Illegal Gold Mining: A Growing Threat to the Peruvian Amazon
Illegal gold mining has become one of the biggest threats to the Peruvian Amazon and important region to the world because of its role in regulating the climate and its extraordinary biodiversity. This illicit activity is expanding rapidly across several departments in the region, including Loreto, Madre de Dios, Amazonas, Huánuco and San Martín, and has already affected more than 30 districts in the country.
Distinguishing informal mining —which is undergoing a legal formalization process, from illegal mining—which operates entirely outside the law, often operating in prohibited areas using toxic substances and disregarding environmental and safety regulations—is crucial.
A highly profitable but deeply destructive activity
Illegal gold extraction is an extremely lucrative business. A single dredge can generate over USD 135,000 per month, which explains the rapid growth of this illicit trade. However, behind this profitability lies a trail of increasingly severe environmental, social, cultural and economic destruction.
In recent years, the situation has particularly worsened in Loreto, Peru’s largest department, whose geography facilitates the expansion of illegal mining along its rivers. While oil extraction was historically the main economic driver in Loreto, illegal mining has shown steady growth, fueled by rising gold prices, weakened territorial control and unclear formalization policies.
Today, much of this activity is concentrated in the Nanay River basin, one of Loreto’s five major watersheds and the main water source for its capital, Iquitos. By the end of 2024, 210 dredges were operating there out of the 280 identified across the department.
Criminal networks and weakened state control
Illegal mining in Loreto is not an isolated activity. It is closely linked to broader criminal networks and other illegal economies controlled by transnational criminal organizations. These groups influence public decision-making through political pressure, media manipulation and corruption.
Between 2021 and 2024, 25 legislative bills related to informal mining were submitted, 23 of which promoted the deregulation of the sector and weakened the state's ability to control it. While Loreto has not yet experienced full state capture, there are growing concerns that certain private interests are shaping public policies to their advantage.
Impact on communities
The expansion of illegal mining impacts local populations and Indigenous communities directly. While some communities maintain effective territorial control and denounce illegal activities, others have become involved, either by providing labor or by offering support services.
This creates internal tension, weakens social cohesion and fosters economic dependence on illicit activities.
An urgent challenge, a possible opportunity
Loreto faces a significant challenge. However, there is still an opportunity to reverse the situation and strengthen governance across its territories. This requires firm commitment from the Government, national institutions, clarity in formalization policies, and substantial improvements to monitoring and enforcement mechanisms.
The future of Loreto—and of the Peruvian Amazon—must be based on sustainable development that respects life, the rights of communities and the integrity of ecosystems.
Amazonia: challenges and threats
Would you like to learn more about the extraction of hydrocarbons and the illegal mining of gold in the Peruvian Amazon?
Transforming Natural Resource Governance: Break Silos, Sharpen Politics
The political dimensions of natural resource governance are more prominent than ever. Rising threats to democracy, including surging populism, repression of civil society, and shifts in global power form an intimidating backdrop. This context will affect the levers of change that those seeking to promote effective natural resource governance must use. At the same time, there are opportunities to seize, including a growing global consensus of the imperative to address the climate emergency and state capture, and decolonize development by ending the systemic injustices and racism that plague the extractive sector.
To address these political challenges and capitalize on these opportunities, the natural resource governance community must evolve. We need to deepen and broaden coalitions at the local, national, regional, and international levels. We need to be politically savvier. We need to examine different ways of collaborating; consider merging efforts and institutions; and recognize when it is best to lead, follow the leadership of others, or move beyond the traditional single-leader model.
Confronting geopolitics and state capture
Meeting the twin objectives of defending gains and advancing resilient and sustainable governance of natural resources requires navigating geopolitical realities and political economy considerations. In an environment of intensified competition for natural resources, where gains made on transparency, civic space, and governance standards are under threat, the natural resource governance field must more proactively and effectively engage key geopolitical players. China serves as a case in point. China’s significant demand for natural resources, increasing presence in resource-rich countries, and dominance in the global rare earth minerals market show its prominence and centrality in the global natural resource governance space. Participants at the dialogue identified China as a priority actor for engagement.
Several participants noted that while China has often dominated the conversation (in large part due to its outsized role in global supply chains), those conversations have been about China rather than with China-based stakeholders. Dialogue participants called for adding another, newer dimension to engagement with Chinese standards and with Chinese stakeholders: in particular, more engagement with the Chinese government and company representatives in countries where they are extracting. Participants suggested that adding to the existing mix a new approach encouraging transparency and accountability on reputational or business grounds could be more effective for improving natural resource governance than a normative, moralistic one. Another key shift in perspective is to see the geopolitics from an Asian vantage, not just a US-EU-UK centric lens.
More generally, to appropriately analyze the interaction between corruption risks, political economy, and governance issues, a number of participants emphasized the need to understand and diagnose state capture—a pervasive form of high-level political corruption whose dynamics vary across settings. This may help transparency and accountability activists and reform agents to clearly identify obstacles to economic diversification, energy transition, and effective and equitable public health measures. Moving forward, implementing radical transparency in both industry (including state-owned enterprises) and government regarding natural resources and climate and environmental risks; eliminating tax loopholes, subsidies and bailout handouts for the fossil fuel industry; and advancing political finance reforms and reviewing the role and responsibilities of the U.S. oil majors in international initiatives such as the EITI must be priorities.
Combating repression of civil society
The pandemic has provided ample opportunity for states to abuse COVID-19 related restrictions to ramp up internet surveillance and restrict freedoms of assembly, association, and expression. As a result, many transparency and accountability advocates face increasing safety concerns. Yet, some international NGOs are struggling to maintain access to and political cover for these local actors.
New action within the natural resource governance field is needed to reinforce at-risk actors. While civil society actors often bear the brunt of risks for engaging with government, investors, IFIs, the G7, and G20, there must be a shared responsibility for protecting these activists by calling out bad actors and leveraging the power of investors, states, institutions, and corporations as appropriate. Political support should come from a wide range of groups at both the local and international levels, and from those with the power to influence government behavior.
Growing the coalition and strengthening alliances
COVID-19 has broadened the gap between groups operating on the local level and those functioning on a national or international level. Even before the pandemic, divides between local civil society organizations and national or international NGOs perpetuated the idea that policy discussions are high-level, technical exchanges between public officers and professionalized institutions.
Many participants expressed concern that the natural resource governance community has not done enough to collaborate across strategic vertical alliances within the natural resource governance field and horizontal alliances with other fields and movements. On the former, actors in the field believe that IFIs, local civil society organizations, national and international NGOs, and governments must unite on common objectives and improve information-sharing channels. On the latter, international and national groups must also find ways to engage more effectively with on-the-ground social movements such as those on human rights, gender, taxes, and climate in order to create a lasting change that is informed by and helps meet the needs of locally led, broad-based coalitions. Rather than co-opting those movements, natural resource governance actors should complement broader movements that will have spillover benefits for good governance of natural resources.
Advancing the agenda ahead
Throughout this three-part series, we have highlighted some of the trends, challenges, and opportunities that researchers, activists, and policymakers may examine to reimagine the sector. The call is to be clear and bold. Timid efforts and insufficient focus risk decreasing the effectiveness and credibility of the natural resource governance field.
Read the first two entries in this series here and here. Share your thoughts on these and other issues related to the future of natural resource governance on Twitter using #FutureOfNRG and participate in our survey on natural resource governance priorities.