What Happens After a Mining License Is Granted? Inside Indonesia's First Resource Governance Assessment
Indonesia is the first country assessed under NRGI's new Resource Governance Assessment. It finds strong foundations for mineral governance, alongside significant gaps between the rules, how they are implemented and what the public can see.
Just over a year after public outcry over nickel mining in Raja Ampat led the Indonesian government to revoke four of the region’s five nickel mining permits, the issue is back in the spotlight. New research published by Greenpeace Indonesia in late July reported that three nickel mining licenses are in process for eastern Waigeo, Raja Ampat’s largest island. The one permit that was not revoked, held by state-owned PT Gag Nikel, resumed operations in September 2025.
The renewed debate comes as Indonesia’s mineral resources, particularly nickel, are becoming increasingly important to global energy transition supply chains and to the country’s own downstream industrial ambitions. It is a reminder that Indonesia's mineral governance challenge is no longer simply about writing better laws or improving how mining rights are awarded. It also raises a broader question: what happens after a license is granted?
As NRGI argued in its commentary on the Raja Ampat case, the episode has exposed the gap between formal governance arrangements and their implementation in practice. Over the past two decades, Indonesia has introduced major regulatory reforms, digital licensing systems and stronger institutional frameworks for managing its mineral resources. But information about contracts, company ownership, compliance, government oversight and payments remains much harder for the public to access once mining is underway.
These questions formed part of the backdrop for the launch of Indonesia's Licensing and Taxation component of the Natural Resource Governance Institute's (NRGI) Resource Governance Assessment (RGA), in Jakarta on 5 August 2026. Developed in partnership with the Research Center for Politics and Government at Universitas Gadjah Mada (PolGov UGM), it is the first assessment published under the RGA; Chile, Senegal and Zambia will follow.
The RGA succeeds NRGI’s Resource Governance Index (RGI), but rather than ranking countries, it examines individual countries in greater depth and combines a common set of core indicators with optional ones chosen to reflect national priorities.
Opening the event, Erica Westenberg, NRGI's Governance Program Director, emphasized that the assessment is intended as a starting point for policymakers, industry, civil society and researchers to discuss where governance systems work well and where they need to improve.
Strong foundations, uneven transparency
Indonesia scores 52 out of 100 overall: 41 for licensing, 57 for taxation. But the detailed findings reveal a much more uneven picture.
Indonesia has substantially strengthened the administration of mining licenses. Digital platforms such as Minerba One Map Indonesia (MOMI), Minerba One Data Indonesia (MODI) and the Indonesia EITI Extractive Data Portal have expanded public access to concession and licensing information, and the country has established a comprehensive legal framework governing mining taxation and royalties. The assessment scores it 92 for pre-licensing processes and 100 for the rules governing taxation and royalties.
There are significant gaps elsewhere. Indonesia scores 33 for beneficial ownership disclosure and 0 for public access to mining contracts. Information on production, compliance, inspections, sanctions and license amendments is fragmented across institutions.
Taxation shows the same split. Indonesia has strong rules governing mining taxes and royalties, but public disclosure of company- and project-level payments remains limited. Payments to government score 58, while transparency around quasi-fiscal expenditures involving state-owned enterprises receives a score of 0.
Indonesia's taxation score is lower than the 84 it received in NRGI's 2017 Resource Governance Index, but the two are not directly comparable: the earlier RGI covered oil and gas as well as minerals and used a different methodology, with less ambitious criteria for good practice. The difference should not be read as evidence that Indonesia's taxation governance has deteriorated.
Indonesia's next phase of reform is less about creating new rules than implementing existing ones consistently and expanding public access to information.
What do the findings mean in practice?
At the launch, participants took the findings further.
Aryanto Nugroho, national coordinator of Publish What You Pay Indonesia, connected the findings to Indonesia's downstreaming agenda. While much of the policy debate focuses on downstreaming, he pointed out that it depends on what happens upstream, including how mining rights are governed.
Elvita Trisnawati researcher at the Indonesia Center for Environmental Law (ICEL) described what the findings mean for communities. Licensing procedures have become more transparent before permits are issued, she said, but once mining begins communities can still struggle to access information about compliance, environmental monitoring and government oversight.
Both point to the same issue. Without transparency after licenses are awarded, it is harder for communities to see how mining is governed or who benefits from it.
Where reform could focus next
Participants also challenged the assessment itself. Beneficial ownership was one area of debate, with some arguing that recent implementation efforts may not have been fully reflected in the findings, and questioning whether data collection had captured developments across relevant agencies.
The RGA is designed to invite this kind of debate. Its findings are an evidence base for governments, civil society, industry and researchers to examine and challenge, not a set of fixed conclusions.
Indonesia already has substantial digital infrastructure in place. Connecting MOMI, MODI and SIMBARA with beneficial ownership and revenue information would make it possible to follow the chain from license allocation and ownership through production, taxation and revenue collection, and would extend public accountability across the mining lifecycle.
The renewed attention to mining in Raja Ampat shows why implementation of the legal framework and public access to information matter. This first assessment sets out where Indonesia's mineral governance is strong and where it is not. Further components will examine revenue management, socio-environmental impacts and the energy transition.
Read the Indonesia Assessment
Where Indonesia's mining governance is strong, where it falls short, and what the scores mean in practice.
Still Have Questions About the RGA?
Common questions on scoring, methodology and how the RGA differs from the Resource Governance Index.
RGA Indonesia — Licensing and Taxation in the Minerals Sector
Resource Governance Assessment
Indonesia has strengthened the legal foundations of mineral licensing and taxation, but governance remains uneven once mining operations begin. This is the first country assessment published under NRGI's new Resource Governance Assessment (RGA) framework — measuring not just what the law provides for, but what happens in practice.
Overall licensing and taxation score
Licensing 41/100·Taxation 57/100
Two decades of reform have built a strong foundation. Digital platforms including Minerba One Map Indonesia, Minerba One Data Indonesia and the Indonesia EITI Extractive Data Portal have significantly improved public access to licensing and concession data.
Transparency drops sharply once licenses are awarded. Mining contracts are not publicly disclosed, beneficial ownership data is incomplete and confidentiality provisions still block company- and project-level tax and royalty disclosure.
The next phase is implementation, not new legislation. Indonesia has a strong legal and regulatory foundation. The priority now is to apply existing rules consistently and expand the information available to the public.
Licensing — 41/100
Indonesia has made major gains in licensing administration, particularly before licenses are awarded. Digitalization and centralized systems have improved consistency and access to information. But transparency weakens once mining begins, particularly around contracts and beneficial ownership.
Detailed score breakdown (7 indicators)
Indonesia has built strong systems for allocating licenses, but public accountability has not developed at the same pace once mining operations begin.
Taxation — 57/100
Indonesia has a comprehensive framework for mining taxation and royalties, but public visibility over how revenues are paid, enforced and transferred is much weaker. Company- and project-level payments remain largely confidential and transparency around some SOE financial flows is particularly limited.
Detailed score breakdown (10 indicators)
Indonesia scores 100 for its taxation rules, but much of the information needed for independent scrutiny of revenue collection and SOE financial relationships remains unavailable.
Recommendations
Indonesia has made significant progress in strengthening governance of the mineral sector through regulatory reform, digitalization and institutional modernization. Future reforms should build on these achievements by improving implementation and expanding public access to information across the mining value chain.
Expand disclosure beyond license allocation to contracts, production data, environmental monitoring, inspections, sanctions, permit amendments, suspensions and license revocations. Build on existing platforms such as MOMI, MODI and the Indonesia EITI Extractive Data Portal to provide a more complete picture of mining activities from license allocation through mine closure.
Strengthen beneficial ownership implementation through better verification, higher-quality data, stronger enforcement and free public access to information. Increase disclosure of company- and project-level tax and royalty payments in line with domestic legal reforms and international transparency standards.
Strengthen interoperability among MOMI, MODI, SIMBARA, beneficial ownership registries, revenue reporting systems and SOE disclosures so stakeholders can trace the chain of accountability from license allocation and ownership through production, taxation and revenue distribution.
Standardize reporting of dividends, capital injections, guarantees, subsidies and quasi-fiscal expenditures to improve public understanding of how state resources are allocated and managed.
About this assessment
This is the first assessment published under NRGI's Resource Governance Assessment (RGA) framework, produced in partnership with the Research Center for Politics and Government at Universitas Gadjah Mada (PolGov UGM). It covers licensing and taxation in Indonesia's mineral sector; assessments of revenue management, socio-environmental impacts and the energy transition will follow.
Data collection ran from July 2025 to February 2026, drawing on laws, regulations and policies issued through December 2025, with external review from the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (EITI Indonesia Secretariat) and Publish What You Pay Indonesia (PWYP-Indonesia Secretariat).
Read the full RGA FAQ for more on methodology and how findings can be used.
What the findings mean in practice
Indonesia’s first RGA reveals significant transparency gaps after licenses are awarded. Read our analysis of what this means in practice.
Introducing the Resource Governance Assessment: A Redefined Tool for a New Era
How countries govern their oil, gas and mineral wealth defines whether those resources build inclusive, resilient and prosperous societies, and support just energy transitions—or if they deepen inequality, conflict and instability. This challenge has rarely been more urgent: inequality is accelerating, geopolitical realignment is reshaping global supply chains and demand for critical minerals is surging. All of this raises the stakes for resource-rich countries, their people and the world at large.
This year, as NRGI marks its 20th anniversary, we are launching the Resource Governance Assessment (RGA), a new framework providing a comprehensive, independent understanding of governance across the mining, oil and gas decision chains. Built for governments, civil society, oversight institutions and others, it helps identify where governance is working, where gaps remain and where change is most needed.
Why a new assessment?
Resource governance has changed significantly over the past two decades. In the past, debates centered on revenue management, taxation and transparency. Today, the lens is much wider. Resource-rich countries are making decisions across a range of interlinked spaces that will shape their economies for decades—from approving new mining or extraction projects, to deciding how revenues are spent, to determining how communities share in the benefits and how the energy transition reshapes their prospects.
These changes demand a different kind of assessment. The RGA provides a shared evidence base for informed decision-making across multiple, linked areas of resource governance, designed to support change. Governments can use the findings to strengthen laws, policies and institutions. Civil society and oversight bodies can support accountability and advocacy with credible facts, while companies, investors and development partners can better understand governance risks and opportunities for engagement.
The RGA builds on the legacy of NRGI's Resource Governance Index (RGI), published in 2012, 2017 and 2021. Assessing extractive governance across dozens of countries, the RGI established a global evidence base and encouraged governments to strengthen policy and practice. But as governance challenges became more complex, a single global index, tied to a specific point in time could no longer capture the full picture.
The RGA responds with a more flexible, country-specific framework.
The RGA: a closer look
The RGA is designed to provide a complete and practical assessment of resource governance. It does this in four ways.
Comprehensive
The RGA examines governance across four components that together span the resource decision chain:
- Licensing and taxation
- Revenue management
- Socio-environmental impacts
- Energy transition
Together, these components provide a more complete picture of how natural resources are governed, from awarding licenses to protecting communities and managing for the energy transition. Every assessment includes a common set of core indicators, alongside optional indicators, providing both a consistent foundation across assessments, as well as the ability to tailor the RGA to specific circumstances.
Country-specific
The RGA is a country-specific assessment, allowing it to respond to national priorities and be carried out when it can have the greatest impact, such as during policy reforms, election cycles, or major resource or investment decisions. Optional indicators also allow each assessment to reflect the country's context and specific governance targets, making findings more relevant and useful.
Because countries are assessed at different times and can include country-specific indicators, the RGA is not intended as a ranking or league table. Comparisons remain possible for indicators consistent with previous editions of the RGI, but the RGA's purpose is to support practical action in each country.
Collaborative
Stakeholder engagement also plays a much greater role in the RGA than it did in the RGI. Consultations take place when indicators are selected and again when preliminary findings are shared with key stakeholders for review. Governments and other stakeholders can also submit additional public documentation before assessments are finalized. This strengthens the process, builds confidence in the findings and helps ensure they can inform policy going forward.
Evidence-based and transparent
Every finding rests on publicly available evidence, assessed against a published methodology. Like the RGI, the RGA measures the gap between the legal framework (“law” indicators) and actual practice (“practice” indicators). This shows not only where strong rules exist, but whether they are effectively implemented and where reform is needed to make a real difference.
Looking ahead
The first RGA assessment, covering Indonesia's licensing and taxation component, will be published in the coming weeks, with the remaining three components for Indonesia to follow. Assessments for Chile, Senegal and Zambia will be published over the coming months, with additional countries to follow over time.Like resource governance itself, the RGA will continue to evolve. New optional modules, including one on value addition, are already being developed to ensure the framework remains relevant as new challenges emerge.
As the choices facing resource-rich countries grow even more complex, the need for credible, independent evidence will only grow. The RGA is designed to meet that need, turning evidence into dialogue, decisions and lasting change.
Everything you need to know about the RGA
Explore the methodology, assessment process and more in our frequently asked questions.
Tax Avoidance, Tax Evasion and Trade Misinvoicing: Risks to Senegal’s Mining Sector
Key messages
- Tax evasion, trade misinvoicing and multinational companies’ efforts to avoid tax are important risks in the extractive sector, especially in developing countries, including Senegal.
- Senegal’s extractive governance arrangements are strong in many areas, including in preventing multinational tax avoidance.
- However, there is cause for concern in two areas: misinvoicing of international trade (imports and exports), and cost inflation by subcontractors in the extractive industries. Quantitative estimates of trade misinvoicing suggest the former is a significant problem for Senegal (including for its mining sector), which could lead to the loss of 1–3 percent of the country’s tax revenues.
- Authorities in Senegal should address such risks, especially before the country begins large-scale oil and gas production. Unless they do so, revenues from the country’s hydrocarbon resources will be at risk.
- Measures that Senegal can take include strengthening the tax authorities—especially customs and auditing accounts of extractive industry suppliers.
Senegal’s extractive industries could provide 8–9 percent of state revenues until 2030. But efforts by companies or individuals to dodge their tax responsibilities could reduce the contribution the sector makes. Evidence suggests, for example, that multinational corporations shift around 35 percent of their profits to tax havens. This problem affects the extractive industries and is particularly acute in developing countries such as Senegal.
Flows of funds linked to corruption, illegal mining, money laundering and avoiding regulations can also undermine resource-rich countries’ ability to benefit from their extractive industries. Senegal appears to be significantly affected by these problems. Various estimates have suggested that the country could be losing 1-12 percent of its tax revenues each year, due to various types of the illicit financial flows mentioned above, with a significant share linked to the mining sector. The wide range of estimates underscores the need for better data.
This report includes estimates of Senegal’s tax revenue losses due to trade misinvoicing (false customs declarations): losses of USD57 million to $153 million (1–3 percent of tax revenues) depending on the method used, with a substantial share linked to the mining sector. If reclaimed, these amounts could be large enough to double the size of Senegal’s cash transfer support program for households.
How do such losses occur? Though Senegal’s tax system is strong in many ways and officials have high capacity for overseeing the taxes of mining companies, there are still weaknesses. For instance, Senegal could strengthen coordination and information sharing between the tax department and the Ministry of Mines. The country may also need to acquire more capacity to audit oil and gas companies for tax purposes, including through hiring geologists. In addition, Senegal may be losing tax revenues due to trade misinvoicing.
Gold exports to the United Arab Emirates appear to be particularly affected, although by themselves they would account for a minority of the tax revenue losses that Senegal experiences. According to the country’s national statistical agency, another major source of tax losses in the extractive industries is the under-declaration of the value of minerals, where these are processed in Senegal by the mining company (or a part of the same group). A further potential area of vulnerability is subcontractors in the extractive industries. When subcontractors based abroad supply extractive companies in Senegal from the same multinational group, the subcontractors can be used to inflate costs. Such subcontractors capture a substantial share of gross revenues from the extractive sector and can benefit from tax treaties that allow them to avoid taxes.
The Senegalese authorities should also remain vigilant to the risks of tax treaty abuse, given that several multinational companies operating in the extractive industries benefit from tax treaties that Senegal has signed with other countries (either directly, or indirectly via bilateral investment treaties). This report identifies a number of policies to address these problems. For example, it recommends that Senegal’s government and parliamentarians strengthen the country’s tax authority (Direction Générale des Impôts et des Domaines) with more personnel, and remain vigilant to the risks posed by tax treaties and bilateral investment treaties. To the Direction Générale des Impôts et des Domaines, the report recommends that officials improve co-ordination between the tax authority and the Ministry of Mines, and information sharing with customs authorities of Senegal’s trading partners, to help prevent trade misinvoicing.
2013 Resource Governance Index