Pemex and the Energy Transition: Timely Responses to Growing Threats
The energy transition requires timely and effective responses to ensure a sustainable future for everyone.
Key messages
- An energy transition that progressively phases out fossil fuels is needed to avoid climate catastrophe. Nonetheless, such a transition will harm oil-producing countries and their state-owned businesses, such as Mexico and Pemex. In the International Energy Agency’s Announced Pledges Scenario, an estimated USD 10 billion of Pemex investments would not break even. This would harm Mexican society: government revenue would fall, and Mexican businesses in the oil industry, such as those in the states of Campeche and Tabasco, would suffer.
- The energy transition is increasingly likely to result in a progressive and lasting decrease in global demand for oil. Although Mexico’s domestic oil market is significant, were Pemex to produce only to meet domestic demand, this would not sufficiently protect it or Mexico from the fall in global export demand.
- The energy transition may exacerbate what is already a difficult financial situation for Pemex. It is the world’s most indebted state oil company, with high costs in its refinery system, its labor and pension commitments, and several upstream projects. These challenges weaken the company’s position vis-à-vis the impacts of the energy transition.
- Oil extraction in Mexico has decreased over time. Despite substantial government financial support, Pemex has been unable to reverse the significant downward trend, and this is unlikely to radically change.
- Without sufficient profits, Pemex’s debt will grow. Its creditors have thus far been willing to loan it money, expecting continued government support. However, as more creditors worry about energy transition risk and decarbonize their investments, such willingness to lend is reducing. Interest rates are already rising for Pemex and likely also to increase for the Mexican government. This trend will make debt costs prohibitive for the company, trigger a spiraling of financial problems and increase the costs of government support.
The global energy transition is necessary to avoid the worst impacts of the climate crisis. However, it also brings risks for fossil fuel producer countries and national oil companies (NOCs), such as Mexico and Petróleos Mexicanos (Pemex). The International Energy Agency (IEA) estimates that if governments around the world meet the climate commitments they have set, global demand for crude oil will drop by half by 2050. This won’t be sufficient to meet the targets in the Paris Agreement, but it is concerning for oil companies and oil-producing governments.
The energy transition comes at a time when Pemex already faces challenges. Its oil production has fallen by nearly half since 2010. As a result, Mexico is today a net importer of oil products. To boost its “energy sovereignty” as defined by the Andrés Manuel López Obrador administration, and to ensure a diversified and secure oil supply, Pemex has invested significant resources in its national refinery system. The company also carries important financial labor liabilities linked to funds committed to its workers’ pensions. Considered the most deeply indebted oil company in the world, Pemex stays afloat because of substantial government support. Pemex’s debt exceeds USD 100 billion, equivalent to 5.6 percent of Mexico’s gross domestic product (GDP) for 2023.
On top of this, a significant portion of the government’s revenue comes from oil revenue. In 2023, oil revenue accounted for 15 percent of its total budgeted income. Of this total, 10 percentage points (MXN 736.56 billion) came from Pemex revenue. If we include the contribution Pemex makes to the Mexican Oil Fund, Pemex’scontribution to the country’s 2023 budget revenue is 22 percent. Nonetheless, as this report will explain, Pemex itself has reabsorbed a large portion of this contribution through financial support from the government.
These factors put Pemex in a difficult bind in facing the global energy transition. The response from Pemex and the government will be crucial for the sustainability of this state-owned enterprise. The response will equally be critical for Mexico’s public finances,6 its energy security, and the 520,000 people Pemex and its associated industries employ—especially in states like Campeche and Tabasco, where Pemex extracts most of its oil (50 percent and 41 percent of total company production respectively).
The decisions Mexico’s new government makes around Pemex will be pivotal, as will be proposals for how the company can face the enormous challenges ahead, including the energy transition risks the new administration faces. Mexico’s change of government in October 2024 represents an opportunity for citizens to demand a commitment from their political leaders to focus on the challenges Pemex faces in the context of the transition and on progress toward the country’s energy and decarbonization goals.
This report contributes to an understanding of the current situation and recommends three main focuses of discussion and action for Pemex, the Mexican government and policy-makers
Nigeria must reduce methane emissions in the oil & gas sector: NRGI
Major hurdles facing Nigeria’s methane emissions reduction – NRGI
Gas Expansion: Experts Concerned Over Potential Rise in Methane Emissions
Oil and gas companies stall on net zero plans
National Oil Companies Betting $1.2 Trillion of Public Money On Climate Catastrophe
State-run oil companies plan to spend $1.2 trillion on oil and gas projects that won’t turn a profit if humanity manages to meet the International Energy Agency’s “net zero” climate change scenario, new research shows.
The massive sum reflects an increase in potentially unprofitable hydrocarbon spending by national oil companies, when compared to similar calculations made two years ago by the Natural Resource Governance Institute. NRGI’s updated analysis, Riskier Bets, Smaller Pockets: How National Oil Companies Are Spending Public Money Amid the Energy Transition, out today, finds that while many oil-producing countries plan to invest more on extraction, they have also become more indebted.
“This concurrence of rising debt and increased willingness to spend on fossil fuel expansion is a perfect storm for both climate and economic disaster,” said David Manley, one of the report’s authors. “Either these investments turn a profit, or we manage to halt warming fast enough to avoid catastrophic and irreversible impacts. It’s one or the other. Citizens in poor countries cannot afford even worse climate impacts, and their governments cannot afford to bail out state oil producers that make bets on risky fossil fuel projects.”
Even under climate change scenarios less stringent than “net zero,” vast amounts of public funds are still at risk, the authors found. In the IEA’s “announced pledges” scenario, in which demand for oil falls to 55 million barrels a day, $425 billion of state companies’ planned investment over the next decade will be unprofitable.
“These are huge sums of money that belong to citizens, often in countries where inequality and poverty persist,” said Suneeta Kaimal, president and CEO of NRGI. “Now more than ever governments should invest seriously in plans to diversify their economies away from dependence on oil and gas production. Yet over the last two years we’ve seen national oil companies double the riskiest portions of their portfolios with plans to invest in high-cost projects.”
In a second report published today, Facing the Future: What National Oil Companies Say About the Energy Transition, NRGI reveals that only nine out of 21 NOCs analyzed have acknowledged the risks of the energy transition, with a mere four implementing transition risk assessments and five outlining concrete strategies to mitigate these risks. None of the analyzed NOCs have published “just transition plans” that would detail how they intend to support workers and communities affected by evolutions in the energy sector.
“While NOCs like Brazil’s Petrobras and Colombia’s Ecopetrol have some good practices that others could follow, most NOCs we analyzed are covered in red flags,” said Andrea Furnaro, one of the report’s authors. “National oil companies must urgently and publicly acknowledge the risks, conduct thorough risk assessments, and implement effective mitigation plans to protect public capital at risk in the context of the energy transition. Transition risk disclosure is essential to enable citizens, investors and policymakers to scrutinize NOCs’ decisions.”
NRGI’s reports, published two days before the COP28 climate conference in Dubai, build on recent findings by UNEP and climate think tanks that governments in oil-producing countries and NOCs are investing far too much public revenue in oil and gas. This overinvestment will result in the production of more than double the amount of fossil fuels than would be consistent to limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels.
“Even as governments gather to take stock of global progress this week, they still gravely underestimate the role that national oil companies must play in reaching the Paris Agreement's objectives,” said NRGI’s Patrick Heller, an author of Riskier Bets, Smaller Pockets. “Our research shows how urgent it is for governments at COP28 to face up to the reality of national oil company investment plans. They should send a strong signal that the future demands a shift away from oil and gas that is rapid as well as equitable, including with concrete commitments to support transition in low-income countries.”
For more information
Lee Bailey, Communications Director | lbailey@resourcegovernance.org | +44 (0)7823 442 954
Notes to editors
- This research will be discussed at two upcoming events open to the media:
- Underlying data as well as editable formats of the reports’ charts and graphs and data are available upon request
IEA’s Ambitious Climate Scenario Underscores Need for More Transparency on Fossil Fuel Projects
The IEA experts have articulated several dramatic milestones that would be necessary to reach this critical goal, including:
- no approvals of new oil and gas field development and no new coal mines or mine extensions by this year
- electric vehicles reaching 60 percent of global car sales by 2030
- nearly 70 percent of global electricity generation produced from solar and wind by 2050.
Given that government and industry leaders rely on IEA scenarios in their planning, many hope that these urgent targets will spur much-needed climate action.
Beyond these headline prescriptions, the IEA makes another critical point: changes brought by the clean energy transformation will be challenging to implement, so decisions must be transparent and just. As the gap grows between government and company plans for future production and the levels consistent with a Paris-compliant world, there is increasing attention on how supply-side commitments from oil-producing countries might shape net-zero ambitions. These countries face significant economic shocks as the world decarbonizes: the IEA estimates that per capita income from oil and gas in producer countries would fall by 75 percent under its new net-zero scenario. Even if the world falls somewhat short of the Paris goals, governments in these countries face the prospect of dramatically lower revenues and public assets wasted by excessive concentration in a declining sector. Against this backdrop, citizens in low- and middle-income producer countries will inevitably face major uncertainties in the race to net zero. Access to basic information about how their social and economic prospects are shifting should not be one of them.
Governments and companies must disclose more information of relevance to the billion people that live in poverty in oil- and mineral-rich developing countries, and engage impacted citizens in producer countries as core stakeholders in energy transition policy dialogues. Despite the urgency of the economic challenge they face, many fossil fuel producers have not done enough to develop strong plans for economic diversification or inclusive development in a lower-carbon future.
The allure of oil and gas has thus far been powerfully addictive. Open dialogue between governments, companies, and citizens on the role of fossil fuel production in national economies will facilitate meaningful climate action and improve the prospects of countries that remain hooked on oil and gas. Globally inclusive dialogue is also needed around which countries should reduce production first; developing and emerging market producers are already calling on wealthy countries to lead the decline.
Today, too much information that is necessary for just and effective transition discussions remains hidden from view. Increasingly, debates will center on whether specific fossil fuel projects are viable or not—from both economic and climate perspectives. In many producer countries, the decision to halt or continue one or two key projects can affect the whole economy. Project-focused transparency efforts could support a just transition by helping citizens in producer countries assess the impacts and effectiveness of divestment and economic diversification plans. Greater transparency at this level would also help citizens hold government officials, multinational decision-makers and industry executives accountable for an equitable and well-managed process.
Governments and companies should disclose the following information about fossil fuel projects:
- Exposure to climate-related financial risk. To hold governments and companies to account and determine whether continued extraction or particular project configurations are in the national interest, citizens need: information about the viability of projects and national budgets under various transition scenarios (including the IEA net zero scenario); break-even prices, reserves and potential emissions of current and pending fossil fuel projects; and price and revenue forecasts used by financial authorities. The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) encourages the governments of its 55 implementing countries to disclose information that will further public understanding and debate around issues of revenue sustainability and resource dependence, including official production, commodity price and revenue projections. In practice, however, few countries publish this information, which must change. The EITI Standard should require, rather than merely encourage, these disclosures. The Standard should also require EITI supporting and member companies to disclose their own scenarios, assumptions and projections. United States and European regulators, who are also considering this issue, should also require this project-level information of fossil fuel companies globally.
- Plans for energy transition and production. Governments in producer countries should disclose information about their project divestment (and investment) and energy transition plans, and invite public debate on these topics. Oil companies—both private and state-owned—should also disclose production, energy transition, and responsible exit plans for their projects. They should also engage with stakeholders on the social and economic impacts that project continuation, wind down, or transfer would have on host governments and communities (e.g., impacts on payments to government and local employment, timelines and decommissioning plans). Governments and companies must also disclose the contracts that govern projects so that oversight actors can assess exploration and production rights, project amendment conditions, and adherence to decommissioning and asset sale obligations. At a minimum, both government and company actors should account for how much proposed projects will cost, their carbon footprints, and whether they align with climate goals.
- Financing and subsidization of carbon-intensive projects. Countries should disclose current and proposed spending on fossil fuel projects by national oil companies, public investment in fossil-fuel linked infrastructure, and the value of tax incentives and other subsidies they provide to support fossil fuel projects. They should also disclose the impact various transition scenarios would have on the return on public investment.
- Carbon intensity of production and reserves. Officials and executives should disclose the levels of greenhouse gas emissions (scope 1 and 2 emissions) associated with a project, as well as information necessary to assess the emissions associated with the eventual burning of those fuels, including emissions made abroad after export. This information is critical for informed public debate about the climate impact of a country’s extractive activities. In addition to disclosures around current production, citizens and investors need reliable information about undeveloped fossil fuel reserves, their embedded carbon content and the costs necessary to extract them to make equitable decisions about which countries need to phase out production fastest.
- Influence of fossil fuel interests on policymaking. In some producing countries, political leaders use fossil-fuel revenues to maintain their positions and power, giving them strong incentives to continue production. In others, fossil fuel companies enjoy considerable influence over policymakers. Governments and companies should disclose information that enables accountability actors to monitor channels of influence by vested interests. This information includes the identity of politically exposed beneficial owners with stakes in extractives projects, details about industry lobbying activities and political donations, and corporate reporting on compliance with “revolving door” policies and other integrity measures.
The IEA report makes the case for decisive and immediate climate action. The many necessary steps will require complex negotiation and coordination. But extractive sector companies and governments of producing countries can rapidly implement a core set of project-level, supply-side disclosures that would enable impacted stakeholders to assess project viability and contribute to energy transition plans. Increasing production-related commitments in nationally determined contributions is a clear opportunity. Reporting entities should leverage the readymade platforms and multi-stakeholder networks offered by transparency-oriented forums like the EITI and the Open Government Partnership, and draw on the considerable thinking that already exists on many of the key technical components and data standards that would be central to such disclosures.
What remains unclear, however, is whether an actor or group will take up the mantle of making this critical transparency a global priority and realizing it. We are working with partner organizations to explore how we can jointly push global leaders to step up. With more than 50 global and regional climate-focused gatherings taking place in the next six months, culminating in COP26 in November, the time is ripe.