is not going to be coming from Europe and other places, if they decide to pull out the investment, we still need to develop these gas markets and there are other groups of money even domestically on the continent, with the sovereign world funds, but also some of the pension funds, et cetera, to put into some of these investment. And of course, you need to address all the regulatory and political risk issues and ensure that you are pricing the gas appropriately and doing that based on what must go to industry, and which ones must go for domestic consumption. Because if we don't develop those regional gas markets, and it is all about export, export, export, then, unfortunately, it is still going to be, in my view, the same old colonial extractivist model, which has dominated the geopolitical order for the last 400 years, with very little trickle-down effects for livelihoods on the continent.
SO: Thank you. To what extent do you think COP27 will be a moment for settling some of these questions? Are there many questions still out there?
TA: I think going into COP27, there are three key things: the issue of energy access, the issue of climate financing, and all around the issue of just transition. But I think really what is important here is that historically, Africa has not had a unified strategy on most of these issues. I think, going into COP, we, as a continent, must present a unified strategy, and the strategy should detail, in my view, our unique circumstances, but also highlight the role that oil and gas would play as an important fuel choice for any decarbonization pathway for the continent. I am not talking about other continents. I am only talking specifically about oil in Africa. In that regard, both oil and gas and renewables would for sure play a big part of that agenda.
I am just worried that the attempt to force this different pathway like it is this and not that, is going to push a lot of the already existing assets for reserves and make them potentially even become stranded in the first instance, and that would already have a cascading impact on the worst energy poverty that we were talking about with about half of the continent not having access to electricity, so the strategy is important, highlighting unique circumstances, and also advocating for more of the financing flows on the continent. And lastly, things around the critical minerals for transition where many of the countries on the continent have one form or the other. But to really make an opportunity out of it, it must be developed on a regional basis.
SO: Thank you, Carole and Theo, for joining me today for this episode of the NRGI podcast. This has been a very interesting conversation, leaving us with a lot of food for thought on what really constitutes a just transition.
For our listeners: please check out the first two episodes on your preferred platforms. We are on SoundCloud, YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts and Google Podcasts. Do join us in the next episode. Thank you.
Disclaimer: Views and opinions expressed in this podcast belong to the individuals featured and do not necessarily represent those of the Natural Resource Governance Institute. The recording and transcript have been edited and condensed for clarity.
NRGI's podcast The Resource Remix explores new futures for commodity-exporting countries in the energy transition.
VIDEO: Europe's Hypocrisy Over Africa's Gas?
Examining which countries in Africa can increase gas production in the next few years, Scurfield highlights Nigeria's and Angola's liquefied natural gas (LNG) plants' spare capacity to extract more gas and supply gas to Europe if appropriate investment are made.
Projects that can’t come online until 2030 probably won’t have much of a market in Europe to supply at that point.
He adds: “But there are other countries where production is a lot further off. A country like Tanzania, that has had an LNG project plan for over a decade, hasn’t yet reach an investment decision and is unlikely to do so before 2025, meaning production won’t start until 2030. It seems like those sort of projects won’t be able to meet Europe’s needs and make the most of this opportunity from this supply crunch, given that Europe is looking to find other sources of gas right now, but actually in the longer term its main response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine is to accelerate its energy transition. And it is looking to reduce its gas consumption by 40 percent by 2030. So projects that can’t come online until then probably won’t have much of a market in Europe to supply at that point."
Scurfield also stresses that the European Union and wealthy countries in general must meet their existing climate finance commitments before new European Union investment commitments and funding pledges can be taken seriously: "It [the European Union] still isn’t providing the 100 billion USD dollars of climate finance a year that it promised back in 2009 that it would provide by 2020. It didn’t in 2020. It didn’t in 2021. And it doesn’t look like it will do in 2022. So this package of support does holds some promise, but it’s hard to take it seriously until these exciting climate finance commitments are met."
On the question of whether Africa should invest in costly pipelines that require years of planning and construction, given Europe's demand outlook, Scurfield is sceptical that by the time the pipelines are built and can deliver gas, the market in Europe will be large enough to make investing in these projects truly profitable.
He says, "There’s a worry that governments from the countries involved in those, because of the likely private investor reluctance to get involved or at least cover all the costs, would stump up a significant amount of the money required and then those pipelines wouldn’t actually generate the expected returns. There is a real risk of those pipelines being talked up now because of this hype around European demand, but them actually becoming stranded assets and a real dead weight on the public finances of the countries involved.”
Europe’s demand for Africa’s gas
Read key insights from NRGI expertsThe Resource Remix: Ana Carolina González Espinosa and Daniel Kaufmann Discuss New Resource Governance Paradigms
In this second episode of NRGI's podcast, available on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts and Spotify, Ana Carolina González Espinosa converses with NRGI president emeritus Daniel Kaufmann about evolutions needed in the resource governance field in light of the climate emergency, the conflict in Ukraine, and other global challenges.
NRGI · The Resource Remix - Episode 2 - Toward New Resource Governance Paradigms
During their conversation, Kaufmann explains what is meant by resource governance, where the field of resource governance came from, and what important organizations have played a role in this field. They also discuss the results of the 2021 survey Kaufmann and colleagues conducted among hundreds of participants on the future of natural resource governance in the era of the energy transition. Kaufmann highlights some of the top priorities for reform cited by respondents, including protecting democracy, addressing state capture, high-level corruption, and climate emergency. Although these dimensions received very high priority, respondents were more pessimistic about the likelihood of progress in these areas, informs Kaufmann.
Looking at the systemic challenges facing the world today, Kaufmann and Gonzalez discusses the actors that must drive change and the bold strategies that should target these various stakeholders, including the state, the public and private sectors, and international institutions. Gonzalez stresses the importance of going beyond mobilizing traditional actors working in the natural resource governance field to bring about change. The organizations mentioned includes women's and youth organizations, indigenous and peace groups, and other grassroots movements operating differently from traditional NGOs.
Other dimensions explored includes the importance of changing the narrative of the global energy transition, which is driven primarily by the Global North, and the importance of including the voices of producer countries to push for more concrete commitments on climate finance to ensure that the energy transition is actually possible in these countries as well.
Daniel Kaufmann and Mario Picon also addressed a related topic in this commentary by the Brookings Institution.
***
Transcript
Ana Carolina González Espinosa: Some of the most critical issues in the world today are linked with the way we govern natural resources. From Russia’s war funded by oil revenues to the existential threat of climate emergency, many also relate to the commodities in the earth beneath us. For example, we want to transition to sustainable energy, so we reduce carbon emissions and fight climate change that can lead to so many of the world's natural resources.
But to do that, for these renewable energies to be used on a larger scale, the extraction of certain minerals that are needed has to be on a larger scale as well: the lithium and cobalt that go into electric car batteries, just to name some. And that also comes with an enormous challenge:
avoiding that the extraction of these minerals negatively impacts on countries and communities, and instead benefits them. So it is about governing natural resources in a way that avoids funding the world’s kleptocrats, or in a form that ensures communities and countries benefit from them.
And today, many people and organizations work to ensure this happens. But how do all these organizations and people get here, in what we call the natural resource governance field? And where should we go, given the new nature of the challenges that are emerging? Are the same policy recommendations of past decades are still relevant? Do we need to rethink our assumptions, and how? Do we need other models, pathways, bolder ideas about what resource governance is?
I am Ana Carolina González, senior director for programs at the Natural Resource Governance Institute. And these are the issues we at NRGI grapple with every day and also in this podcast series, The Resource Remix. It is my pleasure to welcome to this podcast NRGI’s former president and CEO Daniel Kaufmann. Dani is a pioneer in the field of governance at the World Bank, now affiliated with the University of the Philippines, the Brookings Institution, and Resources for Development. Welcome, Dani.
Daniel Kaufmann: Thank you very much. It is an enormous pleasure and honor to be with you and with the whole NRGI family again. And it’s such an important topic that you have outlined.
ACG: Dani, I started by speaking about some of the critical current events related to resource governance. You have been writing and presenting about this seismic shift for the past few years. But for those of us with shorter memories, can you quickly get us up to speed on what is meant by resource governance and where the field of resource governance came from?
DK: Thanks. I am glad you’re inquiring into this historical perspective, not only because without history, we misunderstand the present and we will keep repeating past mistakes in the future, but also because it puts into context the sense that the field of natural resource governance is at the crossroads right now. You see, contrary to popular beliefs, concerns about natural resource governance, which refers to the good stewardship of the natural resource features of the country for the benefit of all, for the growth development and benefit of all, did not just start in the U.K. and with the likes of Tony Blair and others two decades ago.
In fact, in the early 1700s, the British publication The Spectator wrote, “It is generally observed, that in countries of the greatest plenty, there is the poorest living.” So this is a longstanding concern, the increasing traction to the idea that resources might be more of an economic curse than a blessing began to emerge in the 1950s and ’60s with the analysis of challenges in developing countries. In the early ’90s, there were writings already about how countries rich in resources were unable to use that wealth to boost their economies, especially compared with non-resource-rich countries, and then the likes of Jeffrey Sachs and other academics, found a very strong correlation between natural resource abundance and poor economic performance. In the ’60s, thanks to the concerns in the Netherlands that they had just found plenty of natural gas and were earning fresh foreign exchange, a particular economic policy dimension of the resource curse garnered attention, namely the exchange rate of evaluation, which discouraged non-resource exports, the so-called Dutch disease. We can call this “Resource Curse 1.0,” and we are talking more than half a century ago, the very economic manifestations of the resource curse. Only after the turn of the century, that very economic focus begins to take on also a governance dimension, very seriously, beyond traditional economics, “Resource Curse 2.0.” And we enter at that point, what I would call, the “soft governance” era, which focuses very much on transparency in extractives, and particularly at the beginning, transparency of payments of the industry to governments, to have full disclosure, to the extent possible, which still has not happened until today.
NGOs, like Global Witness, were pioneers, which later led to the creation of Publish What You Pay. In this space they influence the U.K., and eventually, this leads to the inception of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative or EITI. And all this is also a predecessor to the support given by NRGI at that time, which was called Revenue Watch Institute, obviously Revenue Watch Institute, the predecessor of NRGI plays an important role in this process as well. Then about a decade ago, the increasing realization that transparency may be absolutely necessary, but it’s far from sufficient, results in an increasing focus on participation and accountability, or what we call sometimes “the TAP troika,” i.e., transparency, accountability, and participation. Among others, the notion of protection of civic space becomes important and we work hard to institutionalize those protections in initiatives like in the EITI and elsewhere, and that begins to happen.
And the evidence did show that improved transparency, improved participation and accountability could help mitigate some forms of corruption. And that is all part of this governance “Resource Curse 2.0” package. But again, more recently, it becomes clear that this focus was also insufficient, leading to the case we have been making for broadening the governance scope and natural resource governance, sometimes called “TAP plus.” So going beyond the TAP troika into very tough rule of law, reform issues, regulatory reform issues, public sector reforms, state-owned enterprise reform, particularly with national oil companies; and very timidly, a start with the so-called energy transition.
In brief, that is where we are now. But with two pending key dimensions, which we can discuss later of the resource course that we have not gotten the focus in the natural resource governance field that it deserves, even if there are some initiatives here and there, but they fit as a whole, one, which we can call the “Resource Curse 3.0,” and label it as the tough governance dimension. Let's call it for what it should be called: tyranny, conflict and climate crisis. And the other “Resource Curse 4.0” related, which is a corporate resource curse. It’s the corporate dimension of the resource curse—the capture by industry, like oligarchs, and their collusion with the kleptocrats.
ACG: And it is very interesting, Dani, that you take us back to very early days in history because when you discuss natural resource governance, what might think that it all started at least with some emblematic initiatives or conversations. I remember particularly that report Global Witness published in 1999 denouncing corruption in Angola in the oil sector and demanding companies to disclose the payments that were being made to the government as an incentive to avoid corruption. And then the emergency of Publish What You Pay, EITI, where NRGI actually took a very active part. But a lot of things had happened. And all the people are still, of course, interested in having information about these payments. What you see in the case of popular consultations in mining regions in Colombia or what you hear from local communities in South Africa that are asking for them to be included in just transition plans, is that people are no longer looking only for information, or even as you mentioned, for transparency, accountability and participation. People are no longer looking only to hold governments and companies to account. They want to decide, they want to influence decision-making. They want a share of power.
So while we have made important gains in transparency around the extraction of oil, gas, and minerals, we clearly aren’t where we need to be. You have been promoting major change for some time already, but do you think organizations in the field are asking these fundamental questions? I know that you took the lead in designing and implementing a survey, in which NRGI and a hundred other participants took part, in relation to these. So, you and your colleague are publishing a report on it. So what have you found?
DK: When we asked hundreds of respondents to identify the most important priorities for reforms, some of these very tough governance dimensions that we just mentioned—including the protection of democracy, addressing state capture and high-level corruption and the climate emergency—all came out addressed as a very high priority. That is not very surprising. But the same respondents were rather pessimistic about the likelihood of progress in those areas. There is a huge gap between stated priority and likelihood in their view. But that’s not the case when we ask them questions about the traditional ongoing areas of work in the field, such as continuing the work on disclosures and transparency that started 20 years ago. They don’t give it the absolute top priority, a bit lower, but the likelihood of being successful is fine. So consistent with that, there are lots of people in the field that are comfortable continuing with that trajectory, because at least the probability of failure is lower since it’s much lower hanging fruit.
Then when we asked these respondents about what kind of transitions were needed in the various natural resources. Those in the natural resource governance field were more gradualist and conservative regarding moving away from fossil fuels than those outside of the field, which is telling in itself. Surprising regarding this set of findings, civil society respondents—because we asked all stakeholders, industry, government, international financial institutions and civil society were involved—but civil society respondents on average were basically as risk-averse, as the respondents from the other stakeholders, governance and IFIs. I mean, there are some small differences, but you don’t find a huge difference there.
There were some exceptions, of course, there are rays of hope. And in terms of some respondents wanting and believing that something bolder is possible and giving also bolder type of recommendations as to what to do ahead. On average—this is not universal, it’s not a one-to-one correlation—but on average, that’s associated with younger and female respondents, interestingly enough. So that’s a message right there. They were not the norm though. The norm was risk aversion and comfort. So overall, we do find some risk aversion and measure of conformance, one of which is not really consistent with seismic global shifts that are taking place that we have been discussing. So the case in the report for much more audacity associated with concrete and bolder change is being made.
ACG: You mentioned that the respondents in the survey highlighted unsurprisingly, the effects of the COVID pandemic on the economy and the unsettling that comes with not knowing what is going to happen with the economy in producing countries. And also, of course, the climate crisis and the challenges that come with the energy transition, for example, for oil, gas and minerals producing countries because that is also consistent with what we have been observing in NRGI. And also the rising authoritarian regimes and the growing restrictions on civic space.
But a couple of additional changes that are important to take into consideration, and maybe are related to what you mentioned about the different role young people and women can play, is that there is an important change, and I am observing this as well, in terms of how the field can require multidisciplinary perspectives. And so the traditional organizations working mostly around resource governance need to add other movements to the conversation, right? We need to build bridges with other movements with the climate movements, the human rights organizations, tax organizations and other, because the challenges that we are facing today are so systemic that require us to build coalitions outside of the traditional actors, in what we call the natural resource governance field.
And even beyond them, something that the actors in the field might need to do as well is to acknowledge that with the social protests of the last few years, an important number of new actors of social movements have emerged also in producing countries, even in the context of deep restrictions to civic space. So even with people knowing that it’s difficult to participate, wanting to participate more. So women’s organizations, youth organizations, indigenous and peace organizations, or more grassroots movements and networks—they operate very differently from NGOs, but they are key actors when we think about how to make change happen. That is one thing I would like to stress—there is a need to build bridges also with these social movements.
And on the other hand, another change that I think has happened and requires the field to kind of be bothered is that, when we think about the actors that we need to target to push for change—the state, the public sector, remain key and central. And we know that we need bold strategies to target private sector. As you mentioned, like the corporate sector’s responsibility for resource governance and international institutions for change—that’s not very new either. But sometimes we might have overlooked the role of media narrative, not just to disseminate information. It is not just about influencing decision-makers but to influence public narrative. The way people see natural resources playing in their countries, in their territories, the power of moving the needle in public opinion, to then create a stronger and maybe longer-term incentive for decision-makers to act.
For example, how to influence the narrative of the global energy transition that is mainly driven by the Global North to include the voices of producing countries, to push for more concrete commitments in terms of climate finance, so we ensure the energy transition is actually possible in those countries as well. For that, you need to change narratives at a wider level and strategic communications and alliances are key for that.
So it looks like we might need some more paradigmatic change here. How can we make this possible, especially given what you’ve mentioned in terms of some risk aversion between organizations in the field and between other actors in the field. What are the opportunities that you see, but also the barriers that we might need to overcome? We have been, recently discussing in NRGI about encouraging such a discussion, but what do you think are the elements we should consider?
DK: We need to consider a bolder approach, whether that will signify paradigmatic change or not, that’s for another podcast. Let me give you just a few ideas and suggestions. I would ask, why aren't we making more progress now? You mentioned multidisciplinary approaches: this has been taking place for a long time and now more is needed, nobody will disagree with that. But a bolder version of that in the current situation is to say, we need the most extreme form of partnership, not only in terms of discipline but in terms of also the focus on good research and analysis and activism. The most extreme form of partnership is a merger. We did one almost 10 years ago, combining Revenue Watch with the Natural Resource Charter, and became NRGI, but they’re extremely rare.
The incentives in the field among NGOs, media, more user-friendly storytelling, and all that. That's very nice, and we have been discussing that for a very, very long time. But right now, as we see in the world and in the worst-governed places regarding hydrocarbons and so on, we need to protect and support the toughest type of investigative journalists and to get these stories out in places where everything is being banned, everything is secret, and journalists have been put in jail.
But in addition, why not consider a major scaling up in addressing the huge remaining misgovernance within fossil fuels themselves due to the actions and the capture by big oil, by the kleptocrats, by the rulers of oil-rich countries; that’s really tough. And how do we do it? It’s a different discussion. There are some staff at NRGI and other places that are working on that, but these are niche issues. These are not being integrated into the core of what the field should be doing.
Why also don't we fully expose without mincing words—we have to use a different language—the massive greenwashing in the whole ESG industry, by the corporates, which we can discuss at very much like.
Then take the national oil companies. Why continue to fiddle at the margin regarding taking a little measure here or there on additional disclosure and a few changes in corporate governance, when some of them are totally captured politically? It’s been high time for years to consider a very different model in those settings. Even if that's very politically difficult, instead of trying the same reforms at the margin in places, in organizations and institutions that may be unreformable.
ACG: Maybe also that I would add Dani is in terms of having the conversation, I totally agree with you. This is about having a conversation on a podcast, but it cannot be just that. It’s about who participates in the conversation and the form it takes. And again, who participates in the conversation, we need new voices, we need additional voices to the ones that have traditionally been associated with the ways of natural resource governance, including people in other fields, social movements, universities in the Global South, Global South think tanks… And journalists as actors, they are not just targets for us, as you say, to disseminate information, et cetera. They are very important actors in the field as well.
But in relation to the how, how do we get there? How do we promote this change that the field needs? How do we take these conversations that are happening maybe in podcasts or in many interesting meetings here and there in a specific context? What if we have this conversation in specific territories, in specific countries, and if we look for experience where those changes are already in play in the way organizations, communities, or other actors are pushing for resource governance in this new era, instead of a bottom-up approach to learning, to understanding what resource governance means today.
And what if we learn also from other movements; we are not the first movement to face the need for change, like the human rights movement has also faced many changes in the last decades. What if we pilot as we learn new ways of understanding this natural resource governance and innovative ways again to communicate and provide visibility to the process and to specific efforts that maybe are small, or we don’t know them yet. What if we provide some visibility to those? It is less about big words and more about interesting, even if small, actions.
DK: In terms of, very concretely speaking, the whole issue of bringing in different voices and addressing this problem of state capture: Let me mention a very concrete examples that the field could engage more with. One is my own country, Chile, with a newly elected, youngest president in the world, Boric. But at the same time, a new constitution is being drafted, we don't know yet if it's going to be approved by the whole population. But it is being drafted in the most participatory manner ever of any constitution anywhere. So we are having that as we speak. Now Chile is the number-one producer of copper in the world. So it would be extremely fertile to collaborate with that case study and draw the lessons of the art of the possible in this context.
ACG: I think I also remained positive about what can come. It’s not easy, path dependency is always there, this idea of continuing doing what how to do, what you have been doing for so long. But I think that the time has come when we need to be bolder and think about other layers because the challenges are so huge that we definitely need to build bridges with other movements and see how to push change forward. But the problem is also that the context might not be helping that much. So what do you think about the impact of the war in Ukraine, and how do you think these new trends in the international commodities market energy markets can actually maybe delay or maybe be an opportunity for this conversation and this major change to materialize?
DK: At the end of the day, it is a question of mindset and preparedness to take risks, because one way of looking at what's happening now is to say that there have been extremely adverse developments, and we know where they are. You have mentioned them, we have written about that. So it’s time to protect former gains, to hunker down and be very careful about going in directions of trying to address the enormity of these new challenges, because politically they may be intractable, and the probability of success is obviously much less than protecting early gains and continue to work on what we are accustomed to. So that would be a safer, risk-adverse way.
The other option is to say, maybe continue to do the same, that may be safer, and we will not have a huge failure, but the impact is going to be so small and we’re going to become irrelevant given the new developments. So there is absolutely no choice but to consider a strategy with much more audacity and boldness, and then the question becomes what to address.
Let's face it—and I mentioned and hinted at it earlier—we are in that era now (and you mentioned the war context, Putin’s invasion of Ukraine), in which it has become very clear that there are hydrocarbon-fueled wars and invasions of other countries. This is so well beyond these soft notions of governance—that we need more transparency than we have had in the past. So it is the notion that’s a completely different dimension of the resource curse. Because of that, we know that it is not just the climate crisis challenges, that we all know, and it’s been ongoing and it’s becoming worse, but there are major energy security considerations. As a result, many other countries in Europe and others are not only considering but are approving really fast major new investment plans. And also because the oil and gas prices have gone through the roof. So NRGI and others could be monitoring these proposals and actions in terms of more, not less, new investments in hydrocarbons, and particularly LNG and so on.
And obviously, there are enormous trade-offs with energy security and so on. There’s a bit less of a discussion because it’s so difficult politically to say, “no, this is absolutely disastrous for the climate crisis.”
We have to put it very starkly, at the end of the day, countries are going to face either stranded assets or climate catastrophe. So these two choices, unless we do something really, really boldly, and just calling into action and showing with the numbers, what is happening and showing also the differences, what can be done next year versus the next five years, is really important. And that’s why I put it into the mix.
We have to discuss issues like nuclear power. We also have to discuss demand destruction. Again, it’s a political taboo in the United States, with a carbon tax, and so on, but basically the obsession with oil consumption has to shift and it’s beginning to shift in some countries, and in fact, some European countries have decarbonized relatively quickly.
We are not talking enough about great examples in Africa. In Kenya, there is a large amount of electrification with renewables thanks to major wind and solar projects, in which the African Development Bank is involved. There are a number of other examples. Instead we focus so much on how much they're going to lose in revenues if they don't produce as much in terms of oil.
Of course, we have to be mindful: these countries are not the main carbon emitters. So that’s not where the main problem is. And they have not benefited from hydrocarbons the way the West has. So the issue is one of climate justice. But because of that, my suggestion for a topic that should take much more prominence is major compensation mechanism; a Marshall Plan-like mechanism may be needed. There is a concrete example of what some European Union countries and Canada did a few months ago with $8 billion for South Africa to start phasing out coal. So again, it’s not academic, it's about very concrete areas where things can change. And we need to think big and say, how do we scale these up? What would be the proposal?
If we’re going to have audacity, to really try new things, we’re going to take a risk and we are going to fail as well as succeed. So we do not want to fail at everything, but, and that’s a difference in mindset that needs to be changed. And that’s why the fresh blood, the new voices… And having frank conversations with boards, and with funders, is very important at this stage. The world has changed dramatically.
ACG: One of the things you mentioned was the impact of the war in Ukraine and the need to monitor what is happening out there in terms of new investments and new plans to expand gas and oil exploitation. It is something that we have been following very closely, especially because this raises a lot of expectations in the producing countries. You have already seen how countries in Africa like Tanzania or Senegal mention the possibility of expanding their old gas fields to supply the European market with their gas. And, of course, there are a lot of things to discuss, that we don't have time to discuss.
One of the things that we have recommended in our reports and blogs is that Europe needs to be clear about this, and needs to make bolder commitments in terms of not only providing itself with the energy that it deserves, so energy security is a priority—but also making sure that the energy transition in these [producing] countries is not delayed because of this new move. I think what you mentioned about the need for climate finance to be much more deliberate, meaningful and intentional to really move the needle on energy transition in these countries is very important.
And the other thing I wanted to mention is, it’s also about the model, because if we want to just expand renewable energies or other types of exploitation of critical minerals to provide those renewable energies in the same way that we have been developing in the last three or four or five decades, it is just not going to be possible. We need to listen to other movements. We need to listen to the climate movement, but we also need to listen to the communities that are proposing new development models as well. And to examine also our consumption patterns and see how they can be modified, and how we can learn from others as well.
DK: You said we need to listen. I would say we need to merge.
ACG: That too, definitely. We start by listening and then we need to merge and, and build bridges and build coalitions. Thank you, Dani. This has been a great conversation, definitely not the last one on this topic. It is clear from what we have discussed that at least our thoughts align in terms of the need for a bolder change. I would call it for maybe a new resource governance paradigm or different paradigms around natural research governance. Imagine from a different context and different regions, et cetera, but definitely, something that puts policy at the center, that builds bridges across movements and social movements and sectors and perspectives, and a natural resource governance framework that includes at least the hard tough reforms that you mentioned that are needed, including of course being more intentional about fighting kleptocracy and ensuring that people have a seat at the table in decision making. So thanks for these. And I hope we will have the time to continue this conversation and others in other Resource Remix podcasts.
DK: Thank you very much.
Disclaimer: Views and opinions expressed in this podcast belong to the individuals featured and do not necessarily represent those of the Natural Resource Governance Institute. The recording and transcript have been edited and condensed for clarity.
NRGI's podcast The Resource Remix explores new futures for commodity-exporting countries in the energy transition.
A Call to Action: Advancing Civic Space in the Extractive Sector
Shrinking civic space in resource-rich countries
Civic space is under threat from forces within and across borders. Russian authorities have grievously compromised the sovereignty of the Ukrainian people; they have also brutally suppressed opposition to the invasion within Russia as part of a sustained crackdown on Russians’ civic freedoms. In Myanmar, the military government abused pandemic emergency measures to further restrict civic space; we’ve seen the same trend in Uganda. And in Nigeria brutality by police and security forces reached a terrible peak in 2021.
In countries where the call for transition to clean energy threatens interests vested in the fossil fuel sector, civil society is coming under increasing threat. The challenges faced by Ghanaian organizations questioning the Aker Energy deal is one example.
Efforts to strengthen and defend civic space have been central to the NRGI’s work since its founding. At the global level, we help to design and implement civic space safeguards through multi-stakeholder initiatives like the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) and the Open Government Partnership (OGP). In meetings of the EITI international board, NRGI fought for the adoption and implementation of the EITI Civil Society Protocol. Yet too often governments and companies balk at enforcing these protocols when it comes to calling out specific countries—as happened recently in the Philippines.
In parallel with these standards, NRGI works in resource-producing countries with local civil society and media actors to build their sector expertise and to guard against harassment and intimidation. We also work with governments to promote multi-stakeholder dialogue and bolster the legal framework for civic participation.
But translating pledges into action remains a challenge. Although the government of Niger rejoined EITI in February 2020, just weeks later civil society actors again accused authorities of harassing and arresting activists. The authorities justified their actions citing pandemic restrictions.
In Nigeria, NRGI is working closely with our partners to help citizens confront challenges in civic space. Authorities’ repression of freedom of speech and association in recent years complicates the accountability processes fundamental to strong resource governance. It also compromises citizens’ ability to engage in needed dialogue about the country’s preparation for the energy transition. Police crackdowns on protest and social media shutdowns during the pandemic meant that citizens were largely in the dark as government oil revenues declined. Late last year one of the most vocal civil society organizations, CISLAC, endured unwarranted harassment. Frontline reformists and advocates feel threatened with the marked fall of Nigeria’s performance in the World Press Freedom Index. Combined with the closure of internationally supported programs providing funding and technical support to oil-sector reform, this shrinkage in civic space risks foreclosing public dialogue on Nigeria’s economic future—which is more essential now as the energy transition gains momentum.
Charting a path forward
NRGI and our partners are reconceptualizing our work to advance resource governance in increasingly constrained and politically hostile environments. Together with Publish What You Pay (PWYP), Oxfam America, the International Center for Not-for-Profit Law and the Institute for Development Studies, we recently explored how we might adapt our objectives and approaches, brainstormed new strategies for protecting civic space, and examined the challenges associated with a just energy transition.
Building on these discussions and lessons learned, NRGI seeks to evolve its work to advance civic space and resource governance efforts in the following ways:
- Build more effective and diverse coalitions. Internal conflicts are hampering many existing coalitions. Resolving them, although no easy task, would make them more effective and less vulnerable to government backlash. In NRGI priority countries, we will work with PWYP and others to invest in dispute resolution, replicate models of successful coalitions, and encourage the diversification of coalition membership. Critical to this work will be more effective analysis of political economy, as we have undertaken in Nigeria, to identify the points of influence and actors to leverage amid closing civic space. We will also support and equip our partners to engage in and contribute to national debates on emerging topics related to just transition.
- Connect actors across country, regional and international dialogues. Authoritarian regimes are replicating their playbook across countries. We will in turn seek to connect advocacy across countries, for greater collaboration and impact, specifically to strengthen negotiation opportunities for lower-income countries in the context of the energy transition. One immediate task is to define and effectively advance a just transition agenda for resource-rich countries, and ensure that national agendas influence global climate action. We will engage more in relevant international forums like climate COPs, working with global partners and facilitating participation from civil society organizations of resource-producing countries.
- Support the translation of policy into effective practice. Where strong policies exist to protect civic space, we will use our influence and that of our partners to ensure strong implementation. For example, we will use our role on the EITI international board to push for a stronger implementation of the civic space protocol. We will also support the establishment of the OGP Civic Space Learning Network.
- Call out kleptocratic regimes and practices that enable them. We will leverage the global attention on Russia to call out the risks of seeking fossil fuels from other autocratic regimes. We will support calls for divestment to result in economic opportunities for democratic and reform-minded states. In parallel, we will advocate strengthening safeguards to ensure that economic opportunities related to critical minerals for the energy transition do not reinforce autocratic regimes.
To support these efforts, we call on a range of actors to take action:
- Bilateral and philanthropic foundation funders should strengthen long-term plans to support capacity development and coalition-building efforts, seeking to reinforce existing mechanisms for dialogue and participation—not creating new competing platforms.
- Multi-stakeholder initiatives like EITI and OGP should commit to more efficiently translating their standards into implementation; and to enforcing the standards they set—even in tough cases.
- Extractive sector and energy companies should speak up and support the protection of civic space, which is key to positive economic outcomes.
- Investors should strengthen criteria related to civic space protection in their business decisions, and encourage companies and governments to ensure the protection of civic space as essential to environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations and a positive investment climate.
- International financial institutions should make greater use of their lending power to call for action to support civic space.
Civic space remains the cornerstone of resource governance and essential to the pursuit of more sustainable and equitable societies. Together with our partners, NRGI is committed to making the necessary pivots to respond to evolving civic space challenges.
Can African Oil and Gas Benefit From Europe’s Energy Crisis?
This commentary originally appeared in African Arguments on 29 March 2022 under the title "Will Africa Really Be ‘Europe’s Next Gas Station'’’?
These shifts, combined with Western oil and gas companies dumping their Russian interests, present an opportunity to other petroleum producing countries, albeit one tempered by actions to address the climate crisis. This has led governments and commentators to discuss African producers as potential beneficiaries of Europe’s supply gap, with talk of a “seismic shift” to Africa and of the continent as “Europe’s next gas station”.
Such headlines gloss over the complex reality. It is true that several established producers – such as Algeria, Angola, and Nigeria – are already reaping higher revenues from soaring oil and gas prices. Countries with projects due to start within the next year or so, such as Mauritania and Senegal, will likely also benefit from higher prices. However, most current producers have limited spare capacity to quickly ramp up supply and need to attract more investment before they can.
Investment decisions on key liquefied natural gas (LNG) projects in prospective producers, such as in Mozambique and Tanzania, are not likely until at least 2024 given security challenges in the former, and ongoing negotiations and outstanding project design processes in the latter. This means significant production is unlikely before 2030. Most of Mauritania and Senegal’s oil and gas reserves won’t be developed until later project phases. And any supply from prospects currently under exploration is likely even further off. It has historically taken sub-Saharan countries around 12 years to move from discovery to production – often longer than initially predicted by governments and companies.
While some African projects may come online more quickly, investors will make decisions based on an uncertain long-term outlook. The current spike in prices is a potent reminder of the fundamental unpredictability of oil and gas markets. Seven years on from the price spike in 1979, rates had fallen more than two-thirds from the peak of the crisis.
Three factors make the current outlook particularly uncertain. First is Russia’s role in the oil and gas market. Its supply to Europe will be affected by how its negotiations with Ukraine unfold, as highlighted by how prices have fluctuated in line with perceptions of how the talks are progressing. Russian supply earmarked for Europe could be diverted to Asian markets in the long term. This would reduce Asian demand for gas from elsewhere and offset the benefit of increased European demand for oil and gas from these producers.
The second factor is how much market share other non-African producers capture. Europe is not only looking to Africa to fill the gap. US LNG exports to Europe are surging, multiple additional large US LNG projects are ready for development, and European leaders are striking long-term deals in the Middle East. Many of these producers have more spare capacity and projects that can be greenlit more quickly than African producers.
Third, prospective suppliers must consider potential “demand destruction” and the pace of the energy transition. A lesson from the 1970s is that high prices and market turmoil often lead to a permanent reduction in demand through improvements in energy efficiency and development of alternative technologies. The current crisis could lead to even greater demand destruction given it appears to have reinforced Europe’s conviction to accelerate its energy transition away from fossil fuels. Beyond its goal to secure non-Russian supplies in the short-to-medium term, the EU also aims to leave fossil fuels behind for good.
What African and European officials can do?
Leaders in both Europe and Africa can take steps to make this moment more of an opportunity for Africa.
The EU could begin by clarifying its energy transition strategy for the benefit of African producer countries and potential private investors. Thus far, its pathway has been a minefield of mixed messages. For example, its plans announced in February 2022 to label some kinds of gas-fired power as “green” was seen by some producer countries as a signal to move ahead with gas projects. However, some European leaders seem to increasingly view renewables as not only necessary to tackle the climate crisis but also to improve energy security.
As Europe seeks to expand its use of clean energy, it should ensure that African producers of the critical mineral inputs to green tech receive good and fair deals.
To ensure a globally equitable transition, Europe should consider meeting any longer-term demand first with petroleum from African countries, given their pressing development needs. Europe could also champion the inclusion of incentives for good governance in the sequencing of the global phase out of fossil fuel production. In so doing, it should balance addressing European energy security with reducing African energy poverty as part of a broader strategy that also supports African countries’ own transitions to clean energy. Finally, as Europe seeks to expand its use of clean energy, it should ensure that African producers of the critical mineral inputs to green tech receive good and fair deals.
Irrespective of how Europe proceeds, officials in existing and prospective oil and gas producing Africa countries should soberly evaluate the longer-term uncertainties. While prices are soaring now, this unpredictability includes the possibility of fewer supply opportunities and lower prices over time.
Governments should ensure that strong revenue management frameworks are in place, including by directing any windfall revenue toward sustainable development and economic diversification. Diversifying economies remains crucial. Governments should also rigorously analyse their prospects across different scenarios, factoring in project timelines and potential market evolutions. They must remain cautious and avoid using public capital to make risky bets on oil and gas.
While some African producers may benefit from Europe’s scramble for non-Russian oil and gas, the reality is unlikely to match the hype.
How to Stop Oil Companies From Propping Up Kleptocrats
Divestments by these Western oil companies contribute to the crisis now facing Russia’s oil and gas sector, one of the largest in the world. Even in the absence of sanctions on energy exports, oil companies as well as commodity traders, insurance providers, banks, and other industry players are backing away from the country. This leaves Russia without buyers for its crude oil and has sent the stock value of Russian oil companies plummeting. In the longer term, divestments could delay key projects, such as the ExxonMobil-operated Sakhalin oil and gas fields, and deprive the industry of the financing and technology it needs to sustain its growth...
Read the full commentary.
Gillies subsequently spoke on a related topic to National Public Radio (U.S.):
Gillies also addressed a related topic in this short documentary by VICE News:
The Russia-Ukraine war has led to a range of new challenges and opportunities for developing countries rich in oil, gas and minerals.
NRGI Statement on Russian Invasion of Ukraine
NRGI stands in solidarity with our Ukrainian partners and the citizens of Ukraine in the face of the ongoing invasion by Russian forces. The assault is especially appalling given the progress that Ukraine and its people have made toward democracy and transparency.
NRGI works with partners around the world so that citizens benefit from—and are not harmed by—natural resource extraction. It has been our privilege in recent years to collaborate with and learn from passionate advocates of transparency, integrity and accountability in Ukraine, and it is devastating to see their advances attacked and undermined. NRGI rejects all forms of violence, which undermine basic human rights and run counter to the values underpinning our vision and mission.
The crisis in Ukraine exposes once more the staggering challenges of global resource governance. Oil and gas play a central role in the unfolding war. Ukraine is in the middle of a geopolitical race to control access to extractive resources and energy. Vladimir Putin’s regime and many of its senior members depend on returns from Russia’s massive oil and gas industry—wealth acquired in part through partnerships with Western companies—and the Kremlin is using resource wealth to finance its military campaign. Europe’s dependence on Russian oil and gas has limited its options for forcefully responding to Russian aggression. The unfolding war underlines the grave costs of the world’s continued dependence on fossil fuels, and may jeopardize global efforts to accelerate the transition to cleaner energy.
We join our voice with those of our partners and colleagues around the world in condemning this war and calling for concrete action to safeguard the progress made by Ukraine in the areas of democratic consolidation and transparency.