The 35 × 35 Electrification Target is a Minerals Target Too
On Day Four of COP31 in Antalya, electrification is one of the biggest conversations. But while the focus is on the target, there's an important aspect that is currently being overlooked—the link with critical minerals.
Patrick Stephenson, Ghana Country Manager at NRGI says:
"The COP31 presidency wants electricity to meet 35% of the world's energy use by 2035, and we are hearing that the EU and others are pushing to make that clean electrification. For now, we understand this is likely to be a voluntary target, and around 20 countries are preparing to make public commitments.
But too few people are asking what this target depends on. The answer is minerals.
Clean electricity is mineral-hungry. Every grid, battery and solar panel depends on copper, lithium, cobalt and nickel.
Many of these minerals come from developing countries. So the question is whether people in those countries can truly, and fairly, benefit from the wealth below their soil, or if they will once again bear the costs of extraction while others capture the value.
At COP30, minerals entered the negotiations for the first time. Then they were stripped from the final text. We can't let that happen again.
So we're calling for three things. First, COP31's electrification outcomes should recognize that the target depends on critical minerals. Second, the new Just Transition Mechanism should be designed to support fair, transparent mineral value chains in producer countries. And third, all of this should lay the groundwork for a minerals compact at COP32 in Addis Ababa, as the Chair of the African Group of Negotiators has called for.
Electrification can be a driver for just energy transitions in mineral-rich developing countries. But that won't happen by accident. Let's recognize that and work to ensure that this mineral boom is different to those of the past."
Communiqué Issued Following the Policy Dialogue on “The Role of NNPC in Nigeria’s Energy Transition” Held at Abuja Continental Hotel, Abuja, on Thursday, 8 October 2026
Background
On 8 October 2026, the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI), in collaboration with the Centre for Petroleum, Energy Economics and Law (CPEEL) at the University of Ibadan, the Centre for Energy, Finance and Development (CEFD), and the Inclusive and Sustainable Development Research Centre (ISDRC), convened a policy dialogue on “The Role of NNPC in Nigeria’s Energy Transition” in Abuja.
The dialogue examined a fundamental policy challenge facing Nigeria. NNPC Limited is expected to support increased petroleum production, strengthen domestic energy security and contribute to government revenues, as a commercially oriented company under the Petroleum Industry Act, while responding to Nigeria’s energy transition commitments. These expectations create difficult investment, governance and policy choices at a time of increasing uncertainty in global energy markets.
The dialogue followed a technical workshop held on 29 September 2026 with NNPC’s Governance, Risk and Compliance and Sustainability teams, during which the research partners presented preliminary findings and received institutional feedback. NNPC representatives acknowledged the difficulty of reconciling petroleum expansion objectives, commercial obligations, national energy security and transition commitments, while engaging constructively with the strategic options presented.
The subsequent dialogue brought together representatives of NNPC Limited, the Nigerian Upstream Petroleum Regulatory Commission, the National Council on Climate Change, the Rural Electrification Agency, the Presidential Task Force on Power Sector Reset and Restoration, research institutions, civil society organizations and other stakeholders.
Objective
The dialogue sought to advance an evidence-based assessment of NNPC’s role in Nigeria’s energy transition and identify practical institutional, investment and policy measures that could support commercially credible decisions consistent with national development priorities.
Specifically, it examined the implications of alternative investment strategies for NNPC and the wider economy, the viability of existing oil and gas ambitions under changing market conditions, opportunities for diversification, and the governance and institutional reforms required to reconcile the company’s commercial mandate with wider public policy objectives.
The engagement was designed to inform the finalization of collaborative research by CPEEL, CEFD and ISDRC and provide a basis for further institutional consideration of the findings and dissemination of NRGI’s relevant evidence-based research.
Key Issues from the Deliberations
Following the research presentations and discussions, the following issues emerged as priorities for further institutional consideration.
1. NNPC’s commercial mandate and national policy expectations require clearer alignment
The dialogue highlighted the difficulty of reconciling government expectations for increased petroleum production with NNPC’s commercial responsibilities and Nigeria’s energy transition commitments. Participants recognized that these objectives cannot be addressed through NNPC’s investment decisions alone. Clearer government policy direction, coordination across responsible institutions and explicit treatment of the costs of public policy obligations are necessary to reduce conflicting expectations and improve strategic decision-making.
2. Nigeria’s petroleum production ambitions must be tested against changing market conditions
Nigeria’s objectives to expand oil and gas production must be assessed alongside uncertainty in future demand, prices, access to finance and international climate policies. Investment decisions based principally on production targets may expose NNPC and the wider economy to financial risks if underlying market assumptions do not materialize. The research highlighted the importance of regular portfolio reviews, scenario analysis and commercial evaluation of major capital commitments.
3. Gas investments require more rigorous assessment of domestic demand and delivery prospects
Natural gas remains important to Nigeria’s power generation, industrial development and energy security objectives. However, discussions raised concerns about the gap between ambitious gas development plans and the historical performance of gas-to-power investments. Future gas projects should therefore be assessed against realistic domestic demand, infrastructure constraints, financing conditions, implementation capacity and alternative energy supply options. Gas investment priorities should reflect demonstrable economic and energy access benefits rather than production expansion alone. Alternative energy sources should be considered where gas cannot provide reliable and affordable access to electricity.
4. Energy diversification should be selective, commercially viable and consistent with NNPC’s capabilities
The dialogue recognized potential opportunities for NNPC in renewable energy, lower-carbon activities and emerging energy markets. However, diversification does not automatically create value or reduce transition risks. New investments should be assessed against commercial viability, institutional capabilities, potential partnerships and the availability of finance. Targeted partnerships and pilot investments may provide more appropriate entry points where commercial opportunities remain uncertain.
5. NNPC’s strategic choices have wider implications for Nigeria’s economy and public finances
NRGI’s transformation strategic choices report formed the basis for reflections on strategic choices for Nigeria aligned with development and climate objectives; partial or deep diversification or full industrial diversification. The economic modelling reinforced the importance of examining the national consequences of alternative investment pathways. Decisions affecting petroleum production, capital allocation and diversification may influence government revenues, employment, investment and economic growth. These implications require coordinated assessment by NNPC and the institutions responsible for fiscal policy, economic planning and national development.
6. Public policy obligations must be distinguished from commercial investment decisions
The dialogue highlighted the importance of distinguishing activities undertaken by NNPC on commercial grounds from those pursued in support of government policy objectives. As a commercial entity reformed under the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA), NNPC would benefit from clear criteria, appropriate safeguards, and transparent costing when undertaking activities outside its core commercial mandate. This is particularly relevant for major financial commitments, including securitization arrangements and refinery investments, where commercial viability, affordability, and operational capacity require careful consideration.. Participants emphasized that strong commercial discipline and effective governance are required to balance these priorities,
7. Governance, transparency and institutional coordination are central to credible transition planning
NNPC’s evolving role will depend on decisions made across institutions responsible for petroleum development, climate policy, electricity, public finance and national planning. Fragmented objectives and unclear responsibilities can weaken implementation. Participants highlighted the value of stronger coordination, transparent investment assumptions, credible oversight and mechanisms for reviewing strategic decisions as market and policy conditions change.
8. The research process demonstrated the value of direct institutional engagement
The technical consultation and policy dialogue provided opportunities for independent researchers and NNPC representatives to examine areas of convergence and disagreement. NNPC’s constructive engagement with the findings, including its recognition of the difficult balance between commercial obligations, petroleum expansion and transition objectives, reinforced the practical relevance of the research. The engagement also identified opportunities for further analysis and institutional discussion, without presuming that NNPC has formally adopted the research recommendations.
9. Clarity in objectives translates to clarity in messaging
Just transition principles and priorities should be aligned in how NNPC communicates within its borders and the larger international community. Insights from NRGI’s narrative study on the role of NNPC reveal that while NNPC and Nigerians are aligned on themes: energy access, just transition, economic prosperity, and Nigerians' concerns; access to jobs, minimization of environmental harm, etc., more needs to be done to clarify NNPC’s position and provide greater alignment with its commercial objectives under the PIA.
Priority Recommendations Ahead of the 2027 Elections and for NNPC Institutional Consideration
Drawing on the research and issues raised during the dialogue, the following actions are proposed to strengthen NNPC’s strategic planning and Nigeria’s wider energy transition governance.
1. Clarify NNPC’s role within Nigeria’s national energy transition strategy.
The Federal Ministry of Finance, the Federal Ministry of Budget and National Planning, working with NNPC Limited and the National Council on Climate Change, should establish clearer expectations for NNPC’s contribution to energy development, domestic energy security, emissions reduction and economic diversification aligned with development objectives and climate commitments. This clarity would help ensure that NNPC’s contribution remains grounded in its commercial objectives, while supporting broader government priorities only where these are appropriately aligned.
2. Undertake a structured review of NNPC’s major investment portfolio
NNPC Limited should consider a systematic assessment of its existing and proposed oil and gas investments against alternative global demand, price, financing and transition scenarios. The review should identify projects that remain commercially resilient, those requiring reconsideration and areas where capital allocation could be improved. Findings should inform future investment prioritization and risk management.
3. Assess transition risks - subject major gas investments to realistic demand and commercial stress tests
NNPC Limited, in coordination with relevant petroleum and electricity sector institutions, should strengthen the assessment of proposed gas projects against credible domestic and export demand, infrastructure readiness, financing requirements and alternative energy supply scenarios. Particular attention should be given to whether investments can deliver affordable domestic energy and sustainable commercial returns under less favourable market conditions.
4. Develop a selective and commercially grounded diversification approach
NNPC Limited, including its emerging energy businesses, should assess opportunities in renewable energy and other lower-carbon activities based on commercial viability, strategic relevance and institutional capabilities. Where opportunities are promising but uncertain, partnerships and pilot investments should be considered before major capital commitments. Clear performance criteria should guide decisions on whether to expand, modify or discontinue such activities.
5. Establish transparent arrangements for government-directed investments
The Federal Ministry of Petroleum Resources, the Federal Ministry of Finance and NNPC Limited should clarify the mandates, financing responsibilities and accountability arrangements for investments undertaken primarily to achieve public policy objectives. Where such activities impose costs or risks on NNPC, these should be explicitly assessed and appropriately reflected in government and corporate decision-making.
6. Integrate the economy-wide implications of NNPC’s strategy into national planning
The Federal Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning, the Federal Ministry of Finance and relevant energy institutions should consider the fiscal, employment, investment and economic growth implications of alternative NNPC investment pathways. This would support better coordination between national energy policy, public financial management and economic diversification planning.
7. Strengthen disclosure and accountability around major strategic investments
NNPC Limited and relevant oversight institutions should consider improved public disclosure of the strategic rationale, material assumptions, financing arrangements and expected public benefits of major investments, subject to legitimate commercial confidentiality requirements. Clearer reporting on investment performance and transition-related risks would support informed oversight and public accountability.
8. Establish a structured mechanism for continued technical engagement
NRGI, CPEEL, CEFD and ISDRC should seek further engagement with NNPC Limited and relevant government institutions to present the final research findings, consider institutional feedback and identify areas where additional analysis could inform strategic planning. Priority areas could include portfolio risk assessment, gas investment evaluation, public policy mandates and governance arrangements.
Rethinking Resilience in East Africa (COP31)
Uganda Pavilion, Blue Zone, COP31, Antalya
At COP31, the Centre for Energy, Finance and Development (CEFD) is hosting a panel on how East African countries can strengthen energy security while advancing green industrialization.
The discussion will examine the economic and fiscal trade-offs of large-scale investment in refining infrastructure, what those investments mean for energy security, and alternative ways to build energy resilience. Panelists will look at diversified fuel supply, regional trade and infrastructure, and how development finance can support industrial development on a low-carbon pathway.
The central question: how can African countries strengthen energy security while managing fiscal risks and advancing their development priorities?
NRGI’s Patrick Stephenson will speak on the panel.
Featuring NRGI’s
Patrick Stephenson
Ghana Country Manager
The Role of NNPC in Nigeria’s Energy Transition (COP31)
Nigeria Pavilion, COP31, Antalya, Türkiye
The Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPC) has a central role in Nigeria’s energy sector and economic future. As global energy markets change, the company faces important choices about its investments, commercial priorities and contribution to Nigeria’s energy transition.
Building on discussions held in Abuja in October, this COP31 session will examine how NNPC can respond to a changing global energy system while supporting Nigeria’s wider energy and development goals. It will consider opportunities for diversification, the role of national oil companies in the transition and the governance and investment decisions needed to support economically viable pathways.
NRGI Nigeria Country Manager Tengi George-Ikoli will participate in the discussion, bringing perspectives from NRGI’s research and engagement on national oil company transformation and Nigeria’s energy transition.
Featuring NRGI's
Tengi George-Ikoli
Nigeria Country Manager
Delivering Iraq’s NDC: Advancing the Energy Transition, Reducing Gas Flaring and Tracking Results (COP31)
Iraq Pavilion, Blue Zone, COP31, Antalya
Iraq’s updated Nationally Determined Contribution, submitted to the UNFCCC in November 2025, commits the country to cut greenhouse gas emissions by up to 5 percent below business as usual by 2035, and by up to 22 percent with international support. Delivering on those targets depends heavily on the oil and gas sector, including ending routine gas flaring, which burns off gas that could otherwise supply Iraq’s power plants.
This session at the Iraq Pavilion looks at how Iraq can advance its energy transition, reduce gas flaring and track progress on its climate commitments.
Laury Haytayan, NRGI’s Middle East and North Africa director, will speak on the panel.
Featuring NRGI’s
Laury Haytayan
Middle East and North Africa Director
The Energy Transition between Opportunities and Challenges: The TeraMed Initiative (COP31)
Arab League Pavilion, Blue Zone, COP31, Antalya
TeraMed is a civil society campaign calling on Mediterranean governments to reach 1 terawatt of installed renewable energy capacity by 2030, in line with the COP28 pledge to triple renewables worldwide. This session, hosted by the Arab Network for Environment and Development (RAED) at the Arab League Pavilion, looks at the opportunities and challenges the energy transition brings to the region.
Abir Yahyaoui, NRGI’s Middle East and North Africa senior program officer, will speak on the panel. NRGI has supported TeraMed since COP29 in Baku. Read more in TeraMed’s Campaign to Unlock the Mediterranean’s Renewable Energy Potential.
Featuring NRGI’s
Abir Yahyaoui
Middle East and North Africa Senior Program Officer
Electricity at the Heart of a Just Energy Transition
A Shared Regional Vision for the Future of Energy in the Middle East and North Africa
Developed by civil society partners from five countries, this roadmap sets out five shared priorities for fairer, more transparent and resilient electricity systems in the Middle East and North Africa.
Electricity is central to a just energy transition in the Middle East and North Africa. Reliable, affordable electricity supports livelihoods, essential services and economic development. How the sector is governed will shape countries’ ability to expand renewable energy, strengthen energy security and deliver benefits for communities.
This regional civil society roadmap sets out a shared agenda for electricity sector reform, identifying five priorities:
- Reforming subsidy and pricing policies to strengthen investment in electricity.
- Strengthening transparency, accountability and access to information.
- Improving governance and institutional coordination.
- Strengthening the role of civil society and the media.
- Expanding regional cooperation and electricity interconnection.
For each priority, the roadmap outlines common challenges, calls for reform and commitments by participants. It invites governments, regulators, electricity utilities, regional institutions, international partners, civil society and the media to turn these priorities into concrete policies, initiatives and partnerships.
About this roadmap
During 2025 and 2026, the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) convened stakeholders from Morocco, Tunisia, Egypt, Lebanon and Iraq to identify shared priorities for a just energy transition in the Middle East and North Africa. Four representatives from each country participated, drawn from government, civil society and the media.
Participants compared national priorities and identified electricity governance as a shared concern and a regional priority for collective advocacy and action. Civil society partners then reconvened to develop this regional roadmap. It reflects their collective priorities, informed by technical expertise and national perspectives contributed by government representatives, experts and media participants throughout the process.
The roadmap is a resource for civil society, policymakers and others working to build fairer, more resilient electricity systems across the region.
NRGI’s role was to convene and facilitate the process. The priorities, calls to action and commitments in this roadmap are the shared views of the relevant participants and do not necessarily represent the positions of NRGI.
Electrification Priorities for the Middle East and North Africa (COP31)
Blue Zone, COP31, Antalya
The COP31 Presidency has set a goal to raise electricity’s share of global final energy demand from just over 20 percent today to 35 percent by 2035. For the Middle East and North Africa, electrification could cut fuel import bills, lower energy costs and reduce exposure to oil price shocks. Whether those benefits reach people depends on governance choices about affordability, access and how power systems are run.
This session brings together civil society voices from across the region to set out their priorities for electrification. Speakers will discuss what the 35x35 goal should mean for MENA countries, both importers and producers, and what governments and international partners need to do to deliver it fairly.
Featuring NRGI’s
Laury Haytayan
Middle East and North Africa Director
Abir Yahyaoui
Middle East and North Africa Senior Program Officer
The Role of NNPC in Nigeria’s Energy Transition
Abuja, Nigeria
The Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPC) is one of the most consequential actors in Nigeria’s energy sector. Its investment and commercial decisions influence the development of the country’s petroleum and gas infrastructure and its contribution to initiatives such as the federal government’s Decade of Gas. As Nigeria seeks to expand energy access, support industrial development and advance its climate objectives, what role could NNPC play in the country’s energy transition?
The Centre for Petroleum, Energy Economics and Law (CPEEL), the Centre for Energy, Finance and Development (CEFD), the Inclusive and Sustainable Development Research Center (ISDRC) and the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) will bring together representatives from government, NNPC, civil society and the policy community to examine this question. The discussion will draw on new policy research examining where NNPC has the capabilities and commercial rationale to contribute to Nigeria’s energy transition and the institutional conditions needed for the company to play these roles effectively.
Participants will consider potential areas for NNPC’s involvement, including power-sector development, clean energy investment and new low-carbon value chains. They will also examine the boundaries of the company’s role, the responsibilities of other public institutions and the private sector, and the financing, governance and accountability arrangements needed to ensure that diversification initiatives are commercially credible and contribute to Nigeria’s wider development objectives.
Speakers
- Chinedu Igwe, Head of Sustainability, NNPC Limited
- Lanre Babalola, Chairman, Presidential Task Force on Power, Nigeria
- Patrick Stephenson, Ghana Country Manager, NRGI
- Nicolas Lippolis, Founder and Executive Director, Centre for energy, FInance and Development
- Tengi George-Ikoli, Nigeria Country Manager, NRGI
- Oluwasola Omoju, Inclusive and Sustainable Development Research Centre
Financing Nigeria’s Energy Future: Closing the Gap Between Policy Commitment and Public Investment
Abuja, Nigeria
Nigeria has set ambitious goals for renewable energy, climate action, and the broader energy transition. Yet financing has not kept pace with these commitments. Public spending remains heavily constrained, investments in renewable energy and climate-resilient infrastructure remain limited, and gaps in budget execution continue to slow progress.
The challenge is not only about how much funding is available. It is also about how Nigeria’s public finance systems work where budgeting processes are often insufficiently aligned with climate priorities, climate finance remains fragmented and difficult to track, and limited transparency around the allocation and use of energy-sector resources makes it harder to translate policy ambition into tangible outcomes.
To address these challenges, BudgIT, NRGI and the Resource Justice Network are convening the Sustainable Energy Summit 2026, themed "Financing Nigeria’s Energy Future: Closing the Gap Between Policy Commitment and Public Investment," bringing together government representatives, development partners, private-sector actors, civil society, media, and researchers to examine how energy policy commitments, public budgeting, and climate-finance flows interact.
The conversation will focus on:
- How public budgets are supporting or falling short of supporting Nigeria’s energy priorities.
- How climate-finance flows and mechanisms connect with domestic public-finance systems.
- The institutional and political-economy factors shaping investment and spending decisions.
- Opportunities to improve transparency, coordination and implementation.
- Practical pathways for translating policy commitments into better financing outcomes.
Featuring NRGI's
Tengi George-Ikoli
Nigeria Country Manager
Ahmad Abdulsamad
Nigeria Program Officer
Damilare Ogunmowo
Africa Communications Officer